If I asked you what Donald Trump and Bono have in common, the easy and accurate answer is that they both have lots of money.
But if I asked you to identify a shared perspective by the two men, at first glance that would seem to be a much harder
question.
After all, it seems like a rock star and a real-estate tycoon are about as different as two people could possibly be.
Yet the answer should be obvious.
I’ll give you a big hint. You probably have the same perspective as well.
At least if you answer “no” to the first question and “yes” to the second question.
- Do you ever voluntarily pay extra tax?
- Or do you, like John Kerry or Bill and Hillary Clinton, take prudent steps to minimize the amount of your income confiscated by government?
In other words, the perspective shared by Donald Trump and Bono is one that is widely held by every sensible person. Simply stated, your income belongs in your pocket, not in the grasping hands of politicians.
This irks politicians such as David Cameron in the U.K., who seem to think we have some sort of moral obligation to help finance their vote-buying efforts.
But I bet almost all of us agree with Trump’s view. Here are some excerpts from a CNN report.
Trump was unambiguous. “I pay as little as possible,” he said. “I fight like hell to pay as little as possible, for two reasons. Number one, I’m a businessman, and that’s the way you’re supposed to do it, and you put the money back into your company and employees and all of that.” “But the other reason is that I hate the way our government spends our taxes. I hate the way they waste our money. Trillions and trillions of dollars of waste and abuse and I hate it,” Trump said. “And I’ll be probably the first candidate in the history of politics within this country to say, I try — by the way, like every single taxpayer out there — I try to pay as little tax as possible, and again, one of the big reasons is I hate what our country does with the money that we pay.”
Amen.
As an economist, I don’t want tax increases because the economy will be hurt and workers will suffer.
But what upsets me at a visceral level is the notion of sending more money to DC when there’s so much waste, fraud, and abuse.
And I suspect tens of millions of other Americans agree that it would be foolish to reward the wasteful antics of Washington politicians with more of our money.
Which is why almost all of us also agree with Bono’s view. As reported by the U.K.-based Mirror, Bono says it is very “sensible” to minimize tax and that it would be “stupid” to behave otherwise.
Members of U2 have hit back at claims they shield millions of pounds in overseas tax havens – claiming they are just “being sensible”. In an interview with Sky News, lead singer Bono insisted the band pays a fortune in tax and it was the right decision to move some of their business to the Netherlands. “It is just some smart people we have working for us trying to be sensible about the way we are taxed,” he said. …“Because you’re good at philanthropy and because I am an activist people think you should be stupid in business and I don’t run with that.”
Bingo, he’s exactly right.
Indeed, even though I’ve praised Bono’s economic analysis in the past, I suspect he doesn’t even understand how right he is.
Because he’s not just doing what’s right from his band’s perspective, he’s also doing what’s right for the rest of us as well.
P.S. While I’m glad lots of leftists seek to minimize their tax burdens, it would be better if they weren’t such total hypocrites.
[…] IRS, Sanders showed typical statist hypocrisy by giving the same reason used by every rich person (including Trump) and every big […]
[…] Trump paid so much tax? I realize I’m a curmudgeonly libertarian, but I was one of the people who applauded Trump for saying that he does everything possible to minimize the amount of money he turns over to the […]
[…] Trump paid so much tax? I realize I’m a curmudgeonly libertarian, but I was one of the people who applauded Trump for saying that he does everything possible to minimize the amount of money he turns over to the […]
[…] happened a lot during the campaign, as Trump would say very good things one day and then say very bad things the next […]
[…] I pointed out in this interview, Trump did nothing wrong based on the information we now have. Nothing morally wrong. Nothing legally wrong. Nothing economically […]
[…] commend Trump when he says something accurate or when he proposes good policies, and I defend him when he’s […]
[…] government or smaller government. Higher taxes or lower taxes. More intervention or less. Sometimes he says things I like. Sometimes he says things that irk […]
[…] government or smaller government. Higher taxes or lower taxes. More intervention or less. Sometimes he says things I like. Sometimes he says things that irk […]
[…] shameful and illegitimate. But I doubt they’ll make much progress since no rational person (not even Bono or Donald Trump) voluntarily pays more to the government than is legally […]
[…] shameful and illegitimate. But I doubt they’ll make much progress since no rational person (not even Bono or Donald Trump) voluntarily pays more to the government than is legally […]
[…] shameful and illegitimate. But I doubt they’ll make much progress since no rational person (not even Bono or Donald Trump) voluntarily pays more to the government than is legally […]
[…] So France wants to punish Panama, even though Panama already has agreed to help enforce bad French tax laws. Meanwhile, President Obama reflexively wants to punish taxpayers who have the temerity and gall to not voluntarily over-pay their taxes (an issue where Donald Trump actually said something sensible). […]
[…] sometimes says things indicating that he understands Washington is a cesspool of waste. But on other occasions, he seems to be singing off the same song sheet as Bernie […]
[…] sometimes says things indicating that he understands Washington is a cesspool of waste. But on other occasions, he seems to be singing off the same song sheet as Bernie […]
[…] have to give Trump credit for dominating the election. Whether he’s making dumb statements or smart statements, he knows how to work the […]
[…] there’s nothing wrong – legally or ethically – with taxpayers choosing not to overpay the federal […]
[…] I did like what he said about wanting to pay as little tax as possible because the government wastes so much of our […]
[…] I did like what he said about wanting to pay as little tax as possible because the government wastes so much of our […]
I hate to pay taxes. It’s even more egregious when you take a close look at how my money is being wasted by ridiculous government programs. The waste and fraud is icing on the already spoiled cake. http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/oct/22/tom-coburn-highlights-ridiculous-government-spendi/?page=all
I’ll add to this that liberals not only personally behave rationally and try to minimize their taxes, if they have extra money they wish to use to help people they don’t give it to government. They give it to private charity. Even Obama gives his extra money to charity to help people rather than to the federal government he runs.
Since they acknowledge that it is better to give money to private charities than to government, they should allow us the freedom to give more of our money to charities instead of government. We should copy an idea from the notion of school vouchers or tax credits that seek to create competition to government run schools. Charitable donations should be a tax *credit* rather than a deduction. The concept is simple, but the details may be tricky, this page goes into the idea further:
http://www.politicsdebunked.com/government-fails-the-poor
[…] Reposted from International Liberty. […]