At a basic level, my attitude on patriotism is captured by this t-shirt. And hold the snarky comments. My view is not influenced by the woman modeling it.
Or, if you want something with more substance, this Penn & Teller routine is very instructive.
But this polling data, taken from a recent report from the Pew Research Center, captures what is great about American exceptionalism.
When I periodically express my patriotic feelings, I am celebrating my happiness that I live in a nation where a majority of people still favor liberty over dependency.
[…] In other words, it seems like Americans are morphing into Europeans. […]
[…] being said, other than occasional examples of cross-country polling data, I’ve never seen a good way of ranking nations based on […]
[…] In other words, it seems like Americans are morphing into Europeans. […]
[…] other words, it seems like Americans are morphing into […]
[…] the United States has been insulated from that problem because of a belief in personal responsibility. But ever-growing levels of dependency suggest that this advantage is […]
[…] don’t want America to turn into Europe, with people thinking they have a “right” to a wide array of goodies, paid for by […]
[…] of the problem is attitudinal. I’m not talking about European-wide attitudes (though that also is something to worry about, given the erosion of societal capital), but rather the views of the European […]
[…] Makes me proud to be American, just as I was back in 2011 when reporting on some Pew research that also showed Americans had a greater spirit of self reliance. […]
[…] commented before that America has a big advantage over Europe because of a greater belief in self-reliance and a greater suspicion of big […]
[…] commented before that America has a big advantage over Europe because of a greater belief in self-reliance and a greater suspicion of big […]
[…] isn’t Europe, either in terms of policy or attitudes. But I worry that we’re heading that […]
[…] isn’t Europe, either in terms of policy or attitudes. But I worry that we’re heading that […]
[…] isn’t Europe, either in terms of policy or attitudes. But I worry that we’re heading that […]
[…] it’s certainly the prevailing mindset of most […]
[…] know that there are any policy implications, but I can’t help but wonder whether America’s greater belief in self-reliance is linked to the tendency of religious people to believe in individual ethics and moral […]
[…] that there are any policy implications, but I can’t help but wonder whether America’s greater belief in self-reliance is linked to the tendency of religious people to believe in individual ethics and moral […]
[…] it’s certainly the prevailing mindset of most […]
[…] it’s certainly the prevailing mindset of most […]
[…] good news is that we’re not close to the point of no return. There is some polling data, for instance, showing that Americans still have a much stronger belief in liberty than their […]
[…] good news is that we’re not close to the point of no return. There is some polling data, for instance, showing that Americans still have a much stronger belief in liberty than their […]
[…] good news, as shown in this polling data, is that a majority of Americans still believe in individual responsibility. Let’s hope that […]
[…] we want to maintain American exceptionalism (both in theory and reality), it would be a very good idea to figure out how to avoid having more people trapped in […]
[…] My contribution to the discussion is basically a reworked version of what I wrote last week about Romney and the infamous 47 percent remark, so there’s no need to regurgitate those remarks. Suffice to say that I gave an answer of “No” because Americans don’t (yet!) share the European belief that it is government’s responsibility to provide the basics of life. […]
[…] me. I think most Americans still believe in the classical liberal vision of a small federal government. But I also think the entitlement culture is becoming a greater and […]
[…] wrote a celebratory post last November about the dramatic difference between Americans and Europeans. There truly is American […]
[…] me. I think most Americans still believe in the classical liberal vision of a small federal government. But I also think the entitlement culture is becoming a greater and […]
[…] we want to maintain American exceptionalism (both in theory and reality), it would be a very good idea to figure out how to avoid having more people trapped in […]
[…] a 2011 poll showed that Americans – unlike their European counterparts – do not believe it is government’s job […]
[…] a 2011 poll showed that Americans – unlike their European counterparts – do not believe it is […]
[…] My contribution to the discussion is basically a reworked version of what I wrote last week about Romney and the infamous 47 percent remark, so there’s no need to regurgitate those remarks. Suffice to say that I gave an answer of “No” because Americans don’t (yet!) share the European belief that it is government’s responsibility to provide the basics of life. […]
[…] by contrast, are having a hard time implementing reforms because too many of their citizens—as seen in polling data—think of government as Santa […]
[…] My contribution to the discussion is basically a reworked version of what I wrote last week about Romney and the infamous 47 percent remark, so there’s no need to regurgitate those remarks. Suffice to say that I gave an answer of “No” because Americans don’t (yet!) share the European belief that it is government’s responsibility to provide the basics of life. […]
[…] we want to maintain American exceptionalism (both in theory and reality), it would be a very good idea to figure out how to avoid having more people trapped in […]
[…] wrote a celebratory post last November about the dramatic difference between Americans and Europeans. There truly is American […]
[…] wrote a celebratory post last November about the dramatic difference between Americans and Europeans. There truly is American […]
[…] wrote a celebratory post last November about the dramatic difference between Americans and Europeans. There truly is American […]
[…] I like to think people in the United States still believe in liberty, and I’ve cited some polling data in support of American Exceptionalism. […]
[…] good news, as shown in this polling data, is that a majority of Americans still believe in individual responsibility. Let’s hope that […]
[…] One of my favorite polls, for instance, compared the degree to which Americans and Europeans think it’s okay to mooch off government. […]
[…] posted some polling data a couple of weeks ago that showed how the dependency mindset (as captured by these cartoons) is far worse in Europe than […]
[…] posted some polling data a couple of weeks ago that showed how the dependency mindset (as captured by these cartoons) is far worse in Europe than […]
[…] I’m thankful for the usual things, such as my kids and being an American. […]
I would be interested to see how the Chinese would rank if included in this survey…seems they have a better handle on capitalism and individual responsibility than many other nations…
Reblogged this on The Conservative New Ager.
To those who believe that America is not past the point of no return, to those who believe that there is still enough American exceptionalism to sustain a per capita prosperity six times the world average, I would like to remind that,
Americans elected Obama to correct Bush’s mistakes, and core American beliefs have become such that Romney is the only electable pro-growth candidate (chuckle!). In other words, the best hope is that the great American prosperity slide – which started in the 1990s complacency and arrogance of being the only superpower left on the planet, and then greatly accelerated in response to the 9/11 attacks—yes, this prosperity slide will proceed at a 2% annual rate under Romney, rather than 3% under Obama. Sure, a marked slowdown if one considers compounding, but hardly an indication that changes the final outcome: American standard of living declines away into the worldwide average.
Is this all you got left Americans? Pathetic! And enormously inadequate in a world where three billion people have finally woken up to the very ideas you once pioneered! Enjoy the ride down, these are the last few years you are enjoying on top of the world. The pitchforks are out, the delusion of top prosperity through collectivism and a flatter effort/reward curve is finally on American shores, thus the great submersion is under way… prepare your children to emigrate to environments of better opportunity… and prepare them to be treated as traitors by the pitchforks. The Desperation of Decline will bring many ugly things once inconceivable…
Communism NEVER in America! Wake up voters!
Are there past data on individualism vs mandatory collectivism beliefs? Including comparisons to the three billon people of the emerging world ? So that one may see if there is American convergence or divergence to the world average — and thus inevitably convergence to the economic prosperity average?
People DO favor liberty over dependency, but they also, currently, favor communism over our current setup with Congress. They view communism as more likely to yield that liberty than the way our republic is currently operating. And the saddest thing is that they may be right.
Can I have my attitude influenced by the message and the medium?
[…] via Dan Mitchell […]
[…] via Dan Mitchell […]
+1 for the t-shirt comment.
But who was questioned, for the statistics? 😉 !
How have those numbers changed over time? Do they simply fluctuate in a pendulous manner? Do they fluctuate in a pendulous manner around a trend?Or do they follow a particular trend?
Sorry, Dan, but if your attitude toward that t-shirt is NOT influenced by the woman modeling it, something has gone wrong.