I know pro-market people who plan on voting to re-elect Trump because they like his record on taxes or regulation. I also know pro-market people who plan on voting against Trump because they don’t like his record on spending or trade.
I understand their motives. What baffles me, however, are people who have decided – because of their views on Trump – to change their views on policy issues. Which is one of the clever aspects of this amusing video from Ryan Long.
By the way, this is not a new phenomenon.
During the 2001-2008 period, I constantly interacted with people who were against proposals for bigger government when Bill Clinton was in the White House, but then decided to rationalize George Bush’s profligacy and interventionism.
There’s a word for this: Hypocrisy.
This accusation certainly applies to politicians, who face pressure to “be a team player” when a member of their party is in the White House and issuing foolish proposals.
But it also applies to ordinary people. And this Ninth Theorem of Government is dedicated to both groups.
I’ll close by revisiting what I wrote about understanding the motives of pro-market people who are either voting for Trump or against Trump.
That being said, I don’t the pro-Trump voters to suddenly decide that it’s a good idea to squander money or impose trade taxes. I want them to vote for Trump in spite of those bad policies.
And I don’t want the anti-Trump voters to decide that it’s a a good idea to oppose pro-growth tax cuts and deregulation. I want them to vote against Trump in spite of those good policies.
This analysis also applies to folks who are motivated by other issues (immigration, foreign policy, guns, judges, decorum, etc). Simply stated, put principles first.
P.S. Here are the eight previous Theorems of Government.
- The “First Theorem” explains how Washington really operates.
- The “Second Theorem” explains why it is so important to block the creation of new programs.
- The “Third Theorem” explains why centralized programs inevitably waste money.
- The “Fourth Theorem” explains that good policy can be good politics.
- The “Fifth Theorem” explains how good ideas on paper become bad ideas in reality.
- The “Sixth Theorem” explains an under-appreciated benefit of a flat tax.
- The “Seventh Theorem” explains how bigger governments are less competent.
- The “Eighth Theorem” explains the motives of those who focus on inequality.
[…] “Ninth Theorem” explains how politics often trumps […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem” explains how politics often trumps […]
[…] Regular readers know which option I prefer, but I can appreciate anyone who has a consistent point of view (hence, my Ninth Theorem of Government). […]
[…] Regular readers know which option I prefer, but I can appreciate anyone who has a consistent point of view (hence, my Ninth Theorem of Government). […]
[…] Regular readers know which option I prefer, but I can appreciate anyone who has a consistent point of view (hence, my Ninth Theorem of Government). […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem” explains how politics often trump […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem” explains how politics often trump […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem of Government” explains how politics often trump […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem of Government” explains how politics often trump […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem of Government” explains how politics often trump […]
[…] Well, a bad idea from Democrats such as price controls doesn’t magically become a good idea simply because it subsequently gets pushed by a Republican (unless, of course, you qualify as a partisan as defined by my Ninth Theorem of Government). […]
[…] Other examples of Trump-themed humor can be found here, here, here, here, here, here, […]
[…] contrast, the worst feature of politics, as explained by the Ninth Theorem of Government, is that it encourages people look at everything through the lens of […]
[…] “Ninth Theorem of Government” explains how politics often trump […]
[…] As explained in my Ninth Theorem of Government. […]
I certainly don’t support every policy Mr Trump has pushed. But for people who say they are voting against Trump because of his high spending … do you honestly think that Mr Biden will spend LESS? The choice is not between Mr Trump and the ideal candidate of your fantasies. The choice is between Mr Trump and Mr Biden. I don’t think that Mr Trump is the most perfect president imaginable. But I think he is way, way, better than Mr Biden.
I was and AM against presidents using their “pen and phone” to make laws that are non-constitutional. When people were supporting Obama’s dictatorial executive orders, I asked- OK- will you also support executive orders when the person in power is not of your same ideology? Crickets. At the time, they were pretty sure they were going to get eight years of Hillary. And now they throw fits every time Trump approaches a pen- even when it is to remove a non-constitutional executive order. I do appreciate the fact that he got rid of all the czar’s- paid Obama cronies.
People should not focus on (supposedly) good politicians. They’re all crooks, some less than others.
Neither should people focus on policy. The way policies are implemented will benefit the politicians, and if it won’t, they won’t be implemented.
Less government means less corruption.