Two months ago, I mocked Trump’s utterly insincere proposal to buy votes by promising $5,000 handouts if Republicans were reelected.
Voters understandably ignored that proposed bribe. They knew they were paying more than $1,000 per household in higher trade taxes. That was real. Trump’s “dividend” check was fake.
And they voted accordingly.
Unfortunately, bad ideas rarely disappear in Washington. The town is filled with ambition-fueled politicians who care about buying votes more than they care about the nation’s future.
For example, Congressman Ro Khanna of California is proposing $1,700 checks. Here are some details for a report in the Hill by Ryan Karlin.
Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) on Monday proposed $1,700 refund checks to reimburse Americans for the economic impact of the Iran war. Khanna, a progressive and potential 2028 presidential contender, said on social media the checks would be sent to every American… Khanna called on Democrats to vote on his measure almost immediately after taking over the chamber. The party won a larger-than-expected House majority and campaigned on its commitment to address affordability concerns. …Khanna has been traveling the country campaigning for midterm candidates as he contemplates a presidential run. As a staunch progressive, he could fill the far-left lane in the Democratic primary field, potentially alongside another popular progressive — Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.).
My guess is that this is an utterly insincere gimmick, just like Trump’s $5K dividend scam.
And I assume the adults in the Democratic Party (I’m praying there are some) will completely ignore Khanna’s silly proposal.
But that doesn’t mean I am totally confident the idea will die. If Dems are looking for a way to signal opposition to what Trump is doing in Iran, maybe this would be their version of low-hanging fruit.
Especially since Trump would probably go along if they called it a dividend check.
Which is a good opportunity to remind readers that bipartisanship in D.C. almost always is a bad thing.
P.S. If you want more cartoons on the dangers of bipartisanship, click here and here.
P.P.S. To give you an idea of his economic illiteracy, Congressman Khanna was a big supporter of the proposed California wealth tax, an idea so radical and misguided that left-wing voters in a left-wing state in a left-wing wave election rejected it.
In my 20th Theorem of Government, I explain that bad fiscal policy (and bad fiscal results) occurs when government spending grows too fast.
On that basis you won’t be surprised to learn that Chicago qualifies. I asked ChatGPT what’s happened to government spending in that city since 2000. Here’s the answer.
Needless to say, a 49 percent inflation-adjusted increase in Chicago’s spending burden is not good news.
The Washington Post has noticed. Here are some excerpts from a recent editorial.
The larger fiscal problem is beyond dispute. Chicago’s four pension systems ended last year with $36.4 billion in unfunded liabilities. Taxpayers are scheduled to contribute a record $3.01 billion next year. This didn’t happen overnight. Chicago’s net operating budget grew nearly 40 percent from 2019 through 2025, aided by temporary federal pandemic money. The federal windfall disappeared. Most of the spending continued. Markets have already sent warnings. Earlier this year, two ratings agencies downgraded city debt, and Chicago postponed a $292 million bond sale. Pension payments and debt service consume almost 40 percent of the operating budget. …Johnson has repeatedly reached for higher taxes rather than exercising the spending restraint necessary to put Chicago on firmer footing. His latest proposal includes a new $25-a-month tax for every employee at companies with more than 125 workers. That is a peculiar way to encourage companies to employ more Chicagoans.
In an article for the Civitas Institute, Thomas Savidge was similarly pessimistic about Chicago’s fiscal policy.
…the city’s operating deficit is just the tip of the iceberg. The mass transit agencies (CTA, Metra, Pace) are also a $770 million deficit in 2026. The Chicago Public School System a $734 million budget gap… As the city’s financial situation worsens, leaders will likely turn to state policymakers in Springfield for financial support before considering bankruptcy. Illinois, however, is in no position to help. As desperation mounts, lawmakers in Illinois and Chicago have strong incentives (and precedent) to turn to federal policymakers, hoping that taxpayers in other states can bail them out. …A similar scenario occurred when New York City faced a fiscal crisis in the 1970s. During the 1960’s and 1970’s, the Big Apple chased hundreds of thousands of jobs and successful businesses out of the city with tax hikes aimed at supporting a bloated public sector. Sound familiar? …When Springfield likely returns to DC seeking additional assistance, federal policymakers must…require the state to make the deep structural changes, such as adopting a Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights Amendment like Colorado, to prevent a cycle of dependency that has Americans nationwide to pay for the irresponsibility of one state’s policymakers.
Professor Jonathan Turley tweeted about this problem.
Let’s start with a look at interest rates for the biggest cities. Lo and behold, investors demand higher returns in order to hold Chicago government debt. Shocking (actually not).
Why do investors demand higher interest rates for holding Chicago debt?
You can find the answer in this chart showing credit ratings for about three dozen jurisdictions. Look which city is easily the worst.
Chicago is at 8 and the Houston, NYC, and LA are between 2 and 2.33.
By the way, I’m extremelysurprised to see Seattle is very creditworthy? I wonder if there are rules that limit the city’s ability to incur a large pile of debt?
P.S. If you want to see how American cities rank on overall economic policy, click here, here, and here.
P.P.S. The Civitas Institute article recommended TABOR-stylespending caps for Chicago, which is very wise, but it makes me sad because the pro-spending lobbies in Colorado finally succeeded in gutting the law.
Those articles highlight elected officials who are especially sleazy and disreputable. And it isn’t an easy award to win given the low standards of politicians.
The only silver lining to that dark cloud is that I have endless material for my columns on politician humor.
Today’s column is going to be the inaugural version of a new award.
Our first recipient of the “Government Contractor of the Year Award” goes to Rodney Rosenstein. Why does he deserve an award? You’ll understand when you read some of the details from this article in the Long Beach Post.
The CEO of a local affordable housing charity was carrying $15,000 in cash and parts for his broken-down yacht when authorities arrested him at the airport in August, federal prosecutors say in new court filings. They allege Rodney Rosenstein was trying to flee across the border and maintain his luxurious life after stealing tens of millions of dollars in a lucrative fraud scheme. …Federal authorities…gave a glimpse of the extravagant life they say Rosenstein led while running a charity that claimed to lift people out of poverty through low-cost housing in Long Beach and Arizona. …Rosenstein was staying at his multimillion-dollar villa on a private peninsula in the resort town of Punta Mita, Mexico. …Nearby, Rosenstein allegedly kept his 53-foot yacht and a mistress. …federal prosecutors in Arizona allege Rosenstein and Helpful Housing stole $2.9 million in COVID relief money and $35 million in bank loans by lying about payroll expenses, creating W-2s for people who did not exist or never worked for him… Helpful Housing falsified paperwork to overcharge nonprofits and government agencies paying tenants’ rents. …his wife stayed in their seaside Huntington Beach home worth up to $5 million and their son started at a new school with tuition running north of $58,000 a year.
The late (and great) Walter Williams referred to people like Mr. Rosenstein as “poverty pimps.” They pretend to be concerned about the poor, but they use their roles as contractors or bureaucrats to line their own pockets.
In the Washington metropolitan area (where I live), we refer to the contractors as “beltway bandits.”
By the way, keep in mind that people like Mr. Rosenstein regularly contribute to the politicians who vote for wasteful programs. This is how “recycling” works in politics.
I asked ChatGPT to create a cartoon illustrating this phenomenon.
The cartoon uses Washington, DC, as an example of where this happens.
I’ve written dozens of articles about President Javier Milei’s remarkable accomplishments in Argentina.
But I’ve only mentioned President Lula da Silva of Brazil a few times.
For today’s column, let’s compare them. We’ll start with a look at some historical fiscal data for both nations (combining charts from this column and this column).
The Wall Street Journal has a report by Samantha Pearson on the rivalry between Milei and Lula. Here are some excerpts.
Argentine President Javier Milei once called his leftist Brazilian counterpart Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva “an angry communist.” Da Silva has dismissed the libertarian Argentine leader for “talking nonsense.” Their rivalry has pitted South America’s two largest economies against each other for nearly three years. Now, the two men are escalating their feud onto the global stage, backing opposing sides in Spain’s election. …Milei and da Silva are now barely on speaking terms. …Relations between Milei and da Silva have been under strain since the Argentine leader was elected in 2023.
I don’t have much interest in the personal rivalry, but I am intensely interested in the policy differences.
Specifically fiscal policy. I asked ChatGPT to summarize what has happened to both government spending and government debt under the two presidents.
Here are the results. More spending and more debt under Lula. Less spending and less debt under Milei.
Lula was elected in early 2023 and Milei was elected in late 2023, so that may explain why ChatGPT opted for 2022-2025 data.
For those interested in 2023-2026 data, here’s a screenshot directly from the IMF database.
Once again, Milei is delivering good results and Lula is driving Brazil in the wrong direction.
Though Lula just won reelection and we’ll have to see what happens in Milei’s election next year. Do people want good policy, or would they prefer to vote themselves into poverty?
Today, let’s look at how nations rank according to economic mobility, based on some new research from the Archbridge Institute.
Here’s a look at the 20 nations that have the policies and institutions that best promote social mobility. Switzerland is in first place, followed by Denmark, Norway, and the U.S.
The obvious question to ask is the factors that determine the rankings.
As you can can see, the three pillars are entrepreneurship and growth, institutions and rule of law, and education and civil society.
Which nations get the worst scores?
Some of world’s basket-case economies, such as Cuba, North Korea, and Venezuela, are not included because of inadequate data.
So the worst of the worst for social mobility is the Central Africa Republic.
I’ll close by noting that you don’t need perfect policy to be ranked highly.
Twiddling my thumbs during a six-hour delay in the Denver airport on Friday, I couldn’t help but wonder how things would be better if the U.S. had copied Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia, Germany, Switzerland, and the other nations with privatized systems for air traffic control.
So today is a good opportunity to share this video from Reason.
I wrote about this topic last year, back when there was a glimmer of hope that the so-called Department of Government Efficiency would lead to good reforms.
My hopes were predictably dashed, but that doesn’t change the fact that air travel would be safer, smarter, and less expensive if politicians no longer were playing an operational role in air traffic control.
Notice I’m not claiming that a private system would necessarily avoid technical snafus, such as the one that grounded flights this weekend.
What I am claiming is that mistakes will happen less often and that there will be a bottom-line incentive to quickly learn from any errors.
I’m not the only one to think this way. Here are some passages from an October 19 editorial from the Washington Post.
Congress has appropriated $12.5 billion for ATC modernization, and the FAA wants at least $10 billion more. In nearly all other developed countries, this funding battle is unnecessary because ATC is fully funded by user fees and operated by a separate government corporation or private nonprofit. Air safety technology isn’t dependent on unreliable legislators, the cost to taxpayers is zilch, and the conflict of interest inherent to self-regulation doesn’t exist. …So long as air traffic control remains within the FAA, the agency will be unaccountable and subject to the whims of politicians. Spinning off ATC, as 98 countries have done successfully for decades, would be good for taxpayers and, most importantly, for passenger safety.
An editorial in the Wall Street Journal last year made similar points.
Here are some key passages.
Start with outdated technology. Congress in 2003 directed the FAA to modernize its systems. Yet the NextGen overhaul isn’t set to be complete until 2030. …the FAA still uses floppy disks. …Few technicians can even repair its aging systems, some of which are more than 60 years old. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported in March that 76% of FAA systems are “unsustainable” or “potentially unsustainable,” which may have “critical operational impacts” on safety and efficiency. …Technological obsolescence is common across the federal bureaucracy because there’s no financial motive to become more efficient. FAA labor agreements also require the government to “work collaboratively” with the air traffic controller union on modernization, which can delay upgrades and divert staff from their day jobs. …the best reform would be if the U.S. followed Canada and other nations and turned air traffic over to a private nonprofit.
Amen.
The private sector responds to the needs of consumers. Politicians and bureaucrats respond to “public choice” incentives.
P.S. Not only are many other nations ahead of us with regards to the niche issues of private air traffic control, the same is true for other issue areas that have profound macro consequences.
Today’s column will also feature a disagreement, but it won’t be about the desirability (or lack thereof) for a particular economic policy.
I’ll start by recycling this chart I shared back in June. It shows that America’s Social Security retirement program has a giant (inflation-adjusted) long-run shortfall.
Now let’s look at a couple of sentences from a recent article in the Economist.
Mr Huang’s Chinese affair could go down as the most expensive shag in history. Nvidia is worth perhaps $500bn less than it was at the end of last week, which ranks this among the most costly corporate crises of all time. (The sum is greater still when you consider that the rest of the market is up.)
You may be wondering how Social Security is connected to a corporate scandal.
The answer is that the two issues are not connected.
My gripe with the article is that it asserts that the Nvidia scandal is “the most expensive shag in history” (for non-British readers, “shag” is slang for sex).
I’m sure Nividia shareholders are not happy about losing $500 billion in value, but that amount of money is trivial to the financial damage caused by another sexual scandal.
Bill Clinton’s liaison with Monica Lewinsky not only exploded into partisan warfare in Washington and impeachment by the House. It also probably blocked Social Security reform efforts. “It’s hard to rerun history,” notes Jeffrey Frankel, who was a member of President Clinton’s Council of Economic Advisers. Nevertheless, Mr. Frankel suspects that Clinton might have succeeded in reaching a deal with congressional Republicans that would have set up individual private accounts as part of a grand Social Security package. “The stars were aligned briefly – until Monica came along,” says Frankel, now at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government.
To add some background, I was very involved with the fight for Social Security reform in the 1990s. Many Republican lawmakers were strongly in favor of personal retirement accounts, as were a number of moderate Democrats on Capitol Hill.
Most important, President Clinton supported some sort of reform. And momentum was building. At the time, I knew any final deal would be well short of complete Australian-style or Chilean style reform. But it was also very apparent that we would have gotten personal retirement accounts.
But the Monica Lewinsky scandal blew up and that ended any chance for bipartisan reform (some leftists openly celebrate the scandal for just that reason).
I’ll now close by sharing another chart from my June column.
Since we don’t know what sort of deal would have emerged in the late 1990s, assuming Ms. Lewinsky never interned at the White House, we can only speculate on how much better off we would be today.
But I’m totally confident that the the benefits would be measured in $trillions rather than $billions.
Denmark, by contrast, is a free market nation that makes the mistake of having a big welfare state. But companies are private, capital is allocated by markets, and prices are set by markets.
If @Kadotttt wants to be Denmark instead of Hungary, I congratulate him.
But if he wants to be Denmark (or any other European welfare state) instead of the United States, I encourage him to read this series (see here, here, here, here, here, here, and here).
The good news is that many states in recent years have adopted full or partial choice systems, meaning schools now must focus on better performance if they want to attract and retain students.
The bad news is that the recent anti-Trump landslide means that some of these reforms may be reversed because more states are now controlled by politicians allied with teacher unions and education bureaucrats.
Here are some excerpts from a Washington Post report by Natalie Fertig and Eric Lau.
Democrats won sweeping victories at the national level on Election Day, but their victories at the state level may be even more significant for millions of Americans. Democrats have flipped 12 state legislature chambers… Democrats’ new state power will allow them to reshape housing, health care, education and child care policies. …In Texas, Democrat Gina Hinojosa shocked the country by defeating three-term incumbent Gov. Greg Abbott (R), and Democrats also flipped the state House. She has proposed ending GOP programs like the state’s new school voucher program… While Republicans still retain full control of 21 state legislatures, they lost 13 supermajorities — in some cases losing veto power over incoming Democratic governors such as Ohio Gov.-elect Amy Acton. Ohio state Rep. Gary Click (R) hoped that Republicans could make changes to expand the state’s school voucher program to include more types of schools in the next session. But he believes such legislation is “DOA now” because Republicans in the House will not have enough votes to override vetoes.
I’m especially worried about Arizona, which wasn’t mentioned in the article, but has a very strong choice system.
Given the terrible – and worsening – track record of government schools, preserving school choice should be a top priority of libertarians, classical liberals, and conservatives.
But not everyone on the right seems to agree. Oren Cass, who describes himself as part of “the New Right,” wrote a column for the New York Times that objects to the notion that education should be treated as a “marketable consumer service.”
Here are some excerpts.
Where Reaganites advocate education reform that treats schools as marketable consumer services measured by test scores and college admissions, the New Right regards public education as a communal project to equip young people with the skills and values they need to build decent lives. Where Reaganites see education primarily as a means to promote mobility, the New Right places greater emphasis on rootedness in one’s community and offers proposals such as universal vocational education that would engage young people in their local economies and help those so inclined to find family-supporting jobs closer to home.
I don’t want to sound insulting, but his arguments are incoherent. He obviously objects to choice-based systems, but that approach promotes the things he claims to value.
Cass says he wants to “equip young people with the skills and values they need to build decent lives,” but that’s a big reason why Reaganites (like me) want school choice. By contrast, the government monopoly that Cass is defending is doing a very poor job of achieving those goals.
Cass says he wants more opportunities for “vocational education,” yet Reaganites (like me) want school choice because this would end the one-size-fits-all government monopoly that currently failing to provide such options.
Cass’ column addresses many other issues, such as antitrust laws, price controls, housing, tax rates, union favoritism, trade barriers, and industrial policy. Since he favors more government in all those areas, I’m tempted to respond, but I want to keep the focus on education.
P.S. Notwithstanding what I just wrote, I can’t resist making a couple of political observations
Cass and his group (American Compass) have been viewed as pro-Trump because there is a great deal of ideological overlap. Yet Cass uses his column to distance himself from Trump.
“There is no Trumpism, however, only Mr. Trump, following instincts and impulses that hew to no identifiable ideology.”
“…the president has squandered the momentum of a decisive victory and the support of a broad-based coalition”
“…never developed new intellectual foundations, an aspirational vision or a durable governing majority.”
But I do object to some of his other political observations.
“Republicans of the past two generations…came of age with Reaganites in control of the party.”
“Reaganite…failures…led voters to abandon them for Mr. Trump in the first place.”
I’m baffled by these assertions. Does he really expect readers to believe that a party nominating Bush I, Dole, Bush II, McCain, and Romney has been controlled by Reaganites?
The comment about “Reaganite…failures” is also a bit of a mystery since Reagan left the White House in 1989. But I’m guessing Cass would cite two examples if he was asked to defend that statement.
First, he would probably point to the Reagan-era amnesty legislation, an approach that many D.C. Republicans de facto supported leading up to the 2016 election. Since I think Trump won the 2016 nomination (as well as the general election) because of his opposition to illegal immigration, I think he would have a strong argument.
Second, he would probably point to GOP support for the Paul Ryan budgets during the Tea Party era in the early part of the 2010s. Those budgets included genuine reforms of both Medicare and Medicaid and it would be very reasonable to claim those budgets were Reaganite. But congressional Republicans repeatedly got elected after proposed and voting for those budget plans. Furthermore, Trump did not win the Republican nomination based on his unwillingness to deal with entitlements.
As an economist, I find protectionism distasteful because it undermines prosperity (see here, here, here, here, and here).
As a citizen, I find protectionism distasteful because it it is a recipe for sleaze and corruption.
That should be all the evidence once needs to oppose trade taxes and other measures to interfere with cross-border commerce.
But I’m going to add another reason that hopefully will be persuasive for my Republican friends. Simply stated, protectionist taxes are a recipe for GOP losses.
I made that argument last year when pointing out that Herbert Hoover’s trade taxes crippled the Republican Party.
Not quite an extinction-level event, but a huge landslide against the GOP.
Today, let’s consider another example. A few years ago, Professor Robert Klotz wrote for the Washington Post about the 1890 mid-term elections Here are some excerpts.
Going into the 1890 election, Republicans held a narrow majority in both houses of Congress. Then they made history in the midterms — in a bad way. After an electoral meltdown, Republicans were left with a mere 86 seats out of 332. No House majority has ever returned with a smaller percentage of seats in the next Congress. The story of how that happened exemplifies the boom and bust political drama of the Gilded Age. …Republicans enacted the McKinley Tariff increase… The 1890 midterm campaign was short and intense. …Democrats focused criticism on the Republican tariff increase, which Harrison had signed into law on Oct. 1, 1890. Democrats argued that the law was a giveaway to rich industrialists — one that would cost consumers more when they went shopping. When the votes were counted, the election proved catastrophic for House Republicans. …voters blamed Republicans for the price increases… The Baltimore Sun foreshadowed this Democratic advantage in its Oct. 10 report that shops are “crowded with persons growling and grumbling” as they “are beginning to feel the effects of the new tariff law in the material increase in prices all along the line.”
Gee, I wonder whether there’s a pattern.
Republicans impose higher trade taxes in 1890 and get slaughtered. Then Republicans impose higher trade taxes in 1930 and get wiped out. Then, a Republican president unilaterally imposes higher trade taxes on “Liberation Day” in 2025 and the GOP gets crushed in 2026.
For those who are not making the obvious connection, here’s a chart from Wikipedia, which I’ve augmented, showing changes in the partisan composition of the House of Representatives.
I joked last decade that the Libertarian Party should have given Barack Obama a “Man of the Year Award” after his failed policies discredited statism.
Well, that type of satire is a two-way street. Here’s a clever cartoon I asked ChatGPT to create.
During Europe’s fiscal crisis about 15 years ago, I warned that Europe’s feckless politicians put the euro at risk by having the European Central Bank engage in de facto bailouts of Europe’s decrepit welfare states.
Bailouts, by contrast, would give politicians leeway to waste more money and incur more debt. And that would create the conditions for an even bigger fiscal crisis in the future.
Unsurprisingly, my advice was ignored. Mario Draghi, the head of the European Central Bank last decade, said in 2012 that he would do “whatever it takes” to save the euro. But what he really meant is that he would use monetary policy to prop up Europe’s welfare states.
Let’s see who was right. Did governments respond by putting their fiscal houses in order, as Draghi presumably wanted? Or did they create bigger debt bubbles with more spending.
Lo and behold, I was right. I’ve already shared data on higher debt levels in some European nations. Here’s a completely up-to-date chart, based on the latest IMF data, of debt changes in major eurozone nations since Draghi’s (in)famous speech.
France has deteriorated the most, but all of these nations have gone downhill. And, keep in mind that the situation is far more dire than shown in this chart because of Europe’s demographic outlook is much worse than it was 14 years ago.
As I recently wrote, I don’t know which country will trigger the fiscal crisis (though I have good reasons for including France, Spain, Italy, and Belgium in the chart). But it definitely looks like a huge mess is unavoidable.
So what should happen? Spending restraint is the right approach. But if politicians refuse to be responsible, I’ll reiterate what I wrote back in 2011: Defaults are preferable to bailouts.
Yes, defaults would be messy, but that outcome would send some very important and valuable signals.
The investors who buy government bonds would learn to think carefully before lending money to irresponsible politicians.
Politicians would learn that there are very negative economic and political consequences for fiscal profligacy.
For all intents and purposes, blocking bailouts is a way of dealing with the problem summarized in my 19th Theorem of Government.
Desmond Lachman of the American Enterprise Institute has a different perspective. Focusing on France, he writes that a bailout is necessary. Here are some excerpts.
France’s public finances are firmly planted on an unsustainable path. Over the last 15 years, persistent budget deficits have caused public debt to surge from 80% of GDP to almost 120%. …if current policies persist, the budget deficit will rise from 5.4% of GDP today to around 7% by 2030. Fiscal recklessness from France’s next administration would make matters far worse. So would an economic recession—an increasingly likely scenario at a time of proliferating shocks to France’s already sclerotic economy. …Against this backdrop, the current selloff of French government bonds should surprise no one. …The good news is that the ECB is better equipped to bail France out today than it was in 2010. In principle, it can use its Transmission Protection Instrument to buy unlimited amounts of French government bonds in the secondary market. The bad news is that the use of that instrument is subject to four criteria that France currently does not meet… The ECB now faces a difficult choice. It can stick to the rules and refuse to bail out France… This might enhance the ECB’s credibility, but it would risk a full-blown bond-market crisis and raise the specter of a French default… Such a crisis could cause the euro to unravel, with major adverse spillover effects on the rest of the world economy. …the ECB could waive its rules and, echoing then-ECB President Mario Draghi’s 2012 pledge, make clear that it will do “whatever it takes” to prevent French government-bond yields from blowing out.
I agree with almost everything he wrote, but I nonetheless disagree with his conclusion.
My main disagreement is that a bailout would reverse the three signals I outlined above.
A bailout would reward imprudent investors for buying debt from dodgy governments.
A bailout would reward politicians for irresponsible spending increases.
A bailout would reward voters for treating government like Santa Claus.
Let’s do a thought experiment. Imagine if Draghi had not done “whatever it takes” early last decade and instead allowed various eurozone nations to sink or swim.
Would that have led to worse short-run outcomes? Yes.
However, would that have led to a better fiscal situation today? Also, yes.
Simply stated, people who touch hot stoves should burn their fingers. And burnt fingers 15 years ago would have led to more prudent fiscal choices afterwards.
I’ll close with one final comment. Lachman wrote that the absence of a bailout “could cause the euro to unravel.” Yet he also writes that refusing a bailout would “enhance the ECB’s credibility.”
That sounds a tad bit contradictory.
But perhaps he’s simply describing the range of possible outcomes. Suffice to say that a French default (or a default by any euro nation) does not – or should not – have any implication for the euro.
Would a default by California, Illinois, or New Jersey threaten the dollar? Of course not.
P.S. Since this is a wonky and dry topic, you can click here and here for some bailout-related humor.
P.P.S. I also recommend this 2011 video. All the lessons are still relevant.
P.P.P.S. American readers may think this issue doesn’t affect them, but don’t forget the pernicious role of the IMF.
That’s the good news. The bad news is that the numbers for poverty and indigence rose in the first half of this year, but both numbers are still well below where they were when Milei took office.
Sounds like something to celebrate, right?
Not for everyone, apparently. In an article for the New York Times, Emma Bubola and Motoko Rich report on a potential conflict between Argentina’s Catholic Church and President Javier Milei.
Here are some excerpts.
Pope Leo landed in Argentina on Sunday as part of a 12-day South American tour that includes Uruguay and Peru. The Argentina visit places him at the center of that uneasy standoff with Mr. Milei, a libertarian economist who has repeatedly attacked the concepts of social justice to which much of the country’s Catholic clergy is deeply committed. The pontiff met with Mr. Milei at the presidential palace in the afternoon, then addressed him along with diplomats and civic leaders in an auditorium. …He reminded them to serve the needs of the unemployed, retirees and workers who struggle to make ends meet saying, “The economy must be at the service of the person, not the person in the service of the economy.” The auditorium exploded repeatedly in applause. …Mr. Milei has often talked in messianic and biblical terms…and called on the “forces of heaven” to accompany him. He has praised capitalism as not only efficient but moral, while dismissing any wealth redistribution as immoral, and he has said political views opposed to his are violations of the Ten Commandments. …Mr. Milei and Catholic leaders are fundamentally at odds over the Catholic concept of social justice. …Mr. Milei has managed to stabilize the economy, rein in runaway inflation and lower the poverty rate.
– New York Times
I’m glad the story noted that poverty has declined under Milei, as well as other good outcomes.
And I think Milei is on solid ground when saying that libertarianism is consistent with the 10 Commandments (i.e., don’t covet your neighbor’s goods).
Since I’m an economist rather than a theologian, I’ll simply observe that Pope Leo should look at real-world evidence.
I’ve repeatedly shared data (see here, here, here, here, here, and here) about free enterprise being the world’s most successful system for lifting people out of poverty.
My big complaint* is that some people, especially financial journalists, don’t understand that GDP is a measure of how national income is allocated (with the big categories being consumption, investment, and government).
This leads them to falsely think more government spending means more GDP, when it merely means additional national income is diverted away from consumption or investment.
It also leads them to incorrectly assume that consumer spending drives the economy, when the causality runs in the other direction.
These reasons are why I prefer “gross domestic income,” or GDI, which is a measure of how national income is generated (with main categories such as wages and business profits).
The two numbers – GDP and GDI – are basically different sides of the same coin, but I find that people think more rationally when looking at GDI.
Having just groused about GDP being an inferior measure of prosperity, I’m now going to defend it. Why? Because some ways of measuring the economy are much worse.
Look at these excerpts from a report earlier this year in the New York Times by Lydia DePillis.
…gross domestic product, the number that serves as a measure for economic progress around the world, is hardly a barometer of human flourishing. …For decades, economists have tried to devise an alternative metric to capture a broader picture of prosperity, which would change the goals that nations try to achieve. …So last year, the United Nations set up a commission to design a more focused set of indicators… The result, released this month, is a dashboard of 31 metrics grouped in four buckets representing peace and human rights, sustainability, quality of life, and inequality. …One commission member and early proponent of a G.D.P. alternative is Joseph Stiglitz, the Nobel Prize-winning former chief economist of the World Bank.
Hopefully, the skepticism is because the campaign to replace GDP is mostly an ideological project. For instance, one of the “four buckets” is “equity and inclusion” and would give nations a lower score for inequality.
But what if all income classes in an unequal country are richer than the income classes in a nation that gets a “better” score for inequality?
But you don’t have to believe me. The proponents of the alternative measure – such as Joseph Stiglitz, Heather Boushey, and David Leonhardt – are very open about wanting a new methodology because it will help advance their ideological goals.
*My small complaint is that GDP data will sometimes lead to inaccurate assessments. For instance, Ireland is a successful nation, but it’s not nearly as rich as GDP data imply. Likewise, Washington, DC, appears rich because a disproportionate share of the money diverted from the economy’s productive sector winds up being spent there. In reality, of course, very little productive economic activity takes place in America’s capital city.
Today, let’s focus on a negative feature that is becoming less negative. And not just for a handful of years.
Using IMF data, here’s a look at what’s happened to the burden of government spending over the past three decades. Sweden has been complying with my Golden Rule.
It may not seem overly impressive to have government grow 3.5 percent annually, especially when compared to Switzerland.
But what matters most is that 3.5 percent spending growth is lower than 4.3 percent GDP growth.
And even though that may not seem like a big gap, what’s key is that the gap has existed for 30 years.
To see how modest amounts of annual progress can translate to major long-run improvements, here’s the same chart, but modified to show what’s happened to the overall spending burden and overall debt burden.
As a libertarian, I’m horrified that government is consuming 49 percent of GDP in Sweden. But that’s a huge improvement compared to having 60 percent of the economy being diverted to government.
And because the burden of government spending is declining, it’s no surprise that government debt has dramatically declined. And those are the numbers for gross debt. Net debt has declined even more, dropping from 46 percent of GDP to less than 14 percent of GDP.
To get where it needs to be, Sweden needs to maintain current levels of spending restraint for…well…um…another 100 years or so. But a journey of a 100-plus years begins with the first three decades.
P.S. I started my analysis in 1996 because the IMF had debt data starting that year. Looking just at spending data, Sweden started moving in the right direction a few years earlier.
P.P.S. For a look at overall economic policy developments in Sweden, feel free to peruse my four-part series (here, here, here, and here).
Today, let’s add a fourth installment to the series and we’ll start with this segment from a recent interview.
The level of debt will be the trigger for the crisis, but the real problem is captured in this chart from Oxford University’s Our World in Data.
As you can see, the burden of social welfare spending has dramatically expanded over the past six decades.
It’s no coincidence, by the way, that the welfare state became a much bigger burden once European governments imposed value-added taxes beginning in the 1960s.
In an article for National Review, John Gustavsson documents some of Europe’s problems. The Swedish expert correctly observes that spending is the problem.
Here are some excerpts.
French bond yields have risen sharply in the middle of a global bond selloff… Other eurozone countries, largely untouched by the crisis 15 years ago, are now also in the danger zone. …A debt crisis is not by any means a sure thing. What is sure, however, is that such a crisis, were it to happen, would look very different than the one during the early 2010s. …a new crisis would be a truly economic crisis caused by a decade or more of accumulating structural issues: a loss of competitiveness causing a long slog with little economic growth resulting in little growth in tax revenues, combined with an aging population and an underemployed migrant population. …How it ends is hard to predict. Wealth taxes, which most of Europe already abolished for good reason, would almost certainly stage a comeback as left-wing populism surged. …Supporters of EU centralization will argue that the problem is the EU’s lack of authority to directly intervene in the day-to-day fiscal affairs of its member states, that if Brussels had the power to force countries to raise taxes or reduce spending, national budgets could be balanced. …markets will eventually, like in the 2010s, force Europe to do what its leaders will not. To quote the words of the economist Herb Stein, “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”
But that would be the least-preferred option for politicians and their dependents. Instead, they’ll want higher taxes, money printing, wealth confiscation, and more borrowing (so long as there are people willing to risk their savings by buying bonds from dodgy governments).
In a recent speech in Buenos Aires, I compared the two presidents.
If you don’t want to spend nine minutes on a video, I pointed out that Milei and Trump have some important similarities – especially combative personalities.
Both of them are also active on social media and anti-woke. And, with regards to policy, both of them favor deregulation and lower taxes.
But, speaking of policy, there are also major differences.
Indeed, the difference between the two presidents on economic policy is so profound that I actually wrote back in 2018 that Trump was somewhat like Juan Perón, the infamously bad post-World War II president who did so much to ruin Argentina.
Which helps to explain this meme.
In a column for the Foundation for Economic Education, Marcos Falcone points out that there are big differences between Trump and Milei.
Here are some excerpts.
Before Trump and Milei were elected, both the US and Argentina were running extensive deficits, and both leaders vowed to address the problem. On the one hand, Milei made good on his promise in just one month and balanced Argentina’s budget for the first time in over a decade. Now, 18 months into his presidency, the Argentinian government is spending less than it takes from taxpayers. By contrast, the US is not only still facing a fiscal crisis, but Trump’s administration refuses to cut spending. …Yet another area of comparison between the US and Argentina, and perhaps the most important one for its global ramifications, is trade policy. President Trump’s aggressive protectionist policies have brought the world closer to recession. …Conversely, the Milei administration has gradually begun to lift tariffs and non-tariff trade barriers in Argentina, causing prices of imported goods to fall. …the root of these results is ideological. All this could have been predicted: Trump could never lead a libertarian administration because he is not a libertarian. As for Milei, a self-described anarcho-capitalist, there is hardly any question that his final goal is dismantling the state, despite his occasional pragmatism. A shared goal of resisting “the left” is not enough to bring together opposing traditions of economic thought like Trump’s mercantilism and Milei’s free market economics, let alone their opposing political visions.
Falcone doesn’t directly compare Trump to Peron, but @HannahDCox made the connection.
And @BriciusX highlighted big differences between Milei and Trump.
Heck, the huge ideological gulf between Milei and Trump was apparent – at least to some people – even before Milei got elected.
Let’s close with some passages from Steven Greenhut’s article in Reason.
Aside from his norm-breaking appeal, Milei’s approach is far different than Trump’s. Milei vowed free-market reforms to overturn decades of populist Perónism—a statist ideology that infected Argentina’s politics since Juan Domingo Perón won the presidency in 1946. …By contrast, Trump is overturning America’s historical embrace of free markets and free trade. He sets himself up as an all-powerful charismatic leader, inserts the feds deeply into the economy… Perónism is more avowedly leftist than Trumpism, but MAGA’s “right-wing” policies sometimes seem indistinguishable from left-wing ones. …Milei is opening Argentina’s economy, whereas Trump is closing ours and centering power in his pen, as he dispenses restrictions and favors. Milei is making his economy predictable, while Trump is basing ours on his whims. …Overall, Milei is using his power to loosen the government’s grip, whereas Trump—although he occasionally reduces regulations—is centralizing government power. The two men have bad hair and unpredictable temperaments, but beyond that the similarities dissipate quickly.
The bottom line is that Trump and Milei may be buddies, but Trump’s policies are closer to Perónism rather than libertarianism.
P.S. There is one more noteworthy difference between Milei and Trump. Trump increased the size and scope of government and suffered a humiliating defeat in this week’s mid-term elections. Milei has been slashing government in Argentina and his libertarian party enjoyed a massive landslide victory in Argentina’s 2025 mid-term elections. Makes you wonder whether my 4th Theorem is actually insightful.
It’s not my role to comment on political outcomes, but it is my role to comment on policy implications of political outcomes.
So here are the good and bad takeaways from the elections.
I’ll start with the good news.
The proposed wealth tax in California appears to be heading for defeat. Given the state’s chaotically laughable system for counting votes, we may have to wait a while to get official confirmation. But the class-warfare measure is currently trailing by more than 10 percentage points and the political betting markets indicate it has almost no chance of approval.
At this point, the Democrats presumably will be favored to win total control of Washington in the 2028 elections (just as Trump delivered total control of Washington to the left in 2020) and have enough seats to impose radical legislation like the Green New Deal and Medicare for All.
Democrats have more governors and have won massive gains in state legislatures, meaning some of the recent progress on school choice could be reversed.
Regarding item #1, because Trump has no principles (other than self-enrichment and protectionism), this tweet terrifies me.
I’ll close with some I-told-you-so advice for my Republican friends.
I warned back in 2016 that Trump was a big-government Republican. He did manage to win the White House, though because of immigration and the weakness of his opponent rather than his make-believe economic agenda.
He then preceded to govern like a “crazy uncle” and Republicans lost the House and Senate in 2018.
He then gave Democrats total control of Washington by losing to Biden in 2020.
Despite all this, Republicans nominated Trump again in 2024. He did win, of course, but he was lucky once again in having a very weak opponent.
But now he’s given Democrats their biggest victory since 1974, if not since 1930.
The moral of the story is that there are three wings of the Republican Party. If the GOP wants to win, it seem obvious which one to pick.
Even though I shared a column of politician humor quite recently, I can’t resist unveiling five new example of satire.
I’m motivated, of course, by today’s mid-term elections. Which makes this first item very relevant since voters will be choosing between donkey socialism and elephant socialism.
Our second item is a cartoon strip that could be characterized as the humorous version of “public choice.”
The next meme is amusing.
Though I believe in inclusivity. Both groups are bad.
I used to think I was a decent political prognosticator, but I no longer pay close attention to congressional races. That being said, I expect Democrats will enjoy big victories today,*
And since I think I’m a decent economist, I’m going to explain why. In part, Republican losses will occur because the party controlling White House generally loses some seats in mid-term elections.
As such, this chart from @ChrisCillizza should not be a surprise. Trump’s second-term approval rating on the economy is miserable.
The key question, though, is why?
I don’t know @jarod_e_a, but he offers a plausible theory. He did some editing of Chris Cillizza’s chart to make the point that Trump governed as a conventional Republican in his first term but has followed his own preferences in his second term.
I’m assuming that he mostly is referring to protectionism when he changed “2nd term” to “Trump economic policies.”
I think that’s a very plausible hypothesis. Trump’s trade taxes have been very expensive for American families and they have contributed to economic inefficiency.
Some supporters of protectionism have argued that the real problem is the attack on Iran, not protectionism. Since voters don’t like higher gas prices, that’s a reasonable argument.
But it’s not a convincing argument. I tinkered with the Cillizza chart to show when Trump launched his foolish trade war and when he attacked Iran.
As you can see, Trump’s approval rating was already on a big downward trajectory well before hostilities began in Iran.
We don’t know, of course, what would have happened if there was no attack on Iran. Would his ratings have continued their downward trend? Would they have stabilized? Or perhaps recovered somewhat?
All of us will have different guesses, but the bottom line is that protectionism is either a big anchor for Republicans or a giant anchor for Republicans.
*My very rough guess is that Democrats will climb to 53 seats in the Senate and 242 in the House. Given Biden’s bad track record on trade issues, I’m not holding my breath that this will lead to less protectionism.
For today’s column, let’s focus on whether Trump is personally corrupt.
Since 99percent of politicians are corrupt, the answer is yes. But I want to focus on the degree of corruption.
I’m motivated in part by a feature story from the New York Times. Authored by David Ovalle and Emily Cochrane, the report says Trump’s corruption has become politically toxic.
Like many Americans, Michael Nave has a hunch that politicians of both parties enrich themselves while the working class struggles to make ends meet. But on Wednesday, Mr. Nave, a Republican, decided the party in power has become too corrupt. He cast his vote early, in Clearwater, Fla., against every Republican on the ballot… “Trump said he would drain the swamp, and he’s become the swamp,” said Mr. Nave… Democratic efforts to bolster the issue this year may be resonating amid a drumbeat of stories about Mr. Trump’s staggering increase in wealth and the billionaire and corporate elites who have supported him. Some recent polls have shown corruption has risen to the top of issues that voters say they care about most.
When it comes to plausibly pay-for-play pardons, Trump in his second term makes Bill Clinton and every other president look like pikers. Paul Walczak, a nursing home executive who’d pled guilty to spending his employees’ federal tax withholdings on such baubles as a $2 million yacht, was in May 2025 on the verge of commencing an 18-month sentence and paying $4.4 million in fines when Trump issued his get-out-of-jail-free card. …Trump’s second-term pardons and sentence commutations have wiped away more than $2 billion in fines and restitutions. …here we are in Trump’s second term, so overwhelmed by dodgy-sounding deals that any attempt to measure or characterize the scope of corruption can seem preemptively futile. …Four days before Trump’s second inauguration, a company called Aryam Investments 1 signed a deal with the president-elect’s son Eric to buy a 49 percent stake in World Liberty Financial for a reported $500 million, half of it in cash up front. The Trump family received $187 million overnight… Did Aryam Investments have any pressing regulatory business in front of the U.S. government? Quite a bit, yes. …So a foreign government official’s secret $500 million deal that personally enriched the president and his family, plus a key Mideast diplomat and his family, preceded by six months a massive regulatory reversal that will further enrich said official and his country. …Donald Trump and his family are executing corruption at a scale never previously contemplated in the American experiment.
Through regulation, taxes, or outright government ownership, politicians limit the ability of individuals and businesses to do the stuff they want to do. To get free from these government-imposed restrictions, businesses and individuals typically have to pay tribute to the politicians. Throughout history and across the world, governments have functioned as shakedown artists. President Donald Trump is more blatant than any recent U.S. president in this regard, and closer to a third-world strongman than to the American norm. …In October, the White House announced it had approved construction of a road to a mining site in Alaska. The Biden administration, heeding the cries of environmentalists, banned the road. Trump last year approved it. …Trump approved it in exchange for a 10% federal stake in the mining company. Trump’s project of building up federal stakes in dozens of companies deserves plenty of scrutiny. I call it “venture socialism,” and it will have unforeseen (mostly bad) consequences down the line. But it’s worth considering why these companies end up playing ball with Trump: Because they feel they have to. …Trump never gives up leverage without getting something in return. …The “quid pro quo president” has so many quids to give because the federal government has so much power.
Dan Hannan of London’s Institute of Economic Affairs view Trump as being a “Third Worldist.”
…the U.S. is starting to behave like some of the tinpot autocracies… The attempt to browbeat the Nobel Peace Prize Committee; the obsession with building big arches; the tariffs; the annexation threats against Canada, Denmark, and Panama; the renaming of public institutions after a living leader. Such things are the hallmark of insecure dictatorships, not of confident democracies. …The ultimate defining feature of the Third World is corruption. …President Donald Trump has more than doubled his personal wealth since he took office, mainly through his family crypto ventures. It might not be illegal, but it would have been regarded by previous generations of Americans as disgusting. …Does Trump get a pass because he never pretends to be a saint? In a world where all politicians are assumed to be shysters, is he excused because he at least lacks hypocrisy? …Those who have downplayed, excused, or ignored Trump’s venality will struggle to find grounds on which to oppose equally sleazy behavior from a successor in either party. Standards have been permanently lowered.
Is there an empirical way of measuring the degree to which Trump is corrupt?
I’ll close with two bits of data.
Here’s a tweet from @leahfiles. I don’t know this person and have no idea if she’s credible or biased. But if she’s close to accurate, this is somewhat damning.
And here’s the chart she prepared.
Last but not least, here’s the Wikipedia chart on Trump’s estimated net worth.
If he uses his office for private gain, he did a terrible job his first term but he’s been very effective in his second term.
One final comment is that you should probably distinguish between the corruption of a politician and the corruption of the people appointed by that politician. There are rare politicians from all ideologies who seem very clean (Reagan, Carter, Milei, Obama, etc), but maybe had some appointees who behaved dishonorably.
If we focus just on the politician, Trump looks bad, especially in his second term. I don’t like any of the sleaze discussed above, but I’m especially concerned that Trump is being too cozy to dictators such as Putin for reasons of private financial gain for him and his family.
Today, we’re going to show a country that has easily exceeded the recent achievements on Denmark and Greece.
Here’s a chart showing how modest spending restraint, maintained for past few decades, has led to a significant reduction in the burden of government spending in Taiwan.
What’s impressive isn’t that the burden of spending dropped by more than 5-percentage points of GDP.
Actually, that is impressive. What’s super impressive is that the spending burden, compared to other developed nations, was low at the start of the century (24 percent of GDP) and dropped even lower over 25 years.
Indeed, the spending burden in Taiwan, as a share of GDP, is less than half the fiscal burden in either Greece or Denmark.
Which may help to explain this next chart.
Taiwan’s policies are not perfect, of course, but there’s muchto admire. Especially with regards to spending policy.
I especially like comparing Cuba and Taiwan. Cuba started the post-WWII era much richer, but is now far poorer.
As I do mostelectioncycles, let’s take a look at a few key ballot initiatives.
We’ll start with California’s suicidal proposal for a (supposedly) one-time confiscation of billionaire wealth. I have a five-part series on this class-warfare initiative (available here, here, here, here, and here), but I’ll add one more bit of avidence.
Here’s a chart showing the probable impact on state tax revenue based on how many rich people leave the state and the concomitant loss of jobs and investment. The red bars mean a loss of revenue.
The chart comes from a study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research.
Here are some excerpts from the study, which was authored by scholars from Stanford University’s Hoover Institution.
This paper examines the revenue and migration impact of the 2026 California Billionaire Tax Act, a one-time 5 percent tax on the worldwide net worth of individuals exceeding $1 billion. …we estimate collections of approximately $30 billion (range $28-36 billion). Seven publicly confirmed departures already eliminated nearly 30% of the wealth tax base before signatures were collected. California’s billionaires contribute an estimated $3.3–5.8 billion annually in state income taxes, and the present value of those lost collections more than offsets the one-time wealth tax revenue under midpoint assumptions. Across 100,000 draws from the plausible parameter space, 85% of outcomes yield a negative net present value, with a mean NPV of −$38.9 billion. Even in 15% of the simulated scenarios in which NPV is positive, the amount of present value revenue would still be relatively small. Policies that distort behavior but generate little or no net revenue gain may nonetheless impose substantial costs on residents through reduced employment, investment, and income. Billionaire departures, and the fact that new founders would think twice about locating in California, have significant potential economic effects if the location of jobs and innovation shifts elsewhere. These findings suggest that the Billionaire Tax Act will not fulfill the primary functions for which it was designed. Although the Act was designed to raise revenue, behavioral response prior to voting has eroded most of the projected tax base. …Even in the minority of scenarios where the net present value is positive, the gains are modest, while the distortions to employment, investment, and the location decisions of future founders are not.
My only comment is that left-wing voters will learn a very painful lesson about the Laffer Curve if the initiative is approved.
The Wall Street Journalopined on the implications two days ago. Here are some excerpts.
Colorado remains a relatively low-tax oasis. Progressives are seeking to change that with two measures on the November ballot that would gut the state’s spending limit and establish a steeply progressive income tax. Democrats and their union friends have long wanted to eliminate Colorado’s 1992 Taxpayer Bill of Rights (aka Tabor). With progressive enthusiasm running high, they see this year as their chance. Tabor limits annual spending growth to the rate of population growth plus inflation. Revenue that exceeds the limit must be returned to taxpayers. …Colorado’s 4.4% flat income tax is lower than the rate in most of its neighbors, including Utah (4.45%), Oklahoma (4.5%), Nebraska (4.55%) and New Mexico (5.9%). This has made it a more attractive place to live, work and grow a business. Maybe not for long. Progressives are pushing a measure (Amendment 87) that would replace the state’s 4.4% flat tax with a graduated income tax that tops out at 8.4%… Under Tabor, lawmakers would ordinarily have to refund to taxpayers revenue that new taxes generate above the spending cap. But additional revenue from the progressive tax would be exempt from the cap. …Let’s hope Colorado voters realize the benefits of their long-time checks on the insatiable appetites of public unions and their politically kept men and women.
There are three other initiatives that I will closely follow.
Unfortunately, I’m generally not optimistic about the outcome of these initiatives.
Voters are not happy with the Trump economy (gee, protectionism backfired, what a surprise!) and Democratic voters are much more motivated this election cycle. And I’m guessing they’ll likely vote for the initiatives I don’t like and against the ones I do like.
The only exception is the California wealth tax. I’m guessing that will fail because a sufficient share of leftists (like Paul Krugman) actually understand the Laffer Curve. As captured by this cartoon, they realize that parasites need a healthy host.
Some people – including me – claim that socialism produces poverty.
But our fourth item today points out that this is only 99.99 percent true. A tiny handful of the socialist elite (Castro, Putin, Chavez, etc) live like royalty.
We’ll close with my favorite bit of humor in today’s collection.
And just like the Halloween-themed satire above, here’s something else that is very timely.
Either the Brewers or Rays will win the World Series this year. The Cubs win it every 108 years. But socialism never leads to success.
At the risk of closing on a serious note, click here, here, here, here, and here if you want to understand the track record of socialism, .
Though, to be technical, I should point out that the problem in all those nations is redistributionism rather than socialism.
In any event, Thatcher was right. And here’s a Chuck Asay cartoon that makes the same point.
I’m addressing this issue today because of a Washington Posteditorial about the social disarray in Europe.
Here are some excerpts, focusing on the mess in France.
France’s political crisis is colliding with a mathematical one. The government has made expensive commitments that its economy isn’t growing fast enough to keep. Hundreds of thousands of people took to the streets again this weekend to fight for larger slices of a pie that is not getting bigger. …In France, unions are asking for fatter government pensions and paychecks, along with increases in housing assistance, family allowances and a minimum-income benefit. Young people have their own 10-point wish list, which student organizations estimate would cost 10 billion euros ($11.2 billion). It includes 250,000 additional places in public higher education and an extra 2,400 euros ($2,688) a year for students receiving government grants. Before politicians can redistribute wealth, somebody has to create it. France has neglected the second half of that equation. …The government is running a budget deficit of more than 5 percent of gross domestic product. Public debt is approaching 120 percent.
But here’s the part of the editorial that deserves a lot of attention. It seems Denmark is becoming a role model.
French politicians…would do well to consider how Denmark has managed its expansive welfare state. To start, Danish leaders…voted to gradually raise the retirement age from 67 to 70 by 2040. …Its public debt is less than 30 percent of GDP, and the government ran a budget surplus. Denmark…demonstrates that fiscal responsibility, a generous safety net and a thriving market economy can coexist. Indeed, the safety net ultimately depends on the economy that finances it.
I think the editorial should give even more praise to Denmark.
It’s not just that Denmark has a responsible welfare state rather than an irresponsible welfare state. The country is actually a case study of the benefits of obeying my Golden Rule, which is a far more important goal.
Here’s a chart showing the progress that has been achieved since 2012.
Denmark’s data would be even more impressive if I used final 2025 data instead of estimated 2026 data.
When I asked ChatGPT to compare Denmark, France, and the United States, it used 2025 data and showed that Denmark is almost exactly halfway between France and the U.S.
Hopefully, the estimate for a larger spending burden in 2026 is just a statistical blip and not a sign that Denmark is returning to French-style profligacy.
I’ll close with some good news and bad news.
On the positive side, the United States has a huge fiscal advantage over France and a big fiscal advantage over Denmark.
Since I want all nations to follow the recipe for growth, I think economic rankings can be very instructive. This is why I try to write every year about the Tax Foundation’s International Tax Competitiveness Index.
The 2026 version tells us that Estonia is in first place, it’s normal position. France, unsurprisingly, is in last place. And the United States is (just barely) in the top half of nations.
Here are the full rankings.
The Index only looks at OECD member countries, so places that might rank above Estonia – such as Monaco, Cayman Islands, and Singapore – are not included.
Another interesting aspect of the report is that no nation gets good scores in every category. Indeed, the top-5 nations all score poorly (dark blue) in one category.
And the bottom-5 nations get an adequate score (light blue) in at least one category.
Keep in mind, also, that a country might not have a good tax system, but it may have other good economic policies. Iceland, for instance, has a very admirable private Social Security system even though its tax code leaves much to be desired.
For European readers, here’s a map showing the best and worst nations (green is best and dark blue is worst).
I’ll close by noting that changes over time deserve attention.
I first wrote about this report back in 2014. In that edition, the United States ranked in the bottom 5. Now the U.S. is in the top half. That’s the biggest improvement of any nation and perhaps Trump’s best accomplishment (though if trade taxes were included, one can only imagine how that would negatively affect the American score).
But to fully understand the level of dependency in a country, you have to know the share of people who actually produce value compared to those who live off of government.
In other words, you need to know more than the number of older people using Social Security and Medicare (or the equivalent programs in other nations). You also need to know how many working-age people are on welfare and how many of them are employed as government bureaucrats.
For today’s column, here’s a chart for four major European nations. In every case, the number of people riding in the wagon is greater than the number of people (the orange bars) pulling the wagon.
The ratio in France is especially bad, which may explain why there’s a strong case that it will be the first domino when the next fiscal crisis occurs (as it almost certainly will).
The fiscal and economic implications of the above chart are very straightforward. Simply stated, government is far too big in these nations and too many people are living off their fellow citizens.
Fixing that problem isn’t complicated. Governments need Swiss-stylespending caps so that politicians are forced to reform entitlement programs.
But smart solutions are not easy solutions. The obvious roadblock to economic rationality is that the number one goal of politicians is to retain power. And if the number of voters living off the government is greater than the number of voters paying for government, it’s very likely politicians will fight to preserve the status quo.
Even if they privately understand it is a recipe for crisis and national decline.
Everything I’ve written so far is pessimistic, so I’ll close by explaining why there’s still hope. Not just for the four nations shown in the visual, but also for the United States and every other country plagued by excessive government.
First, a non-trivial share of the people living off the government are not ideological leftists. Retirees are obvious examples. They get retirement benefits from government, but many of them would have preferred to have personal retirement accounts. And many government bureaucrats also lean to the right. Heck, maybe even some welfare recipients.
By contrast, it’s also true that a good chunk of private workers lean left. The bottom line is that statist politicians will have the advantage in a country with lots of government dependency, but there are exceptions.
Second, one of those exceptions is Greece, where a fiscally responsible government has been in charge since 2019 and getting good results.
The bottom line is that even left-leaning populations can (sort of) sober up once they run out of other people’s money. As I said to a TV audience back in 2009, parasites should understand they need a healthy host.
Compared to other industrialized nations, however, the U.S. and Switzerland have modest-sized, less-destructive governments.
For example, consider this chart, which has received a lot of attention. As you can see, the tax burden (vertical axis) is relatively modest in both the U.S. and Switzerland, as is the spending burden of the welfare state (horizontal axis).
I look at this chart and feel a patriotic stirring in my heart. My left-leaning friends, by contrast, will probably look at this chart and think “American and Swiss politicians don’t care about their people.”
So let’s compare living standards and see where people are most likely to thrive.
I’ve already done versions of that with my 7-part series comparing the United States and Europe (see here, here, here, here, here, here, and here).
For today’s column, let’s specifically focus on the prosperity of ordinary people. Here’s OECD data on median income. Notice that the United States and Switzerland rank very high, along with oil-rich Norway and tax-haven Luxembourg.
France, by contrast, lags far behind.
The most powerful comparison, though, is this chart. Americans in the 5th percentile (in other words, near the bottom by U.S. standards) have the same level of consumption as average people in France.
And somebody from the 25th percentile in Switzerland is equal to someone in the 50th percentile in France.
As they say in tennis, that’s “game, set, and match.”
The moral of the story is that if you care about ordinary people, the goal should be to have a smaller welfare state and lower taxes.
P.S. If you want to specifically compared France and Switzerland, click here, here, and here.
In previous editions of Freedom in the Fifty States (2023, 2022, 2019, and 2016), New Hampshire and Florida have routinely been the two states with the greatest levels of economic and personal freedom.
For the 2026 version, however, the best state is Arizona, with Montana is second place. Florida (#4) and New Hampshire (#8) still do well, but they’ve been dethroned.
Hawaii is the least-free state, beating out New York and Massachusetts.
Since I’m an economist, I was especially interested in the rankings for economic freedom.
On this basis, New Hampshire is still #1, followed by Idaho and Texas.
Hawaii was last (again), followed by Minnesota and California.
And since my economic specialty is public finance, the next map to catch my eye was the fiscal burden.
New Hampshire was the best state on this basis, followed by Florida and South Dakota. Hawaii (again) was at the bottom, followed by New York and New Mexico.
There are lots of additional maps, but I’ll close with one that gives me hope for the future.
I’ve previously written about the encouraging spread of school choice. Our final map shows the best and worst states. So, congratulations to Arizona, Florida, and Iowa.
And total disdain for Rhode Island, Maine, and Virginia.
The obvious takeaway from all this data is that some states offer more liberty for residents. So we should not be surprised that they grow faster (see here, here, here, here, here, here, and here).
In an ideal world, we would dismantle most of the federal government in Washington so that the good states would have more leeway to become hotbeds of freedom. That’s one of the best reasons to support federalism.
I don’t have mixed feelings, however, about businesses that get handouts and other favors from the government. Such companies are clearly immoral.
Indeed, I created my 11th Theorem of Government to express my disdain for businesses that want to steal money rather than earn money.
To elaborate, I applaud when companies lobby to protect themselves from bad policy. But I’m nauseated when they lobby for protectionism, bailouts, subsidies, etc.
But what about when there’s a bad boss rather than a bad company? Does my theorem apply?
Here’s a real-world example, as illustrated by these excerpts from a recent editorial from the Wall Street Journal.
United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby wants to show customers in seat 34B he feels their pain by – get this – endorsing a national wealth tax. …Asked whether he has a responsibility for dispelling public distrust in CEOs, he replied: “Wealth inequality has become a danger to our society, and we need to address hat.” By we, he means government. He added: “We should have a national wealth tax – it won’t work by state because people will just move. And I think we should have inheritance taxes that get close to 100% at some level. I would pay them.”
It’s highly disappointing that Kirby wants tax increases. It’s preposterous that he is embracing two taxes – the death tax and a wealth tax – that certainly rank at the top when measuring potential economic damage.
The editorial then mocks Kirby’s hypocrisy and virtue signalling.
United has its headquarters in Chicago, but Mr. Kirby lives in Texas, which has no state income tax. Does he pay income tax in Illinois? There’s also nothing to stop Mr. Kirby from bequeathing his fortune, or donating his $32.3 million in compensation last year, to the feds. …This isn’t Mr. Kirby’s first ride on the left-wing jet stream. During Woke 1.0, Mr. Kirby declared that two things “where we want to lead and make a difference” are “diversity and inclusion, and climate change.” Customer service apparently takes a back seat to reducing CO2 emissions. …Maybe he should focus more on pleasing customers and shareholders.
For what it’s worth, if any Republican politicians were smart (don’t laugh), they would immediately ask Mr. Kirby to testify. They could ask if he’s a hypocrite for living is zero-income-tax Texas instead of high-tax Illinois.
They could ask if his desire for higher taxes includes aviation fuel taxes, airline ticket taxes, and corporate income taxes. Maybe dumb answers to those questions would convince the Board of Directors at United to find a CEO that sides with the flying public instead of greedy politicians.
I imagine Democrats, after they win Congress next month, will be more than happy to exploit Kirby’s economic illiteracy as part of their class-warfare agenda.
I’ll close on a personal note. My local airport is Dulles, which is a United hub. The vast majority of my flying is on that airline.
But do I want to continue patronizing a company that has a CEO that sides with government instead of taxpayers? My decision will be easy if United fires Mr. Kirby.
P.S. Here’s what I wrote about another leftist CEO.