In the debate over “fairness,” my statist friends mistakenly see the economy as a fixed pie. This leads them to claim that rich people are rich because poor people are poor.
But there’s no data to support this position (other than in kleptocracies such as Venezuela where a ruling socialist elite steals wealth).
So some folks on the left will back down from that extreme claim and instead assert that the rich are the only ones enjoying more prosperity as time goes by.
For evidence, they cite data showing that incomes have been mostly flat over the past 30-40 years for poor people and middle-class people, particularly when compared to the rich.
But there’s a big problem with their data. They look at income levels in some past year and then they compare that data with income levels in a recent year.
But, as I wrote back in 2015, this means they are comparing apples and oranges.
There is considerable income mobility in the United States, which means today’s rich and today’s poor won’t necessarily be tomorrow’s rich and tomorrow’s poor.
I don’t necessarily expect people to automatically believe me. So if you’re one of the skeptics, watch this video from Russ Roberts. It is almost eight minutes and it is filled with rigor and data, but it’s worth watching since it masterfully demonstrates that lower-income and middle-class households actually enjoy larger gains than rich households.
As Russ says, you have to follow the same people over time if you want legitimate analysis.
And he shares lots of data showing that the rich actually have smaller-than-average gains in income over time.
It’s also worthwhile to investigate what happens with families over time. What we find is that children from poor households are more likely to exceed their parents’ income than children from rich households.
In other words, Russ’ conclusion was right. The American dream still exists. And if we can convince politicians to focus on growth, we can achieve better outcomes for people of all income levels.
P.S. The above video is a great addition to John Stossel’s recent video.
[…] a just and sensible society, the goal should instead be upward mobility so that everyone can get […]
[…] The video is great, as are his other videos that I have shared over the years (see here, here, here, and […]
[…] Russ Roberts (a.k.a., @econtalker) on the economic status of the middle class, followed by a video last year on whether the rich are the only ones earning more […]
[…] I don’t want to digress too much. The key point is that workers have seen healthy increases in compensation, notwithstanding the fact that I wish it was more in the form of […]
Look to your upbringing and lifestyle to see why you’re stuck being poor. If you don’t deserve to be rich you won’t be. It takes real effort, not constant complaining. And causing the rich to become poor won’t lift you out of poverty – it will just make you feel better about your poverty.
[…] « Rich, Poor, and Income Mobility […]
Well put! I was thinking just this morning that liberals see the economy as a zero sum game, free market people see it as a positive sum game, and Socialists *make it *a negative sum game.