This isn’t intentional, but there’s been a European theme to this week’s posts. I wrote yesterday about economic chaos in France, and the previous day I wrote about the grim consequences of Italian statism.
Today, we’re going to look at Greece. In the past, I’ve explained that Greece is special, albeit in a bad way. But I’ve also asserted that Greece could be rejuvenated and could deal with its debt with the right reforms.
Heck, Greece could even renege on its debt and still enjoy an economic renaissance if it adopted the right policies. That’s the message of this short video narrated by Garett Jones of George Mason University
So the $64 question (actually, the $231,199,453,552 question according to the latest projection of Greek debt) is whether Greece will do the right kind of reform.
Unfortunately, it appears that all the bailouts have subsidized bad policy. Writing for National review, a journalist from Greece explains that his government is adding more and more taxes onto an overburdened private sector.
…the new austerity measures, which are often amusingly termed reforms, are for the most part tax increases — which may not be popular, but which conform to SYRIZA’s ideological creed. The new package agreed to by SYRIZA and Greece’s creditors is about 90 percent new taxes or tax increases and 10 percent reforms. The tax increases have the benefit of protecting SYRIZA’s core constituency, which is the public-sector employees. Despite the collapse of public revenue and the overall dismal economic outlook, the SYRIZA government plans to increase the salaries of public-sector employees (by as much as 8 percent) and carry on with 45,000 new hires in 2016. Meanwhile, in the private sector, SYRIZA has increased taxes on all sorts of things and is planning to double the taxation of farmers. It has increased business taxes and also demanded the pre-payment of business taxes. It has increased the VAT on almost all goods, and it is defining affluence down so as to increase income taxes for a greater number of taxpayers. And although Greece has probably the highest social-security contributions in Europe, SYRIZA is planning to increase these contributions even more, despite the fact that pensioners now outnumber those who are still employed in the private sector.
More pensioners that private-sector employees?!?
Wow, even I’m shocked by that factoid. There definitely are far more people riding in the wagon than pulling the wagon when you add up pensioners, bureaucrats, and welfare recipients.
So you can understand why Greece is almost surely doomed.
Especially when you consider that many of the people leaving Greece are the productive ones (i.e., those who normally would be pulling the wagon). Here are some passages from a story in the New York Times from last year.
From 2010 to 2013, about 218,000 Greeks emigrated, according to an estimate from the Greek statistics agency. Nearly half of them went to Germany. …Resentments against Germany — Greece’s most powerful creditor — quickly fade when it comes to the prospect of a regular paycheck. Many of those leaving Greece are highly educated professionals and scientists seeking greater opportunity and better pay. An estimated 135,000 Greeks with post-secondary degrees have left since 2010 and are working abroad, according to Lois Labrianidis, an economic geographer and official in Greece’s Economy Ministry. “We think this is human capital that is crucial for the development of the country,” Mr. Labrianidis told me recently, calling the departures a “major blow.” …While much of the attention on recent Greek emigration has focused on the highly educated, I’ve been surprised by the number of working-class Greeks I’ve met who left due to financial desperation.
But there’s one group of people who aren’t leaving.
You probably won’t be surprised to learn that they are the bureaucrats. As noted in this report from the U.K.-based Telegraph, their privileged position is zealously protected by vote-buying politicians.
The other thing most people in the area seem to agree on is that the biggest impediment to progress is the size of Greece’s public sector. The country has a population of 10 million, of which 2.5 million are pensioners, one million are government employees and two million work in the private sector. A further 1.7 million are unemployed. The rest are children or students. “So you can see why the current situation is unsustainable,” says Tryfon. “The only solution is for the public sector to be cut back. But every government since the crisis has chosen to raise taxes, while doing little to stimulate the private sector because they only want to protect votes.” “…Public sector employees and pensioners are the first to get paid and the only ones to get paid on time. We need investment into the private sector, but there is no motivation for companies to come to Greece…” a company would be nuts to invest in a politically unstable country, creaking under debt and crippled by an incredibly punitive tax regime. “What business will invest in a Greece when it takes six months to set up a company compared to Cyprus where it takes 15 minutes?” asks Dimitris Karkavitsas, an investment banker-turned-strawberry farmer. …the young engineer, says everyone who tries to make it in the private sector gets strangled. “The tax is killing us,” he says. …In the meantime, the public sector remains a massive beast.
Moreover, when you set up a company in Cyprus, there’s never a risk that you’ll be required to provide disgusting forms of DNA as part of bureaucratic requirements.
Yet rather than be outraged by overpaid and meddlesome bureaucrats, I suspect most Greeks probably think how they can get on that gravy train. Which explains why, in an interview, I said the Greeks shouldn’t be allowed to “loot and mooch their way through life.”
Until and unless they learn that lesson, the nation is doomed to societal collapse.
P.S. Another sign of Greece’s moral and fiscal bankruptcy is that pedophiles can get disability payments.
P.P.S. To offset the grim message of today’s column, let’s also enjoy some Greek-related humor.
This cartoon is quite good, but this this one is my favorite. And the final cartoon in this post also has a Greek theme.
We also have a couple of videos. The first one features a video about…well, I’m not sure, but we’ll call it a European romantic comedy and the second one features a Greek comic pontificating about Germany.
Last but not least, here are some very un-PC maps of how various peoples – including the Greeks – view different European nations.
[…] when people want examples, I just point to nations such as Greece, Italy, and France. Or states such as California and […]
[…] I’m in Sydney, Australia, but not because I’m confirming that this country will be my escape option if (when?) the United States suffers a Greek-style fiscal collapse. […]
[…] Simply stated, politicians have a “public choice” incentive for never-ending expansions of government, even if they actually understand such policies will lead to Greek-style collapse. […]
[…] is a big gap between the Nordic nations and France. And then another big gap before getting to Greece, and also a big gap before reaching Venezuela at the bottom. Should all of those nations get the […]
[…] Part III will look at the ongoing deterioration of […]
[…] And if things really deteriorate, a government may default (i.e., no longer make promised payments) and investors obviously will refuse to lend any more money. That’s basically what happened in Greece. […]
[…] case of Greece. I’ve written many times about the debilitating impact of high tax rates and wasteful spending in that nation. It has the least economic freedom of all nations in Western Europe, so it’s no […]
[…] case of Greece. I’ve written many times about the debilitating impact of high tax rates and wasteful spending in that nation. It has the least economic freedom of all nations in Western Europe, so it’s […]
[…] In any event, all of the tax increases are having predictably bad effects. […]
[…] da economia com muitos programas de boas aparências. Aí você segue para os países que pertencem à segunda camada , que é caracterizada por economias que estão realmente diminuindo ao invés de apenas […]
[…] we can look today at countries like Cuba, Greece, Venezuela, and North Korea to confirm the utter insanity of supporting any type of […]
[…] um minúsculo Estado de bem-estar social , ou melhor em nações como a França e a Grécia , onde há inchados Estados de bem-estar social, mas muito pouco dinamismo […]
[…] in radically different ways. Sweden shrank government and boosted economic liberty while Greece increased the size and scope of the state (aided and abetted by […]
[…] tax itself to death? Greek politicians are doing their best to see if this is possible, with a seemingly endless parade of tax increases (so many that even the tax-loving folks at the IMF have […]
[…] in wealth expropriation. What about the rights of people in nations – such as Argentina and Greece – where governments wreck economies because of blind incompetence? Shouldn’t they […]
[…] the developed world, I highlight countries such as France, Greece, and […]
[…] solution is – or should be – obvious. And it’s the same one I suggested for Greece. Allow the government to default on existing debt, but only in exchange for pro-market reforms such […]
[…] solution is – or should be – obvious. And it’s the same one I suggested for Greece. Allow the government to default on existing debt, but only in exchange for pro-market reforms such […]
[…] big fall, however, is not surprising. And neither are the astounding declines for Argentina and Venezuela (Argentina improved quite a […]
[…] shape and manage” the economy in the 1800s and 1900s. Heck, the reason why places such as Greece and Venezuela are such a mess is that politicians did a steroid-fueled version of shaping and […]
[…] bills is not good budget policy. It’s basically what happens in poorly governed places like Greece and Illinois. But it’s not default. There wouldn’t be any risk to financial markets if […]
[…] this century. That’s acceptable for New Zealand, but it’s basically a recipe for continued misery in […]
[…] off in Hong Kong, which has only a tiny welfare state, or better off in nations such as France and Greece, which have bloated welfare states but very little economic […]
[…] stability will lead to fiscal crisis thanks to changes in the composition of the population. Think Greece, but on a bigger […]
[…] voters do have an unfortunate tendency to elect more bad politicians (in place likes France and Greece) than sensible politicians (in places such as Switzerland and New Zealand), but that’s not […]
[…] by saying it sometimes helps to have bad examples so the rest of the nation knows what to avoid. Greece and France play that role for the industrialized world. Venezuela stands alone as a symbol of […]
[…] by saying it sometimes helps to have bad examples so the rest of the nation knows what to avoid. Greece and France play that role for the industrialized world. Venezuela stands alone as a symbol of […]
[…] is a big reason why nations such as Greece and Italy already are in deep trouble and why it’s just a matter of time before the fiscal […]
[…] I thought about the failure of nations that go too far down the path of redistribution, such as Greece and […]
[…] why does that mean a Brazilian future? Because as Greece is already suffering the inevitable consequences of a bloated welfare state, Brazil is already suffering the inevitable […]
[…] da economia com muitos programas de boas aparências. Aí você segue para os países que pertencem à segunda camada, que é caracterizada por economias que estão realmente diminuindo ao invés de apenas […]
[…] of Greece’s horrible economy, this link has obvious rhetorical […]
[…] of Greece’s horrible economy, this link has obvious rhetorical […]
[…] conditions in Greece are dire, with countless horror stories about families suffering economic deprivation. After years of […]
[…] will work marvelously in the United States. Just like it’s producing great outcomes in place like Greece and […]
[…] work marvelously in the United States. Just like it’s producing great outcomes in place like Greece and […]
[…] whereas there’s little reason to be optimistic for a rebirth of freedom in places such as Greece and […]
[…] Though it’s an open question whether Greece can be saved. Many productive people already have escaped the nation and most of the ones who have stayed are part of the […]
[…] Though it’s an open question whether Greece can be saved. Many productive people already have escaped the nation and most of the ones who have stayed are part of the […]
[…] voters and politicians can have an incentive for ever-larger government, even if the end result is Greek-style fiscal chaos because taxes and spending reach ruinous levels. I call this “Goldfish Government” because some […]
[…] All this explains why, when categorizing different types of leftists, I put him in the “crazies” group along with the Syriza Party of Greece. […]
[…] when people want examples, I just point to nations such as Greece, Italy, and France. Or states such as California and […]
[…] closed the interview by pointing out that it makes no sense to make America more like Greece or […]
[…] the economic chaos in Greece suggest that government should be […]
[…] Not does it have really bad policies that deserve to be mocked, so it doesn’t get the negative attention that I shower upon nations such as France, Italy, and Greece. […]
[…] that sap an economy’s vitality with lots of feel-good programs. Then you get countries that belong in the second layer, which is characterized by economies that are actually declining rather than merely […]
[…] explains why I am so miserably pessimistic about the future of places such as […]
[…] look at France, Italy, Greece, and other EU nations that are fiscal basket cases even though there are “Maastricht […]
[…] Even Greece has done better! […]
[…] let two wolves and a sheep vote on what to have for lunch. It has destroyed Venezuela. It’s destroying Greece. It’s what makes me pessimistic about the future of nations as diverse as Brazil, Italy, and […]
[…] So maybe French voters finally realize (notwithstanding the bad advice of Paul Krugman) that becoming another Greece isn’t a good idea. […]
[…] also worth noting that Greece gets consistently bad scores. And I’m not surprised that Argentina is near the bottom as well […]
[…] also worth noting that Greece gets consistently bad scores. And I’m not surprised that Argentina is near the bottom as well […]
[…] be sure, we already had proof from Greece, France, the Soviet Union, Brazil, and many other places. But it’s still nice to have another […]
[…] is a great line that cleverly pinpoints the ultimate consequence of statism. Just think Greece or […]
[…] can point to the economic chaos in places such as Greece and Venezuela and explain that Margaret Thatcher was right when she warned that socialists […]
[…] look at Greece. From the moment the crisis began, Greek politicians started raising taxes. And they haven’t stopped, with many of the tax hikes being cheered by international […]
[…] voters and politicians can have an incentive for ever-larger government, even if the end result is Greek-style fiscal chaos because taxes and spending reach ruinous […]
[…] given the Greek government’s rampant corruption and wasteful habits, I think it’s defensible for people to go one step farther and evade as well as […]
[…] two peas in a pod on economic policy. The only difference is that Sanders wants America to become Greece at a faster […]
[…] two peas in a pod on economic policy. The only difference is that Sanders wants America to become Greece at a faster […]
[…] here’s my quandary (and I feel the same way about Greece): I don’t mind debt relief if it’s part of a deal that actually produces better […]
[…] here’s my quandary (and I feel the same way about Greece): I don’t mind debt relief if it’s part of a deal that actually produces better […]
[…] and businesses decide that it’s no fun to work hard when the government is the main beneficiary, they leave. And all of sudden the politicians no longer have as much income to […]
[…] Will the Last Productive Person in Greece Please Turn off the Lights … […]
Greeks have been burning furniture to stay warm… prostitution is flourishing… reports are that a 30 min encounter costs the equivalent of a loaf of bread… medical practitioners in more remote parts of the country fear for their safety… some areas of Greece have been overrun with mid-east migrants… and yet the central government lacks the courage to change the dynamic… yet another sad European story… RIP…
it’s hard to figure Germany… but David Goldman… {Spengler} had some thoughts:
“Dying Germany has only one item on its bucket list, and that is redemption. The Germans cannot seek redemption from the crimes of their grandparents because they do not understand what motivated them to do such terrible things.”
“A Parable for Germany”
by David P. Goldman
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/7221/germany-parable
All said about Greece is correct.
But what baffles me is the Germans. They are responding by pushing for European integration at an ever faster rate. Yes, Germans want to integrate more with the Greeks, the Italians, the Spaniards, the French. What are they going to do with all the wagon riders they want to integrate with? Don’t they understand that they are simply giving riders ever increasing voting rights onto their German wallets? Can a Germany that is already growing at a mere half the world average trendline afford to integrate with those who are growing at a quarter of that pace? A country whose share of world GDP keeps shrinking has ambitions to integrate with even bigger losers?
“But they will reform them!” Oh yes they will!? America could not reform an Iraq with almost one tenth the population, and eighty million Germans will reform two hundred million Greeks, Italians, French, Spaniards and Portuguese? The German, already slow growing, wallets will be voted away in a jiffy.
There may be some deeper underlying principle here, as it seems that Germans must commit suicide a couple of times a century around some new great coercively collectivist idea or another.
P.S. Yes the Greeks gave the world democracy. They also have the world ostracism, in other words, the rule of the pitchfork. While democracy remains the best form of government, when electorates lose social capital there is little hope. In that respect Greeks, like over two millennia ago, may actually be ahead, not behind. Looks like most developed democracies are trending towards pitchfork rule. Strong constitutions with individual freedoms only provide inertia to this degeneration process but cannot stop it. Ultimately sustained pressure by a majority eventually overruns the constitution. It simply gets ignored or reinterpreted. This is very sad for those of us who emigrated from countries like Greece to the new world where there was a different constitutional contract. Or so we thought. The rule of the pitchfork is now catching up with us. Which would all be simply a matter of politico-ethical preferences were it not for the fact that coercive collectivism is associated with the mother of all ills and decline: slow growth.
Good article. I think a more appropriate article title would be ‘Will the Last Productive Person in Greece Please Flush the Toilet When You Leave?” because that’s where that country is going to be within 5 years, and within 15 years they won’t be an independent country at all. These aren’t the Greeks who gave the world logic and democracy.