What’s the most important factor for economic progress?
There are several possible answers to that question. We can take a big-picture view and argue that the key is free markets and small government, and there certainly is lots of evidence in favor of this assertion when you compare countries over time.
But what if we narrow our focus and try to identify, for instance, the key characteristic of a free market. At times, I’ve highlighted the importance of both property rights and the price system.
Private property gives people the right incentives to both produce and conserve, a lesson learned early in American history.
An unfettered price system is a mechanism that best ensures resources are efficiently utilized to serve consumers.
But we need to augment this list by also including the valuable role of the profit motive.
This Prager University video, narrated by my friend Walter Williams, succinctly explains the issue.
I especially like the section where Walter asks what institutions and entities leave us happy and contented. The answer, at least for most of us, is that we’re more likely to be satisfied in our dealing with private companies operating in competitive markets.
That’s because the profit motive gives them an incentive to treat us well, both to boost their reputations and so we’ll be repeat customers.
Simply stated, in a true free market, entrepreneurs, investors, and business owners can only become rich by providing consumers with things that make our lives better.
But our dealings with government (or government-enforced monopolies like cable companies) tend to be less rewarding, whether it’s because bureaucrats are taking our money, bossing us around, or simply treating us poorly.
So the next time some politician or pundit complains about “evil profits,” just remember Walter’s wise words from the video.
P.S. I’ve shared two other videos from Prager University, one of the Laffer Curve and one about statist policies and the Great Depression. They’ve both very much worth watching.
P.P.S. It goes without saying (but I’ll say it anyhow) that profits are only admirable if they’re earned honestly. There are fraudsters in private markets who rip off consumers and there are crony capitalists who use coercive government policies to line their pockets. These groups deserve disdain and punishment.
P.P.P.S. Walter Williams is one of America’s best public intellectuals. I’ve cited his work numerous times, but your first stop, in learning more about him, is this video from Reason TV.
[…] making. Does he think companies shouldn’t try to make profits? Does he not understand the purpose of profits? Does he want to put corporate governance under the control of politicians, like Elizabeth […]
[…] Here are excerpts from his analysis of socialism and profits: […]
[…] Here are excerpts from his analysis of socialism and profits. […]
[…] as Walter Williams has eloquently explained, businesses perform a very valuable social purpose when they earn […]
[…] their “soulless” pursuit of those profits (as explained by Walter Williams) will lead them to be efficient and innovative, which boosts overall economic […]
[…] their “soulless” pursuit of those profits (as explained by Walter Williams) will lead them to be efficient and innovative, which boosts overall economic […]
[…] stated, profit and loss is a powerful feedback mechanism, and entrepreneurs and business owners who want to make money face constant pressure to attract […]
[…] stated, profit and loss is a powerful feedback mechanism, and entrepreneurs and business owners who want to make money face constant pressure to attract […]
[…] economy. Every success and every mistake leads to feedback, both via the price system and also via profits and losses. All of which leads to continuous changes as people – especially entrepreneurs – seek […]
[…] That cronyism is lucrative (I deliberately chose that word rather than “profitable” because money that it legitimately earned is very honorable). […]
[…] said “Lucrative” instead of “Profitable.” After all, as Walter Williams has explained that profit is a meritorious reward for serving […]
[…] instead of “Profitable.” After all, as Walter Williams has explained that profit is a meritorious reward for serving […]
[…] is very compelling, but the most persuasive part of the video is at the beginning when she asks why profit-seeking businesses don’t fire men and hire women if there really is a wage […]
[…] cash” rather than “profit” because I think of the latter as money that is fairly earned in a competitive marketplace, whereas the earnings of the GSE’s are the result of an artificial, subsidized, and protected […]
[…] This video on profit, narrated by Walter Williams, is a good addition to the insight of Smith and […]
[…] Three Cheers for Profits and Free Markets […]
[…] This video on profit, narrated by Walter Williams, is a good addition to the insight of Smith and […]
[…] You can enjoy other great videos from Prager University by clicking here, here, here, here, here, and […]
[…] This video on profit, narrated by Walter Williams, is a good addition to the insight of Smith and […]
[…] If you enjoyed this video, you’ll also like other Prager University videos, including ones on profits, the Laffer Curve, and the Great […]
Here is my take on profit:
https://dickrichardsky.wordpress.com/2014/11/25/profit-the-evil-demon/
[…] WAIT, THERE’S MORE… […]
[…] By Dan Mitchell […]