The world is a laboratory, with lots of experiments to see if a nation can prosper with big government and pervasive intervention.
The results are not encouraging. I’ve written about France being a basket case, over and over again.
And I am equally pessimistic about Greece because the moochers and looters outnumber productive people in that country.
Heck, much of Europe is a mess because of widespread statism.
But the rest of the world is filled with bad examples as well. Japan has attracted my critical attention, and I have very little reason to think that nation has a bright future.
I’ve also dinged bad policy in Mexico and South Africa, so nobody can accuse me of being parsimonious when it comes to criticizing politicians that promote big government.
But the country that may be in the deepest trouble is Italy.
To understand the depth of the problem, you should read a recent article in the U.K.-based Spectator.
Here are some excerpts, starting with an anecdote about the government-funded opera house in Rome.
Financed and managed by the state, and therefore crippled by debt, the opera house — like so much else in Italy — had been a jobs-for-life trade union fiefdom. Its honorary director, Riccardo Muti, became so fed up after dealing with six years of work-to-rule surrealism that he resigned. It’s hard to blame him. The musicians at the opera house — the ‘professori’ — work a 28-hour week (nearly half taken up with ‘study’) and get paid 16 months’ salary a year, plus absurd perks such as double pay for performing in the open air because it is humid and therefore a health risk. Even so, in the summer, Muti was compelled to conduct a performance of La Bohème with only a pianist because the rest of the orchestra had gone on strike.
The story says all the staff eventually were fired.
Is that a sign that policy makers in Italy are sobering up? Or is it too little, too late?
The author of the column, Nicholas Farrell, is not optimistic.
Italy’s irreversible demise is a foregone conclusion. The country is just too much of a basket case even to think about. …The youth unemployment rate here is 43 per cent — the highest on record. That figure doesn’t factor in the black market, which is so big that the Italian government now wants to include certain parts of it — prostitution, drug dealing and assorted smuggling — into its official GDP figures. …Just 58 per cent of working-age Italians are employed, compared with an average 65 per cent in the developed world. …Italy’s economy has been stagnant since 2000. Indeed, over the past five years it has shrunk by 9.1 per cent. …Italy’s sovereign debt, meanwhile, continues to grow exponentially. It is now €2.2 trillion, which is the equivalent of 135 per cent of GDP — the third highest in the world after Japan and Greece. …In Italy, as in France, a dirigiste philosophy has predominated since the second world war. The government is run like a protection racket… Even newspapers are publicly subsidised, which is why there are so many of them.
But high debt in Italy isn’t because of low taxes.
Anyone who works in the real private sector — the family businesses that have made Italy’s name around the world — is in a bad place. Italy has the heaviest ‘total tax’ burden on businesses in the world at 68 per cent… To start a business in Italy is to enter a Kafkaesque bureaucratic nightmare, and to keep it going is even worse. It also means handing the state at least 50 cents for every euro paid to staff.
So where do all this tax money go?
Not surprisingly, there’s a parasitic public sector that is very well compensated. Starting with the politicians.
Italian MPs are the highest paid in the civilised world, earning almost twice the salary of a British MP. Barbers in the Italian Parliament get up to €136,120 a year gross. All state employees get a fabulous near-final–salary pension. It is not difficult to appreciate the fury of the average Italian private sector worker, whose gross annual pay is €18,000. The phrase ‘you could not make it up’ fits the gold-plated world of the Italian state employee to a tee — especially in the Mezzo-giorno, Italy’s hopeless south. Sicily, for instance, employs 28,000 forestry police — more than Canada — and has 950 ambulance drivers who have no ambulances to drive.
I gather Sicily is like the Illinois of Italy, so those horrifying numbers don’t surprise me.
And don’t forget that Italy’s representative in the Bureaucrat Hall of Fame is from Sicily as well.
So what’s the solution to this mess?
Simple, adopt a policy of small government and free markets.
An Italian government that really meant business would make urgent and drastic cuts not just to the bloated, parasitical and corrupt state sector, but also to taxes, labour costs and red tape.
And the current Prime Minister, to be fair, is proposing baby steps in the right direction. Unfortunately, he’s being far too timid.
To get an idea of the magnitude of the problem, the Wall Street Journal opined on Italian labor markets, explaining that “pro-worker” interventions by government impose very high costs.
Led by the country’s largest union, the Italian General Confederation of Labor, or CGIL, the activists want to preserve Italy’s job guarantees as they are. Call it Italy’s economic suicide movement. …there is the Cassa Integrazione Guadagni. Under this income-assistance scheme, businesses that need to downsize can put some workers on “standby,” and the government will cover a significant share of the normal salary until the company can hire back the worker. The program strains the state’s budget, discourages workers from seeking other jobs, and prevents struggling companies from downsizing to stay competitive. Need to fire a worker for poor job performance? To do so, businesses must persuade a judge that no alternative short of termination was available—a process of administrative hearings and litigation that can take months and drain company resources. The World Economic Forum in its 2014-15 assessment of labor-market efficiency ranked Italy 141 out of 144 countries for hiring and firing practices, just above Zimbabwe.
And the biggest victim of the “pro-worker” interventions are…you guessed it…workers.
Italy has the largest number of small businesses in the European Union not because companies don’t want to grow, but because they fear growth will mean having to negotiate with the militant national unions like CGIL. The unsurprising result of all these barriers to firing and efficiency is that businesses are reluctant to hire. The official unemployment rate stands at 12%, and half of Italy’s young people are unemployed.
If you want more info about Italy’s dysfunctional labor markets, I also shared some good analysis from the WSJ back in 2012.
Let’s now circle back to a question asked above. Can Italy be saved?
Like Mr. Farrell, I’m not optimistic. There’s no pro-market political party in Italy. And the so-called technocrats have demonstrated amazing levels of incompetence, so they’re obviously not the solution.
P.S. There is one tiny bit of semi-good news from Italy. Over the past 8 years, government spending has increased, on average, by just 1.6 percent per year. The bad news, though, is that the private sector has grown at an even slower rate, so the actual burden of government spending has increased.
Between 1996-2000, by contrast, government spending grew by 1.1 percent per year. But since the private sector was growing, the burden of government spending fell as a share of GDP.
In other words, when you satisfy Mitchell’s Golden Rule, good things happen.
P.P.S. Even though Italy is a complete mess (or perhaps because it is a complete mess), you won’t be surprised to learn that a New York Times columnist thinks America should adopt Italian-style government policies.
P.P.P.S. Then again, American statists have been urging European-type statism in the United States for decades. To see where that leads, check out these cartoons from Michael Ramirez, Glenn Foden, Eric Allie and Chip Bok.
[…] other words, it’s not a good idea to copy nations such as France, Italy, and […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] policy is part of the problem, of course, but this chart shows that the country also is facing a demographic crisis. The blue […]
[…] briefly addressed this topic in early 2016, but only to make a point about the (myriad) problems of modern […]
[…] warned many times that Italy is the next […]
[…] Wow, makes me wonder if Italy has passed the point of no return. […]
[…] already speculated about whether Italy has “passed the point of no return.” If the Five Star Movement wins […]
[…] the size and scope of government. Perhaps now it’s easy to understand why I fear the country may have passed the tipping point. You can be in a downward spiral even if policy doesn’t […]
[…] the size and scope of government. Perhaps now it’s easy to understand why I fear the country may have passed the tipping point. You can be in a downward spiral even if policy doesn’t […]
[…] I realize that sounds crazy given Italy’s awful fiscal system and grim outlook. But there’s actually a new special tax regime to lure wealthy foreigners. […]
[…] I realize that sounds crazy given Italy’s awful fiscal system and grim outlook. But there’s actually a new special tax regime to lure wealthy foreigners. […]
[…] Pour le dire simplement, je crains que l’Italie, parmi d’autres pays du « Club Med », ait dépassé le point de non-retour en matière d’étatisme, de déclin démographique et de dépendance sociétale. Et cela signifie […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] stated, I fear that Italy, along with certain other “Club Med” nations, has passed the point of no return in terms of big government, demographic decline, and societal […]
[…] “good news” is that there is some awareness that the nation faces a double-disaster of statism and unfriendly […]
[…] “good news” is that there is some awareness that the nation faces a double-disaster of statism and unfriendly […]
[…] to describe the economy. That word would be much more appropriate for failed welfare states such as Italy […]
[…] to describe the economy. That word would be much more appropriate for failed welfare states such as Italy and […]
[…] all intents and purposes, they’re advising nations in the region to copy France and Italy instead of seeking to be more like Hong Kong and […]
[…] all intents and purposes, they’re advising nations in the region to copy France and Italy instead of seeking to be more like Hong Kong and […]
[…] the Swiss ultimately aren’t interested, the Sardinians at least would have a chance to escape Italy’s dysfunctional economic policies if they became […]
[…] the case of Italy, both reasons probably apply. Government debt already is very high in Italy and growth is virtually nonexistent, so it’s presumably just a matter of time before the Italians will be looking for Greek-style […]
[…] Kong, Switzerland, Texas, or Singapore), it’s also good to have bad examples (such as France, Italy, California, and […]
[…] all, Greece, Italy, and France are not exactly role […]
[…] all, Greece, Italy, and France are not exactly role […]
[…] it Italy, which has some of the most coddled government bureaucrats in the […]
Check the demographics of Sweden, Snorri Godhi. Then check the CURRENT demographics of Italy. Under EU immigration law…
Perhaps the main trouble with Italy is that people in the political class lack 3 things: (1) a backbone and (2) and (3) balls.
NB: Thatcher, notwithstanding evidence to the contrary, had all 3.
Having said that, this is just wrong:
“In Italy, as in France, a dirigiste philosophy has predominated since the second world war.”
No: in Italy, it predominated since the early 1960s, when the Socialist Party joined the Christian Democrats in government.
BTW Berlusconi got rich while associated with the Socialist Party — a disclaimer: correlation does not imply causation.
“Even newspapers are publicly subsidised, which is why there are so many of them.”
I didn’t know about that, but it is, or used to be, true in Sweden, and for all its faults Sweden has not passed the point of no return.
I wonder what would happen if the Mafia were allowed to take over the country.
My bet is that there would be significant – and rapid – improvement.
GOOD NEWS. AT LAST. The Safety Net cut Poverty nearly in half last (2013) year. Unemployment down to 5.7% was a big factor. In all ages poverty fell from 28.1% to 15.5% and in those under 18 in age it fell from 27.5 to 16.4% Now, if Koch Tea Partiers will jump in the ocean we can get the much needed increase in the Minimum Wage. Seventeen million will get the needed wage increase. When Clinton increased it by 49%, GDP had a sudden jump of 58 points and a big jump in employment. The additional spending surge created a need for people to service and unemployment dropped to a low 3.9%. clarence swinney
The current prime minister of Italy has proposed modest labor pro-market reforms. Result: one million Italians took to the streets in protest.
Yes, Italy and its people are deadlocked into decline. Everyone depends on everybody else now, nobody can let go, and, naturally, nobody can muster the aggregate enthusiasm to become competitive internationally.
Yes Italy passed the tipping point long ago. Only when it bottoms out — soviet style — there will finally be reform. But there’s still a long way to go. Especially since the modest productivity of other marginally competitive European nations is there to be consumed by the Italian people on their way down.
But can Italy, France and Spain really consume the modest production reserves left in the rest of Europe? The combined populations of these three countries form a pan-European majority. So, “Yes they can!”
And so decline they will, taking with them the rest of the moribund European continent. American HopNChange has indeed found a really successful system to copy and emulate. While I think that the tipping point for Italy passed a long time ago, I believe it has also passed for America. The tipping point for America was 2008, when Americans plagued by problems brought upon by statism, opted for even more statism.
Why so little about Islamic states? And what about them? Is Islam is a illiberal and thoroughly statist cult?
Look at the growth rates of Dar al-Islam (Arabic: دار الإسلام literally house/abode of Islam). What do you find? What does long term experience in every Islamic state suggest about Muhammad’s darnomy? You should be familiar by now with zakat, the redistribution pillar of Islam often wrongly described too narrowly as being for the poor. In fact, three or four of eight categories of recipients can be people, other than the poor, such as bureaucrats and nonmuslims who are helpful to the totalitarian cause. More importantly, this pillar is used to suck in and keep bleeding hearts and to provide an excuse for Islamic statism, for zakat is supposed to be implemented by an Islamic state.
P.S. Your golden rule is interesting. It admits the possibility of both growth rates, the private sector’s and the government’s, being negative while still satisfying the rule that the former should be greater than the latter.