If you live in America and believe in free markets and small government, it’s easy to get depressed. We suffered through eight years of wasteful spending and misguided intervention under Bush, and now we’re enduring four years of additional spending and red tape under Obama.
Moreover, it’s not clear things will get any better in the next four years, regardless of what happens on November 6.
But whenever I begin to feel sorry for myself, I remind myself of how bad things could be if I lived in the United Kingdom.
The burden of government spending in the U.K. rose from 36.5 percent of economic output in 2000 up to 48.7 percent of GDP today. This mostly happened under Labor Party rule, but the coalition of so-called Conservatives and Liberal Democrats that took power in 2010 hasn’t done much to restrain government spending.
To augment the damage, taxes also have been increasing. The feckless Gordon Brown of the Labor Party boosted the top tax rate to 50 percent (a disaster from a Laffer-Curve perspective) before getting evicted by voters.
The Tory-Lib Dem coalition is similarly bad. In recent years, the capital gains tax has been increased (see these amusing posters to understand why this was a foolish idea), along with a big hike in the value-added tax (though, to be fair, the corporate rate has been slightly reduced and part of Gordon Brown’s higher income tax rate has been repealed).
But the Tories and Lib Dems aren’t through with their assault on the economy’s productive sector.
Both Prime Minster David Cameron and one of his deputies have argued that people have a moral obligation to turn more of their income over to the government.
And now the leader of the Lib Dems, Nick Clegg, is proposing a wealth tax. He says it will be a temporary measure until the fiscal emergency ends, but I would be shocked if politicians changed its mind after getting their hands on a new source of revenue (just look, for instance, how British politicians went crazy after first imposing an airline ticket tax).
Here are some illuminating excerpts from a column in the UK-based Telegraph.
…from what can be gleaned, the Deputy Prime Minister seemed to be suggesting a one-off or short term tax hike rather than a permanent change in the way the wealthiest are taxed. He described it as a “time limited contribution” to the “national effort” – since it was becoming clear, he said, that the country was embarked not on a “short economic battle” but a “longer economic war”. Mr Clegg said it would be “people of considerable wealth” who would be asked to make such a contribution.
It doesn’t appear that this plan will get the necessary support from the Tories, but it’s remarkable that it has been proposed. Like the death tax, the wealth tax is a turbo-charged form of double taxation.
P.S. One of the leading Lib Dem politicians got caught dodging taxes, making him the British version of America’s tax-cheating Treasury Secretary. I generally don’t object when people try to protect their income from greedy and incompetent government, but when they also are the same people proposing higher taxes on everyone else, they deserve special scorn.
P.P.S. This post is describing the current dismal fiscal situation, but the title references “a miserable and hopeless fiscal outlook.” That’s because I see no hope of good fiscal policy in the remaining years of the current government, and I suspect the statist failures of the Tory-Lib Dem coalition government will pave the way for a new Labor Party government. Needless to say, that will be – at best – jumping from one frying pan to another. Incidentally, I’m also worried about the United States for the same reason.
[…] I wrote yesterday that the United Kingdom is doomed because there isn’t a political party with the vision or courage to restrain the welfare state. […]
[…] I wrote yesterday that the United Kingdom is doomed because there isn’t a political party with the vision or courage to restrain the welfare state. […]
[…] I was very pessimistic about the U.K. in 2012, but had a more upbeat assessment last summer. Now the pendulum has now […]
[…] United Kingdom suffered a rather large decline, almost all of which happened under the profligate Blair and Brown Labour governments. This will be another nation that will be interesting to watch in coming years, particularly […]
[…] has moved in the right direction (even though the current government made some tax mistakes that led me to be very pessimistic when it first took […]
[…] about his disturbing affinity for tax hikes, but he’s been much better on spending than I thought he would […]
[…] about his disturbing affinity for tax hikes, but he’s been much better on spending than I thought he would […]
[…] me close on a positive note. I’ve expressed considerable pessimism about the future of the United Kingdom, and I think the current leadership of the supposed Conservative Party is […]
[…] Combined with the fact that Europe’s demographic outlook is rather grim, you can understand why I’m not brimming with hope for the continent. And I’ve shared specific dismal data for nations such as Portugal, France, Greece, Italy, Poland, Spain, Ireland, and the United Kingdom. […]
[…] No wonder the country now faces a very grim future. […]
[…] No wonder the country now faces a very grim future. […]
[…] wonder I”m so glum about the long-run outlook for the United […]
[…] And if Ms. Hodge really wants to criticize something evil, she should direct her ire against herself and her colleagues. They’re the ones who have put the United Kingdom on a path of bigger government and less hope. […]
[…] such as Italy, Greece, France, Spain, Ireland, Portugal, and the United Kingdom have imposed massive tax increases, yet their fiscal problems remain. Indeed, in some cases, these […]
[…] me close on a positive note. I’ve expressed considerable pessimism about the future of the United Kingdom, and I think the current leadership of the supposed Conservative Party is […]
[…] me close on a positive note. I’ve expressed considerable pessimism about the future of the United Kingdom, and I think the current leadership of the supposed Conservative Party is […]
[…] A Miserable and Hopeless Fiscal Outlook for the United Kingdom […]
[…] I wrote yesterday that the United Kingdom is doomed because there isn’t a political party with the vision or courage to restrain the welfare state. […]
[…] But getting help from England on fiscal policy is like asking for dining advice from Hannibal Lecter. […]
[…] previous posts, I’ve expressed pessimism about the future of the United Kingdom, largely because all political parties have a statist […]
[…] previous posts, I’ve expressed pessimism about the future of the United Kingdom, largely because all political parties have a statist […]
[…] I wrote yesterday that the United Kingdom is doomed because there isn’t a political party with the vision or courage to restrain the welfare state. […]
[…] warned about potential fiscal crises in France, Greece, and the United Kingdom. I’ve even noted that the United States has a very dismal future if government policy stays […]
[…] A Miserable and Hopeless Fiscal Outlook for the United Kingdom […]
[…] the cause, it’s a sorry sign for civilization. I’ve previously explained that I’m very pessimistic about the United Kingdom’s fiscal outlook. Based on this story, I also should worry about the nation’s mental […]
[…] such as Italy, Greece, France, Spain, Ireland, Portugal, and the United Kingdom have imposed massive tax increases, yet their fiscal problems remain. Indeed, in some cases, these […]
[…] such as Italy, Greece, France, Spain, Ireland, Portugal, and the United Kingdom have imposed massive tax increases, yet their fiscal problems remain. Indeed, in some cases, these […]
[…] such as Italy, Greece, France, Spain, Ireland, Portugal, and the United Kingdom have imposed massive tax increases, yet their fiscal problems remain. Indeed, in some cases, these […]
[…] Sadly, this is the exception rather than the rule. The burden of government spending is excessive in the United Kingdom, in part because of the faux budget cuts of David Cameron’s CINO regime. […]
[…] P.S. The United Kingdom is the only country where more people want to increase spending rather than cut spending. Not a good sign for that nation’s future. Seems I was quite prescient back in August. […]
[…] wrote yesterday that the United Kingdom is doomed because there isn’t a political party with the vision or courage to restrain the welfare […]
[…] wrote yesterday that the United Kingdom is doomed because there isn’t a political party with the vision or courage to restrain the welfare […]
Tax the things you want less of. Guess England wants fewer wealthy people. Curious.
Reblogged this on News You May Have Missed and commented:
A Miserable and Hopeless Fiscal Outlook for the United Kingdom