I’ve commented many times about the misguided big-government policies of both Hoover and FDR, so I can say with considerable admiration that this new video from the Center for Freedom and Prosperity packs an amazing amount of solid info into about five minutes.
Perhaps the most surprising revelation in the video is that America suffered a harsh depression after World War I, with GDP falling by a staggering 24 percent.
But we don’t read much about that downturn in the history books, in large part because it ended so quickly.
The key question, though, is why did that depression end quickly while the Great Depression dragged on for a decade?
One big reason for the different results is that markets were largely left unmolested in the 1920s. This meant resources could be quickly redeployed, minimizing the downturn.
But this doesn’t mean the crowd in Washington was completely passive. They did do something to help the economy recover. As Ms. Fields explains in the video, President Harding, unlike Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt, slashed government spending.
[…] makers had learned a big lesson from the Great Depression about how protectionism was economic poison, and various trade agreements after World War IIhelped […]
[…] makers had learned a big lesson from the Great Depression about how protectionism was economic poison, and various trade agreements after World War II helped […]
[…] 1930s arguably was America’s worst decade for economic policy and economic […]
[…] 1930s arguably was America’s worst decade for economic policy and economic […]
[…] I’ll close with some excerpts about Italian fascism and FDR’s failed New Deal. […]
[…] I’ll close with some excerpts about Italian fascism and FDR’s failed New Deal. […]
[…] At the risk of understatement, amen, amen, and amen. […]
[…] At the risk of understatement, amen, amen, and amen. […]
[…] I studied economics and public policy, I learned that Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt were two peas in a failed big-government pod and deserve membership in that Hall of […]
[…] his approach won’t succeed. But let’s augment theory by examining what actually happened when Hoover and Roosevelt raised tax rates in the […]
[…] his approach won’t succeed. But let’s augment theory by examining what actually happened when Hoover and Roosevelt raised tax rates in the […]
[…] his approach won’t succeed. But let’s augment theory by examining what actually happened when Hoover and Roosevelt raised tax rates in the […]
[…] won’t succeed. But let’s augment theory by examining what actually happened when Hoover and Roosevelt raised tax rates in the […]
[…] P.P.P.S. This video summarizes the awful policies of Hoover and FDR. […]
[…] Roosevelt had two competing camps of advisers on the budget, one of which wanted to borrow and spend, while the other wanted to tax and spend. Sadly, both groups enjoyed plenty of victories. […]
[…] Roosevelt had two competing camps of advisers on the budget, one of which wanted to borrow and spend, while the other wanted to tax and spend. Sadly, both groups enjoyed plenty of victories. […]
[…] In previous posts, I have cited both Sowell and the Wall Street Journal to make this very point, but I also call your attention to this post referencing the seminal work of Robert Higgs, as well as this video on the pernicious role of government intervention in the 1930s. […]
[…] wrong. If the answer is lots of spending over a long period of time, then why did the U.S. economy languish for an entire decade under the Keynesian policies of Hoover and FDR? And why has the Japanese economy languished for […]
[…] wrong. If the answer is lots of spending over a long period of time, then why did the U.S. economy languish for an entire decade under the Keynesian policies of Hoover and FDR? And why has the Japanese economy languished for […]
[…] I studied economics and public policy, I learned that Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt were two peas in a failed big-government pod and deserve membership in that Hall of […]
[…] It’s also worth noting that huge increases in spending and debt under Hoover and Roosevelt didn’t produce good results in the […]
[…] did not get good policy during the economic crisis of the 1930s. Indeed, it’s quite likely that bad […]
[…] This video summarizes the awful policies of Hoover and […]
[…] I’ve explained before, FDR deserves scorn for doubling down on Hoover’s awful policies of higher taxes, increased […]
[…] But beginning with the so-called Progressive Era and then dramatically accelerating under the failed policies of Hoover and Roosevelt, the federal government has expanded dramatically in both size and […]
[…] Great Depression being caused by capitalism and being cured by FDR’s New Deal. In reality, statism deserves the blame. Bad policy by Hoover helped start the Depression and bad policy by FDR helped […]
[…] It didn’t work for FDR. […]
[…] livros de história geralmente promovem o mito de que o capitalismo causou a Grande Depressão e que as políticas de Franklin Delano Roosevelt salvaram a […]
[…] FDR may have won four times, but he was an awful President. His policies deepened and lengthened the Great […]
[…] instance, even though the Great Depression was mostly the result of government intervention, many people think it was caused by capitalism simply because a Republican president was in office […]
[…] is also their knee-jerk response when you point out that Keynesianism didn’t work for Hoover, didn’t work for FDR, didn’t work for Japan, […]
[…] expliqué à maintes reprises que le New Deal de Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) avait été une mauvaise chose pour l’économie. On peut en dire autant des politiques menées par Herbert Hoover, puisqu’il avait, lui […]
[…] Policy presumably deserves the lion’s share of the blame, but politicians also increased the fiscal burden of government and radically expanded the amount of regulatory […]
[…] the economic misery of the 1930s, it should be obvious that copying the awful policies of Hoover or Roosevelt is never a good […]
[…] the way to a global downturn (a repeat of the Great Depression is unlikely since that would require big increases in income taxes and many other bad policies as […]
[…] certainly can’t pick the big-spending era of Hoover and Roosevelt. That was a […]
[…] what it’s worth, I think there were lots of other bad policies from Hoover and Roosevelt that caused – and then exacerbated – the economic damage of […]
[…] close by recycling a Center for Freedom and Prosperity video that reviews the anti-market policies of Herbert Hoover and Franklin […]
[…] But I certainly sympathized with the message since Hoover and Roosevelt were big-spending interventionists. […]
[…] from the review for the simple reason that they match my beliefs (shocking, huh?). First, Reagan (quite correctly) was not a big fan of the New […]
[…] from the review for the simple reason that they match my beliefs (shocking, huh?). First, Reagan (quite correctly) was not a big fan of the New […]
[…] history books usually promote the myth that capitalism caused the Great Depression and that FDR’s policies saved the […]
[…] history books usually promote the myth that capitalism caused the Great Depression and that FDR’s policies saved the […]
Holy shit vocal fry!
[…] That was a decade of tax increases, at least in the United States! […]
[…] certainly can’t pick the big-spending era of Hoover and Roosevelt. That was a […]
[…] Franklin Roosevelt, who doubled the size of the federal government and wanted radical collectivism. Or Lyndon Johnson, the big spender who gave us Medicare and […]
[…] of Woodrow Wilson, the despicable person who gave us both the income tax and the federal reserve. doubled the size of the federal government and wanted radical collectivism. Or Lyndon Johnson, the big spender who gave us Medicare and […]
[…] person who gave us both the income tax and the federal reserve. Or Franklin Roosevelt, who doubled the size of the federal government and wanted radical collectivism. Or Lyndon Johnson, the big spender who gave us Medicare and […]
[…] important point), this helps explain why the Great Depression was so awful. Hoover and Roosevelt engaged in all sorts of interventions designed to “help” workers. But the net effect of these policies was to prevent markets from […]
[…] an important point), this helps explain why the Great Depression was so awful. Hoover and Roosevelt engaged in all sorts of interventions designed to “help” workers. But the net effect of these policies was to prevent […]
[…] notwithstanding all the evidence of failure from the spending binges of Obama, Hoover and Roosevelt, and […]
[…] Did Keynesian spending boost the economy under Roosevelt? No. […]
[…] monetary policy does have a long-established track record. It played a key role in causing the Great Depression, the 1970s stagflation, and the recent financial […]
[…] we shouldn’t be surprised. Keynesian economics didn’t work for Hoover and Roosevelt, or Bush and Obama, so why expect it to work in another […]
[…] we shouldn’t be surprised. Keynesian economics didn’t work for Hoover and Roosevelt, or Bush and Obama, so why expect it to work in another […]
[…] it was only a Great Depression because of awful policies that began under Herbert Hoover and then continued under Franklin […]
[…] drift in the wrong direction began with Woodrow Wilson and the so-called progressives, accelerated during the New Deal (ratified by the horrible Supreme Court decision in Wickard v. Filburn), and has intermittently […]
[…] Wilson has some strong competition from Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who advocated and implemented policies that exacerbated the bad policies of Herbert Hoover and thus deepened and lengthened the Great […]
[…] Prof. Rubin overstates his conclusion. It took a lot of truly awful policies by Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt to produce the Great […]
[…] (just as people for many decades credited Franklin Roosevelt for ending the Great Depression when we now know that FDR’s policies actually lengthened and deepened the […]
[…] (just as people for many decades credited Franklin Roosevelt for ending the Great Depression when we now know that FDR’s policies actually lengthened and deepened the […]
[…] of government spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed to […]
[…] normally bounces back quickly from a downturn. It was only during the 1930s, when Hoover and Roosevelt competed to impose bad policy, that a recession became a […]
[…] there are places such as the Cato Institute that are working to correct the narrative, not only about the Great Depression, but also with regards to the financial […]
[…] there are places such as the Cato Institute that are working to correct the narrative, not only about the Great Depression, but also with regards to the financial […]
[…] Prof. Rubin overstates his conclusion. It took a lot of truly awful policies by Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt to produce the Great […]
[…] Prof. Rubin overstates his conclusion. It took a lot of truly awful policies by Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt to produce the Great […]
[…] Prof. Rubin overstates his conclusion. It took a lot of truly awful policies by Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt to produce the Great […]
[…] a bigger burden of government spending, and massive intervention in markets, a normal downturn was magnified and extended to last an entire […]
[…] a bigger burden of government spending, and massive intervention in markets, a normal downturn was magnified and extended to last an entire […]
[…] help correct the record, I’ve shared a superb video from the Center for Freedom and Prosperity that discusses the failed statist policies of both Hoover and […]
[…] studied economics and public policy, I learned that Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt were two peas in a failed big-government pod and deserve membership in that Hall of […]
[…] You may recognize the host because she narrated a very good video for the Center for Freedom and Prosperity. Michelle explained how the big-government policies of […]
[…] Yup, good old Keynesian economics. Over-promising and under-delivering ever since the failed policies of Hoover and Roosevelt. […]
[…] Yup, good old Keynesian economics. Over-promising and under-delivering ever since the failed policies of Hoover and Roosevelt. […]
[…] is economic stagnation and record debt. Going back further in time, Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt dramatically increased the burden of government spending, mostly financed with borrowing, and a recession became a Great […]
[…] is economic stagnation and record debt. Going back further in time, Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt dramatically increased the burden of government spending, mostly financed with borrowing, and a recession became a Great […]
[…] In previous posts, I have cited both Sowell and the Wall Street Journal to make this very point, but I also call your attention to this post referencing the seminal work of Robert Higgs, as well as this video on the pernicious role of government intervention in the 1930s. […]
[…] I studied economics and public policy, I learned that Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt were two peas in a failed big-government pod and deserve membership in that Hall of […]
[…] I studied economics and public policy, I learned that Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt were two peas in a failed big-government pod and deserve membership in that Hall of […]
[…] back further in time, Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt dramatically increased the burden of government spending, mostly financed with borrowing, and a recession became a Great […]
[…] In previous posts, I have cited both Sowell and the Wall Street Journal to make this very point, but I also call your attention to this post referencing the seminal work of Robert Higgs, as well as this video on the pernicious role of government intervention in the 1930s. […]
[…] it’s also clear that the statist policies of Hoover and Roosevelt turned the downturn into a Great […]
[…] bad, but FDR’s statism helped extend the Great Depression – by an additional seven years according to scholarly research! That’s a much worse track […]
[…] bad, but FDR’s statism helped extend the Great Depression – by an additional seven years according to scholarly research! That’s a much worse […]
[…] And if you want to see rich, pro-tax statists exposed as hypocrites, watch these ambush interviews by Michelle Fields (who also narrated a very good video explaining how government policy mistakes caused – and exacerbated – the Great Depression). […]
[…] explained on many occasions that Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal was bad news for the economy. And the same can be said of Herbert Hoover’s policies, since he also expanded the burden of […]
[…] explained on many occasions that Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal was bad news for the economy. And the same can be said of Herbert Hoover’s policies, since he also expanded the burden of […]
[…] In previous posts, I have cited both Sowell and the Wall Street Journal to make this very point, but I also call your attention to this post referencing the seminal work of Robert Higgs, as well as this video on the pernicious role of government intervention in the 1930s. […]
Actually no way to determine any REALISTIC truth on economic policy — both (or more) sides can cherry-pick “data” and formulate as needed from a political, often ideological stance.
[…] of government spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed to […]
[…] spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed […]
[…] of government spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed to […]
[…] spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed […]
[…] spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed […]
[…] of government spending in hopes that Keynesian economics would magically work (after failing for Hoover and Roosevelt in the 1930s, Japan in the 1990s, Bush in 2008, and Obama in 2009), the Estonians realized that they needed to […]
[…] to know more about that issue, including the damaging impact of statist policies by Hoover and FDR, this video is an excellent introduction. Rate this: Share this:PrintEmailFacebookTwitterMoredeliciousDiggFarkLinkedInRedditStumbleUponLike […]
[…] the way, you may recognize Michelle Fields because she narrated this video on how bad government policies such as the New Deal made the Great Depression […]
[…] the way, you may recognize Michelle Fields because she narrated this video on how bad government policies such as the New Deal made the Great Depression worse. Rate this: Share […]
Reblogged this on The Conservative New Ager.
Excellent video… The girl is so hott! (perhaps a man my age should not make that comment but I am doing it anyway. Here in Latin America those comments are allowed) No talk about the “loose” and “tight” money controversy: Very wise, in my humble opinion.
I brought in Hawley-Smoot above, b/c that was Sowell’s argument in the article that this video cited, that’s all.
I’m ok with the idea of the New Deal prolonging the Depression, but I’m not sure that the rise of unemployment to its 1932 levels (25%) can be blamed on the Smoot-Halwey tariff. Our foreign trade (combined imports and exports) was worth some 7.5 billion at the time, while the GDP was about 100 billion before the Depression. So a fall in foreign trade caused by Hawley-Smoot, to 3.7 billion in 1933 (combined), really wouldn’t account for a collapse in the GDP. Of course Hawley-Smoot didn’t help at all, but I think it’s a stretch to say that this was the government intervention that turned a slight downturn into a depression.
It is time for economists and historians to take seriously the hypothesis that the New Deal prolonged the Great Depression by creating an extraordinarily high degree of regime uncertainty in the minds of investors.
. . . From 1935 through 1940, with Roosevelt and the ardent New Dealers who surrounded him in full cry, private investors dared not risk their funds in the amounts typical of the late 1920s. In 1945 and 1946, with Roosevelt dead, the New Deal in retreat, and most of the wartime controls being removed, investors came out in force. To be sure, the federal government had become, and would remain, a much more powerful force to be reckoned with. But the government no longer seemed to possess the terrifying potential that businesspeople had perceived before the war. For investors, the nightmare was over. For the economy, once more, prosperity was possible.
———-Robert Higgs