Iain Murray of the Competitive Enterprise Institute has put together a very depressing column for National Review. To put it bluntly, he exposes the true size of the federal workforce, which has 5.5 hidden employees for every official bureaucrat.
Officially, as of 2009, the federal government employed 2.8 million individuals out of a total U.S. workforce of 236 million — just over 1 percent of the workforce. …Add in uniformed military personnel, and the figure goes up to just under 4.4 million. There are also 66,000 people who work in the legislative branch and for federal courts. That makes the figure around 2 percent of the workforce. Yet even that doesn’t tell the full story. A lot of government work is done by contractors or grantees — from arms manufacturers to local charities, from environmental-advocacy groups to university researchers. …Unfortunately, we can’t ask the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) how many government contractors and grantees there are. They don’t keep such records. …Instead, we can ask Prof. Paul Light of New York University, who has estimated the size of these shadowy branches of government. As he points out, while there are many good reasons for the government to use contractors (should the feds really be in the business of making dentures for veterans, as they were until the 1950s?), the use of contracts and grants also hides the true size of government…By 2005, the federal government employed 14.6 million people: 1.9 million civil servants, 770,000 postal workers, 1.44 million uniformed service personnel, 7.6 million contractors, and 2.9 million grantees. This amounted to a ratio of five and a half “shadow” government employees for every civil servant on the federal payroll. Since 1999, the government had grown by over 4.5 million employees. Professor Light’s figures are from 2006, but there can be little doubt that the size of the federal government has increased still further since. There are those new contractors and grantees working on “stimulus” projects to add. Then there are the employees of bailed-out and partially nationalized firms: General Motors (still owned in large part by the government despite the sale of stock in November 2010), AIG, and a large number of banks. GM alone employs 300,000 people. …Even if it grew at the same rate as it did between 1999 and 2005 (a conservative assumption), that would suggest a further 4.7 million employees dependent on taxpayer funding since 2005, bringing the total true size of the federal government to just under 20 million employees.
The video below also discusses the hidden or shadow bureaucracy (albeit briefly, around the 1:00 mark). The main focus of the mini-documentary is how bureaucrats are grossly over-compensated compared to workers in the productive sector of the economy. So the overall message is that there are far too many bureaucrats and they are paid way too much.
[…] this may be an even bigger problem. Iain Murray of the Competitive Enterprise Institute estimates that there are “five and a half ‘shadow’ government employees for every civil […]
[…] http://static.seekingalpha.com/uploa…ation_2008.png The Federal Bureaucracy: Even More Bloated When You Count the ?Shadow? Workforce | International Lib… http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/defau…heet%20GDP.jpg […]
[…] and purposes – members of the government workforce. Sort of a shadow bureaucracy that is several times larger than the official count. They get paid by our tax dollars and their jobs exist because of […]
[…] is a specific reason that the national wealth continues to accumulate in and around Washington DC: The Federal Bureaucracy: Even More Bloated When You Count the ?Shadow? Workforce | International Lib… I don't know if you folks actually believe this completely false meme that government hasn't grown […]
[…] Reason TV interview with Andrew Ferguson explains that there is a huge shadow workforce of contractors, consultants, and lobbyists who have their snouts buried deeply in the public […]
[…] There are millions of government contractors, for instance, and many of those people should be considered part of a “shadow bureaucracy.” Too often, they’re doing things that are just as wasteful and inefficient as their bureaucrat […]
[…] 1.44 million uniformed service personnel, 7.6 million contractors, and 2.9 million grantees. The Federal Bureaucracy: Even More Bloated When You Count the ?Shadow? Workforce | International Lib… I guess it's too much to ask that the lefties stick to facts when making their OP's? You had to […]
[…] use of consultants and contractors has skyrocketed. It is what is known as the shadow bureaucracy: The Federal Bureaucracy: Even More Bloated When You Count the ?Shadow? Workforce | International Lib… Is it too much to ask that the left refrain from using false and misleading stats to argue their […]
The fact that is omitted here is that contractors can be dismissed much more easily than federal employees. Actually, I should say that it is possible to get rid of a contractor while it is nearly impossible to fire federal civil servants. As we sail over the fiscal cliff, look for heavy layoffs to hit the contractor ranks while federal employees remain securely ensconced in their sinecures.
[…] what about unofficial government workforce of over-paid contractors? And all the lobbyists, consultants, and cronyists that exist only because we have a bloated […]
[…] what about unofficial government workforce of over-paid contractors? And all the lobbyists, consultants, and cronyists that exist only because we have a bloated […]
[…] federal bureaucrats are wildly overpaid, as I document in this video, and also because there is a huge shadow workforce of contractors, consultants, and lobbyists who have their snouts buried deeply in the public […]
[…] The only bit of semi-good news for Wisconsin taxpayers is that state and local bureaucrats are not as lavishly over-compensated as federal bureaucrats. […]
[…] The only bit of semi-good news for Wisconsin taxpayers is that state and local bureaucrats are not as lavishly over-compensated as federal bureaucrats. […]
[…] The only bit of semi-good news for Wisconsin taxpayers is that state and local bureaucrats are not as lavishly over-compensated as federal bureaucrats. […]
[…] The only bit of semi-good news for Wisconsin taxpayers is that state and local bureaucrats are not as lavishly over-compensated as federal bureaucrats. […]
[…] The only bit of semi-good news for Wisconsin taxpayers is that state and local bureaucrats are not as lavishly over-compensated as federal bureaucrats. […]
[…] The only bit of semi-good news for Wisconsin taxpayers is that state and local bureaucrats are not as lavishly over-compensated as federal bureaucrats. […]