Regular readers know that I generally don’t get overly agitated about government debt (I get far more upset about counterproductive spending, regardless of how it is financed).
But even I recognize that there is a point where debt becomes excessive.
So let’s start today’s column with the simple observation that America’s current fiscal trajectory is unsustainable.
The burden of federal spending is projected to jump over the next several decades up to 30 percent of GDP while taxes “only” increase to about 19 percent of GDP.
It is inconceivable that all that new spending will be – or can be – financed by borrowing. Simply stated, domestic and international investors will decide that bonds from Uncle Sam are too risky.
So that leaves only two options.
- Spending restraint, inevitably requiring entitlement reform.
- Massive tax increases, inevitably targeting middle-class Americans.
Regarding those two choices, Donald Trump supports massive tax increases.
He’s not overtly admitting that agenda, but that’s the unavoidable outcome based on what Joshua Green of Bloomberg recently reported about his opposition to entitlement reform.
Trump is hoping to reverse his fortunes and revive his moribund presidential campaign with a…short video message. …he looks straight to camera and declares, “Under no circumstances should Republicans vote to cut a single penny from Medicare or Social Security.” …In fact, he has been remarkably consistent and outspoken over the years in his attacks on Republican efforts to cut Social Security and Medicare. …he was viewed as the least conservative Republican nominee in decades. He favored lots of infrastructure spending…and he made a big deal about protecting Social Security and Medicare.
The story also explains that Trump was the big-government candidate among Republicans in 2016 (as I noted at the time) and suggests he will hold to that position as the 2024 race develops.
Trump’s position set him apart from the other 16 Republican presidential candidates, who generally shared Ryan’s belief, prevalent among House Republicans, that cutting Social Security and Medicare was a fiscal imperative. That’s where DeSantis comes in. …DeSantis was also one of the founding members of the House Freedom Caucus, which drove the effort to cut entitlements when he was in Congress. DeSantis voted repeatedly — in 2013, 2014, and 2015 — for budgets that slashed spending on Social Security and Medicare
By the way, the article is flat-out wrong on a few points.
It is grossly inaccurate to assert that the Ryan budgets “slashed spending.” Overall spending increased in the budgets that Ryan, DeSantis, and other Tea Party Republicans supported back in 2013, 2014, and 2015.
All that happened is that spending would not have been allowed to grow as fast as previously planned.
Also, while the Ryan budgets included genuine Medicare reform (and much-needed spending restraint), they did not address Social Security reform. So the report was wrong on that as well.
But I’m digressing. The key thing to understand is that Ryan, DeSantis and other Republicans in the House last decade tried to do the right thing.
Donald Trump, by contrast, did the wrong thing. And he wants to do the wrong thing in the future. And that means huge future tax increases on you and me.
[…] neither Joe Biden nor Donald Trump are willing to address the program’s huge fiscal […]
[…] because it is reprehensible that Joe Bidenand Donald Trump are opposed to reforms that would modernize the […]
[…] The bottom line is that Trump needs to change his mind on entitlements if we want to have any hope of better tax policy. I won’t be holding me breath. […]
[…] presidential candidates are a big reason for my dour outlook. Joe Biden and Donald Trump have chosen to ignore the massive long-run fiscal problems with Social Security and other […]
[…] the Biden–Trump view and it’s a recipe for fiscal chaos and – sooner or later – huge tax […]
[…] rematch – America’s biggest economic problem is entitlement spending and Biden and Trump both say they want to keep the status quo (Biden actually wants to make it worse). That’s a […]
[…] because it is reprehensible that Joe Bidenand Donald Trump are opposed to reforms that would modernize the […]
[…] Biden and Donald Trump have both stated that they oppose entitlement reform, so this raises the very important question of […]
[…] on lower-income and middle-class households, which is the approach that is implicitly embraced by Trump and […]
[…] indebtedness and the United States gets an awful score (zero) in that category. Sadly, both Trump and Biden have openly stated that they have no desire to fix this […]
[…] opposition to genuine entitlement reform, which from my perspective arguably is the biggest flaw in Trumpie-type […]
[…] even mention the opposition to genuine entitlement reform, which from my perspective arguably is the biggest flaw in Trumpie-type […]
[…] Trump position on entitlements of kicking the can down the road is a recipe for massive future tax […]
[…] of their opposition to entitlement reform, politicians such as Joe Biden and Donald Trump prefer giant tax increases. And because there are not enough rich people to finance big government, […]
[…] American politicians, such as Joe Biden and Donald Trump, are very much opposed to dealing with Social Security, even though the current system has a […]
[…] the way, there’s little reason for future optimism. Trump and Biden attack anyone who wants to do the right thing on entitlements, so that makes it more […]
[…] the way, there’s little reason for future optimism. Trump and Biden attack anyone who wants to do the right thing on entitlements, so that makes it more […]
[…] Which is strange since he has a great opportunity to attack Trump from the right by pointing out his bad track record on spending (and bad future agenda on taxes). […]
[…] the way, there’s little reason for future optimism. Trump and Biden attack anyone who wants to do the right thing on entitlements, so that makes it more […]
[…] the way, there’s little reason for future optimism. Trump and Biden attack anyone who wants to do the right thing on entitlements, so that makes it more […]
[…] Which is strange since he has a great opportunity to attack Trump from the right by pointing out his bad track record on spending (and bad future agenda on taxes). […]
[…] Biden and Donald Trump, I think the obvious choice is […]
[…] Joe Biden and Donald Trump, I think the obvious choice is […]
[…] because it is reprehensible that Joe Bidenand Donald Trump are opposed to reforms that would modernize the […]
[…] politicians claim there is no problem, but what they are really saying is that their short-run political self-interest is more important than the long-run best interests of the […]
[…] do Joe Biden and Donald Trump have in […]
[…] do Joe Biden and Donald Trump have in […]
[…] because it is reprehensible that Joe Bidenand Donald Trump are opposed to reforms that would modernize the […]
[…] on where and how I make this argument, some people accuse me of being anti-Trump. Or […]
[…] there are not nearly enough rich taxpayers to finance big government, it would mean massive tax increases on lower-income and middle-class […]
[…] The bottom line is that we either control spending – including entitlement reform, or we surrender to European-style big government – including massive tax increases on ordinary people. […]
[…] because it is reprehensible that Joe Bidenand Donald Trump are opposed to reforms that would modernize the […]
[…] because it is reprehensible that Joe Biden and Donald Trump are opposed to reforms that would modernize the […]
[…] entitlements – including so-called national conservatives and politicians such as Donald Trump– are in favor of giant tax increases on lower-income and middle-class […]
[…] You can’t do it if your name is Donald Trump. […]
[…] entitlements – including so-called national conservatives and politicians such as Donald Trump– are in favor of giant tax increases on lower-income and middle-class […]
[…] fixing entitlements – including so-called national conservatives and politicians such as Donald Trump – are in favor of giant tax increases on lower-income and middle-class […]
[…] Donald Trump Supports Massive Tax Increases on Middle-Class Americans, Part II — International Lib… […]
[…] wrote a two-part series (here and here) about Donald Trump supporting massive middle-class tax […]
Reblogged this on Utopia, you are standing in it!.
There are bigger fish to fry than Mitchell’s interpretation of what he believes Trump wants. I normally give great respect to Mitchell, but he seems to almost always, not just once in a while, miss the bigger picture. Pity.