In a perverse way (pun intended), I admire German politicians for their creativity. They will figure out ways to tax just about anything.
Their latest scheme is a plan that requires streetwalkers to put money in parking meters in exchange for a slip of paper that entitles them to…um…ply their trade for a specified period of time.
Here are some excerpts from the Daily Mail report.
Prostitutes working the streets of the former German capital are now having to pay £5.30 per night to a modified parking meter – to gain permission to ply their trade. Sex workers in Bonn face hefty fines for not forking out the new ‘income tax’ which has been brought in to try and regulate the outdoor aspect of the industry. It is to bring them into line with the country’s brothel workers who already pay out a percentage of their profits in tax, which varies depending on the region. …if caught without a valid ticket, offenders would be reprimanded. They would then face fines, and later a ban. The fee is a daily charge, and irrespective of how many punters are entertained. …specific quarters have been designated as sex work zones. City officials have created ‘consummation areas’, which are wooden parking garages where customers driving cars can retreat to with their prostitutes. Dortmund has a similar system where prostitutes buy tickets from petrol stations.
I suppose this is the point where I normally would make some snide comments about greedy politicians, or perhaps offer some analysis about the economic impact of taxation.
But this story is so bizarre that I can’t even get to that stage.
What happens if you’re just a regular motorist and you put money in the meter and press the wrong button?
And I know that most governments will put a boot on one of your tires to disable your car if you don’t pay your parking tickets. Does this mean hookers who don’t buy a street-walking pass will get a chastity belt?
Does the city government also charge for use of the garages in the “consummation areas”? And when did it become the responsibility of German taxpayers to finance something like that?!?
And for the hookers in Dortmund who get their passes at the petrol station, do the mechanics check “under the hood” if they use full service? (okay, pretty lame, but I couldn’t resist)
Most important, will the politicians take this idea to its logical conclusion and put prostitute meters in Parliament? In other words, require politicians to put money in a meter before they try to buy support from interest groups by providing handouts and special preferences.
That’s one tax increase even I could support.
[…] If you want some odd examples of taxation and sex work, check out these stories from Austria, Germany, and the United […]
[…] P.S. If you want other odd examples of international taxation, click here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here. […]
[…] is another question to ponder: How can a nation that is so aggressive (not to mention dogmatic and inventive) about collecting taxes be so incompetent at spending […]
[…] parking meters to levy taxes on the services of […]
[…] Governments get very creative, such as a German plan to tax prostitutes with parking meters. […]
[…] pages deals with the unfortunate nexus between sex and government. You can find columns about taxes and sex, Obamacare and sex, and licensing and […]
[…] since German politicians have figured out innovative ways of taxing hookers (the Spanish government has a more conventional approach), maybe it’s only fair that tax […]
[…] Sometimes I learn about how governments get very creative, such as a German plan to tax prostitutes with parking meters. […]
[…] one handlebar brake, taxing homeowners today for a street that was built beginning in the 1930s, making streetwalkers pay a tax by using parking meters, and spending 30 times as much to enforce a tax as is […]
[…] Germans, after all, came up with an odd scheme to make streetwalkers pay a nightly tax via parking […]
[…] Germany, by contrast, prostitutes have to use parking meters to pay […]
[…] I’m not a huge fan of German fiscal policy. Tax rates are too high and the burden of government spending is excessive. Heck, they’ve even figured out how to use parking meters to tax prostitutes! […]
[…] I’m not a huge fan of German fiscal policy. Tax rates are too high and the burden of government spending is excessive. Heck, they’ve even figured out how to use parking meters to tax prostitutes! […]
[…] I’m not a huge fan of German fiscal policy. Tax rates are too high and the burden of government spending is excessive. Heck, they’ve even figured out how to use parking meters to tax prostitutes! […]
[…] since it would create the worst of all worlds, marrying Teutonic tax efficiency (for example, taxing prostitutes with parking meters) with Greek profligacy (for example, subsidies for […]
[…] Germany, by contrast, prostitutes have to use parking meters to pay […]
[…] P.P.P.S. The Germans at least have figured out an efficient way to tax prostitutes. […]
[…] P.P.P.S. The Germans at least have figured out an efficient way to tax prostitutes. […]
[…] P.S. Since this post looks at both parking meters and prostitution, you’ll be amused by the way the Germans combined those two topics. […]
[…] who among us isn’t impressed that the German tax authorities have figured out how to levy a prostitute tax using parking […]
[…] and you probably won’t be surprised that Germany (the country that figured out a way to use parking meters to tax prostitutes) and France were among the jurisdictions that also ranked below […]
[…] that’s amateur hour compared to the Germans, who have figured out how to use parking meters to tax […]
[…] in mind that this is a country that has parking-meter taxes for prostitutes and a nation with a supposedly conservative Chancellor who is leading the charge for a global tax on […]
[…] other German posts mocked the country’s scheme to tax prostitutes, mocked the government for losing the blueprints for its new spy headquarters, mocked the […]
[…] other German posts mocked the country’s scheme to tax prostitutes, mocked the government for losing the blueprints for its new spy headquarters, mocked the […]
Good point Eitan.
As much as I dislike all taxes, I always considered sin taxes to be a kind of insurance against prohibitionist policies. If the government is getting money from it, they are less likely to prohibit it. Of course this can be taken way too far, like how cigarettes’ costs are more than half taxes. Inanity aside, those politicians should be lauded for allowing people to exercise their freedom, even if you don’t like what they do with it.
The conductor on a European train can ask any passenger to show his ticket, which he also buys from an automated dispenser. That enforces the need for every passenger to buy a ticket.
I pose the question, how does a roaming official check the tickets of the prostitutes? You can’t require every woman standing on the sidewalk to have a ticket; she might not be a prostitute. It would seem that you must interrupt each couple in the act, to check the woman’s ticket. “Very good, your ticket is in order, proceed.”
Catch 22 saw this one coming.