If you asked me that question 30 years ago, I would have said Jeff MacNelly without hesitation.
Not that I was exposed to many options in the pre-Internet dark ages, so my choice may have been driven by lack of knowledge. Nonetheless, MacNelly was a genius with the details, as you can see from these cartoons about IRS complexity and government shutdowns.
But what about today’s cartoonists?
Based on the number of cartoons I’ve shared, the easy answer would be either Michael Ramirez or Chuck Asay, but there are cartoons from other artists that are absolutely superb.
So I’m going to turn this question around.
Here are my favorite cartoons from various artists and you can answer the poll about which one you would rank highest.
In no particular order, the options are:
Michael Ramirez – This gem about Obamanomics is the most-viewed professional cartoon in the history of this blog, and his European lemming cartoon is great, as is his masterpiece on taxes in the Garden of Eden. But if I had to pick only one, it would be his Julia cartoon.
Chuck Asay – Since I’m a budget wonk, I should choose his cartoon about the garbage-in, garbage-out approach of the Congressional Budget Office. But for mass appeal, this tractor cartoon and this regime-uncertainty cartoon are much better. And my favorite is this nothing-left-to-steal masterpiece.
Henry Payne – For sentimental reasons, I might pick this Robin Hood cartoon. But for political cleverness, his Obamacare-Romneycare cartoon is a classic, and his Valentine’s Fairness Act cartoon is satire that could become reality. But given what I focus on every day at Cato, you’ll understand why this cartoon about Greek fiscal policy is at the top of my list.
Lisa Benson – This cartoon about California tax hikes would be near the top of the list, except taxpayers were tricked into voting for the referendum. I very much like this fiscal cliff cartoon, this Keynesian economics cartoon, and this one about jump-starting the economy with tax hikes. But the top prize goes to this cartoon because it perfectly captures Obama’s fiscal policy.
Eric Allie – More than anyone else, he shows with this cartoon and this cartoon how even well-intentioned government goes awry. And the teetering-on-the-edge-of-the-cliff cartoon accurately shows Obama’s mindset on fiscal policy. If forced to choose, though, I’ll go with this forward-to-the-iceberg cartoon.
Robert Ariail – I think I’ve only used three of his cartoons, but the image he produced about Greece, the euro, fiscal policy, and the rest of Europe is a classic. The other two I’ve used (here and here) are funny, but not in the same league. But if you need some added humor to compensate, this map showing how the Greeks perceive the rest of Europe is very amusing, as is this video and this video about the Greek mindset.
Gary Varvel – Here’s a good Halloween cartoon, but Varvel is the best at exposing the spending-cut hoax in DC, as you can see from this sequester cartoon and this deficit reduction cartoon. This cartoon about Bernie Madoff and Social Security, however, is at the top of my list.
Scott Stantis – Here’s a cartoon strip about involuntary contributions to support the green-energy boondoggle. And we also have a cartoon showing Obama’s less-than-stellar appreciation of the Bill of Rights. But without doubt this cartoon about Keynesian stimulus is the best Stantis cartoon I’ve ever seen.
Jerry Holbert – I was tempted to use this cartoon about the rich involuntarily financing a continued spending spree. And the Obama-as-magician cartoon will make you laugh, as will Holbert’s sequester cartoon. My favorite, though, is the one showing big government as a ravenous, spoiled, and destructive brat.
Glenn Foden – Going to Greece in a handbasket doesn’t seem like an obvious topic for a cartoon, but Foden pulls it off. And you’ll understand why I appreciate a cartoon that makes fun of sequester hysteria. But for what it’s worth, I think his best cartoon is the one mocking Obama’s private-sector-doing-fine assertion.
Chip Bok – He’s got a couple of amusing cartoons about Obama’s class-warfare agenda that can be seen here and here. I’m also partial to his cartoon about the Fed helping to bail out the euro. But the one that makes me laugh the hardest is his cartoon about the “war against women.”
Glenn McCoy – He has a great pair of cartoons on condoms and gay marriage, and I also like his cartoon on sequester hysteria. McCoy’s cartoon on gullible voters being bribed with their own money normally would be a contender. I don’t think there’s any question, though, that his cartoon on media bias is the best of the bunch.
A.F. Branco – Since I’m sick and tired of Obama and the special interests complaining about the supposedly savage sequester, I obviously like Branco’s cartoon portraying the sequester as a roadblock that may save us from fiscal destruction. But I’m even more partial to his cartoon riffing on Obama for his you-didn’t-build-that comment.
Unknown – Last but not least, here’s one of my favorite cartoons, though it’s really a parody of the Wizard of Id. And I don’t have any idea about who produced it. But how often do you find first-rate analysis of labor-supply incentives in a cartoon?
That was more work than I thought it would be, but I enjoyed getting a second look at many of these cartoons.
Now it’s time for your input. Which cartoon/author would you rank first?
P.S. Though I lack any artistic talent, I’ve played a role in creating some cartoons. Here’s my photo-shopped cartoon that uses Lucy and Charlie Brown to show why it is utterly naive to think that tax increases will lead to deficit reduction. I even have an award for gullible GOPers who don’t grasp this simple lesson.
We also have the famous set of cartoons showing how the welfare state begins and how it ends. These images were drawn by a Cato intern, but I selfishly take credit for developing the concept and guiding her work. Especially since these cartoons are the most-viewed post in the history of this blog.
I didn’t include either of these in the voting, though, since I’m sure they would have received all the votes. Right? Surely you agree? Hello…anybody there? Can you hear me?
[…] Let’s start with Michael Ramirez. You can see why he’s currently leading in the best-cartoonist poll. […]
[…] bad I didn’t have this Glenn Foden masterpiece when I did the political cartoonist contest last […]
[…] And here’s my favorite one, which criticized Obama’s class warfare policy and became part of my political cartoon contest. […]
[…] It very effectively captures how greedy local governments breed resentment and create conflict by using the law to fleece residents (and it definitely will be featured if I ever do another political cartoonist contest). […]
[…] P.S. Ramirez has a comfortable lead (as of today) in the best-political-cartoonist contest. […]
[…] you find this cartoon amusing, I highlighted my favorite Bok creations as part of a contest to identify the best political […]
[…] The late Jeff MacNelly was the Michael Ramirez of the Reagan generation. For example, see these cartoons about government shutdowns, the tax code, […]
[…] seen his work before, but Pat Cross probably deserves to be an after-the-fact participant in my political cartoonist contest based on these two […]
[…] I gave readers an opportunity to select their favorite political cartoonist back in 2013, they picked Michael […]
[…] I gave readers an opportunity to select their favorite political cartoonist back in 2013, they picked Michael […]
[…] If you like making your opinion heard, my most recent poll was about which state will be the first to suffer political collapse. And my favorite poll was to pick the best political cartoonist. […]
[…] 2013 publiqué una encuesta para ver a quién elegía la gente como su “viñetista político favorito”. Michael Ramirez va […]
[…] in 2013, I shared a poll to see who people would pick as their “favorite political cartoonist.” Michael Ramirez […]
[…] in 2013, I shared a poll to see who people would pick as their “favorite political cartoonist.” Michael Ramirez […]
[…] You can see why Ramirez won the political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] You can see why Ramirez won the political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] cartoons, if done correctly, are remarkably effective tools for teaching about economics and public […]
[…] cartoons, if done correctly, are remarkably effective tools for teaching about economics and public […]
[…] cartoons, if done correctly, are remarkably effective tools for teaching about economics and public […]
[…] cartoons, if done correctly, are remarkably effective tools for teaching about economics and public […]
[…] You can see why readers voted Ramirez as the best political cartoonist. […]
[…] You can see why readers voted Ramirez as the best political cartoonist. […]
[…] And here’s one from Chuck Asay, our runner-up from the cartoon contest. […]
[…] And here’s my favorite one, which criticized Obama’s class warfare policy and became part of my political cartoon contest. […]
[…] Here’s another gem from Ramirez, winner of my cartoonist contest. […]
[…] when I look back at the all-time favorites that I included in my political cartoonist contest, most of them are on that list because they make a very effective and clever point about public […]
[…] With gems like this, no wonder he came in second place in my political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] the great Michael Ramirez points out that the death panel has been very […]
[…] the great Michael Ramirez points out that the death panel has been very […]
[…] bad I didn’t have this Glenn Foden masterpiece when I did the political cartoonist contest last […]
[…] to close with a great Michael Ramirez cartoon. As you can see, there’s a reason why he won my political cartoonist contest. Indeed, if I ever do another contest, this could replace his award-winning “Julia” […]
[…] Both Benson and Payne were part of the political cartoonist contest, so you can see their best work by clicking here. […]
[…] McCoy, by the way, had a very respectable showing in my poll allowing readers to pick their favorite political cartoonist. His top cartoon, on media bias, is funny on several […]
[…] You can see why Ramirez won my political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] You can see why Ramirez won my political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] evidenced by my political cartoon contest, I’m a big fan of that form of […]
[…] evidenced by my political cartoon contest, I’m a big fan of that form of satire. And if I’m looking at cartoons specifically about […]
[…] evidenced by my political cartoon contest, I’m a big fan of that form of […]
[…] evidenced by my political cartoon contest, I’m a big fan of that form of […]
[…] Question of the Week: Who Is Your Favorite Political Cartoonist? […]
[…] can see why Michael Ramirez was the winner of my political cartoonist contest. He conveys so much with a single […]
[…] to my reader poll, Michael Ramirez is the nation’s best political […]
[…] And here’s my favorite one, which criticized Obama’s class warfare policy and became part of my political cartoon contest. […]
[…] And here’s my favorite one, which criticized Obama’s class warfare policy and became part of my political cartoon contest. […]
[…] I did my contest for best political cartoonist, I picked a cartoon about Greece and euro for Robert Ariail’s entry. While I still think that […]
[…] Here’s another gem from Ramirez, winner of my cartoonist contest. […]
[…] Here’s another gem from Ramirez, winner of my cartoonist contest. […]
[…] This cartoon is quite similar to this Chuck Asay gem, and also has the same theme as this excellent Wizard of Id parody (which tied for 5th-place in the political cartoonist contest). […]
[…] by the way, was part of my political cartoonist contest. His cartoon on Social Security and Bernie Madoff was my favorite, but the above cartoon would have […]
[…] And here’s one from Chuck Asay, our runner-up from the cartoon contest. […]
[…] And here’s one from Chuck Asay, our runner-up from the cartoon contest. […]
[…] With gems like this, no wonder he came in second place in my political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] With gems like this, no wonder he came in second place in my political cartoonist contest. […]
[…] Both Benson and Payne were part of the political cartoonist contest, so you can see their best work by clicking here. […]
[…] Both Benson and Payne were part of the political cartoonist contest, so you can see their best work by clicking here. […]
[…] Both Benson and Payne were part of the political cartoonist contest, so you can see their best work by clicking here. […]
[…] When I last checked, Henry Payne was winning the bronze medal in the contest to identify the best political cartoonist. […]
[…] When I last checked, Henry Payne was winning the bronze medal in the contest to identify the best political cartoonist. […]
[…] bad I didn’t have this Glenn Foden masterpiece when I did the political cartoonist contest last […]
[…] bad I didn’t have this Glenn Foden masterpiece when I did the political cartoonist contest last […]
Reblogged this on This Got My Attention and commented:
Who is your favorite? I like Ben at GrrrGraphics. Check it out http://grrrgraphics.wordpress.com/
I’m a liberty-minded cartoonist for a local paper. Some of my work can be seen at: http://ganarus.wordpress.com/concept-art/cartoons/
Let me know – perhaps we can work on a few cartoons together 😉 Then you can add cartoon writer or managing cartoon editor to your resume!
You have so many great cartoons. I often want to share them on Facebook or on my own blog. Is it legal for me to copy your cartoons (with credit to your blog)?