Nope, the answer isn’t smoking. Or fatty food. Or 16 oz. sodas.
And it’s not alcohol, driving too fast, or standing between politicians and a TV camera.
In the past 100 years or so, the biggest cause of premature death has been government.
Back in 2011, while criticizing the Baltimore Symphony for using the Soviet hammer and sickle in a promotion, I linked to a website showing how many millions of people were murdered by the dictators who ruled the Soviet Union.
You’ll find similar data in this video, as well as some equally shocking numbers for other examples of democide (death by government).
I don’t know if all the numbers in the video are right. I don’t even know if the government bought 1.6 billion hollow point bullets. And I certainly hope our tax dollars didn’t help finance Pol Pot’s democide in Cambodia.
But I fully agree that government is the greatest killer of all time.
This doesn’t mean, by the way, that I think all governments are equally evil. I wouldn’t even make the claim that there’s a link between big government and democide (though that’s probably true given the track record of National Socialists in Germany and Soviet Socialists in China and the Soviet Union).
Instead, I’ll simply regurgitate some of what I wrote back in August.
…be thankful that there are some libertarians willing to raise a stink about government even if the rest of the world thinks we’re a bit odd. As we’ve seen dozens of times, most recently with the IRS and NSA, bureaucrats and politicians have a compulsive tendency to grab more power and make government more intrusive. …I’ll end today’s post by mentioning the fable of the frog that gets put in a pot of water and doesn’t jump out because the temperature feels comfortable. But then the heat is slowly raised and the frog no longer has the energy to escape when he finally figures out he’s being cooked. Well, libertarians are the ones who loudly complain when the government puts us into pots.
In other words, governments are less likely to do really awful things if there are some of us fighting when they do mildly bad things.
Don’t forget that when enough mildly bad things occur and you get economic stagnation, one result is the kind of social chaos and rioting that has occurred in some European nations.
And those are the conditions that sometimes lead to takeovers by the types of governments that do really awful things.
Let’s close with two bits of satire. First, here’s something I saw on Twitter. It’s for the statists who claim that communism is a good theory, but that it hasn’t been properly implemented.
Needless to say, I can’t see the appeal of a theory that says we are slaves to each other. But the point of this poster is that real-world communism is always about murder and oppression.
Second, this is a good opportunity to emphasize one of the messages from the end of the video.
A common trait of dictators is that they want the citizenry disarmed.
This poster is the fourth-most viewed post I’ve ever produced. But not because I said anything clever.
Instead, people like this poster and share it with their friends because it makes a very important point about the dangers of unlimited state power.
So what’s the moral of the story? I guess the message is that small government is tolerable. Medium-sized government is bad. And unlimited government is horrible.
Actually, George Washington said the same thing with much greater clarity: “Government is not reason; it is not eloquent; it is force. Like fire, it is a dangerous servant and a fearful master.”
P.S. I suppose this shouldn’t be a joking matter, but here’s an amusing look at communist efficiency from the Beijing Olympics.
P.P.S. And the fourth video at this link has some great examples of Reagan’s use of humor against communism.
[…] Soviet Union was awful. It killed at least 20 million of its own people (some say as many as 60 million). It enslaved and impoverishedits own citizens, as well as those who languished behind the “Iron […]
[…] Soviet Union was awful. It killed at least 20 million of its own people (some say as many as 60 million). It enslaved and impoverished its own citizens, as well as those who languished behind the […]
So the linked sources and fact checking on these garbage strawmanned to the moon articles are not really facts at all, or checked. Hahahahaha. “100,000,000 dead, just take our word for it it’s all from governments which equal communism. Derpy herpin derpin derp herp derp. Ready for a strawman that calls out capitalism for the murder of 1 BILLION people?
[…] https://danieljmitchell.wordpress.com/2013/12/28/the-biggest-risk-factor-leading-to-premature-death-… […]
[…] These are the nutjobs who claim that “real communism hasn’t been tried.” […]
[…] Source: The Biggest Risk Factor Leading to Premature Death Is…? | International Liberty […]
[…] first item is a simple graph showing the relationship historical knowledge and trust in […]
[…] we have a big of humor involving two of history’s biggest mass murderers, Stalin and […]
[…] we have warning signs about all sorts of things, but not about the the biggest threat we […]
[…] written extensively about gun control, but mostly because of practical and moral objections to the notion that government should have the power to disarm law-abiding […]
[…] we have another reminder that government was the most dangerous entity in the 20th century (and presumably in all […]
[…] Moreover, I think it’s safe to say that coronavirus won’t come close to killing as many people as the various strains of socialism. […]
[…] he’s definitely correct in stating that there are much more important reasons to despise Nazis other than their version of socialism (private ownership, but government control, […]
[…] both slaughter millions of […]
[…] it’s definitely true that governments historically have the worst track record of […]
[…] In the past, I’ve mocked leftists for trying to explain away real-world failures with the excuse that “real communism hasn’t been tried.” […]
Reblogged this on Truth Is Power.
[…] to mock socialism and communism, let’s never forget the horrific suffering and death that these evil ideologies have […]
[…] written extensively about gun control, but mostly because of practical and moral objections to the notion that government should have the power to disarm law-abiding […]
[…] So it’s hardly a surprise that it produced awful results. Including mass starvation. […]
[…] So it’s hardly a surprise that it produced awful results. Including mass starvation. […]
[…] a grim relationship not only between socialism and economic failure, but also that the ideology has a long list of […]
[…] both slaughter millions of […]
[…] both slaughter millions of […]
[…] the image is funny, the real-world consequences are […]
[…] we have a variation of the “real communism” or “real socialism” […]
[…] that’s even become a humorous theme (see here, here, and here from my collection of socialism/communism […]
[…] what point does the left admit that “real communism” is brutality and […]
[…] here’s a reappearance of the real-communism-hasn’t-been-tried […]
[…] click here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here […]
[…] here, here, here, and here for other examples). For our first item, we’re going to mock the leftist claim that communism has never failed because various totalitarian regimes were not examples of […]
[…] – This is probably Prager’s weakest point. He’s right that bad people do very bad things when they control a government, but I suspect western nations will suffer societal breakdown rather […]
[…] first one is the sarcastic version of a 2013 column that included a poster mocking people who claim that communism has never been […]
[…] forms of totalitarianism are bad, oftentimes resulting in mass murder. As Dennis Prager noted in his video, both communism and Nazism are horrid ideologies. Yet for some […]
[…] forms of totalitarianism are bad, oftentimes resulting in mass murder. As Dennis Prager noted in his video, both communism and Nazism are horrid ideologies. Yet for […]
[…] forms of totalitarianism are bad, oftentimes resulting in mass murder. As Dennis Prager noted in his video, both communism and Nazism are horrid ideologies. Yet for […]
[…] forms of totalitarianism are bad, oftentimes resulting in mass murder. As Dennis Prager noted in his video, both communism and Nazism are horrid ideologies. Yet for some […]
[…] forms of totalitarianism are bad, oftentimes resulting in mass murder. As Dennis Prager noted in his video, both communism and Nazism are horrid ideologies. Yet for some […]
[…] a very nice collection. Click here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here for […]
[…] a very nice collection. Click here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here for […]
[…] is the same message you find here, here, and […]
[…] is the same message you find here, here, and […]
[…] One expert looked at the Rand Corporation estimates that such policies would lead to a decline in life expectancy of 0.7 years by 2016. He then crunched the numbers and concluded that the aggregate impact would be worse thing to ever happen. Even worse than the brutality of Mao’s China. […]
[…] One expert looked at the Rand Corporation estimates that such policies would lead to a decline in life expectancy of 0.7 years by 2016. He then crunched the numbers and concluded that the aggregate impact would be worse thing to ever happen. Even worse than the brutality of Mao’s China. […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon a […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon a […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon a nation. Dictators like Stalin, Mao, Pol […]
[…] should be remembered first and foremost for the death, brutality, and repression that occurred whenever that evil system was imposed upon a […]
[…] And the only thing worse than that is the final layer of statist hell, which features countries that actually butcher their own citizens. […]
[…] that’s not a good idea if you’re a paranoid libertarian like me. But even if you have a more benign view of […]
[…] Communism is a disgusting system that butchered more than 100,000,000 people. […]
[…] Communism is a disgusting system that butchered more than 100,000,000 people. […]
[…] Communism is a disgusting system that butchered more than 100,000,000 people. […]
[…] Communism is a disgusting system that butchered more than 100,000,000 people. […]
Parsel Tongue is absolutely incorrect. This statement is thrown up again and again and is entirely false. The greatest murderer of all time was Genghis Khan … nothing to do with religion. Then Mao, then Stalin, then Hitler … again, nothing to do with religion. Let’s look at Pol Pot, Idi Amin, and a host of others in Asia and Africa. Again, nothing to do with religion. How about U.S. history: Revolutionary War, War of 1812, Mexican War, Civil War, Indian Wars, Spanish-American War, WW1, WW2, Korean War, Vietnam, etc. Nothing to do with religion.
[…] It’s the socialism version of this communism image. […]
[…] It’s the socialism version of this communism image. […]
[…] If you’re curious how the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia rank compared to other evil regimes, they only killed a tiny fraction of the death toll achieved by the Soviet Union and Maoist China. […]
[…] If you’re curious how the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia rank compared to other evil regimes, they only killed a tiny fraction of the death toll achieved by the Soviet Union and Maoist China. […]
[…] Of course, that’s not where the story really ends. The cartoon needs a few more frames to commemorate the 100 million-plus people butchered by communism. […]
[…] Of course, that’s not where the story really ends. The cartoon needs a few more frames to commemorate the 100 million-plus people butchered by communism. […]
[…] I’m not sure why, but I can’t help but suspect that statists want people to depend on government. Even if that means they are more vulnerable. And even though governments historically are the biggest threats to human existence! […]
[…] be a permanent memorial about the evil of communism. And if you want further reminders, click here, here, and […]
[…] be a permanent memorial about the evil of communism. And if you want further reminders, click here, here, and […]
[…] The next two images make the philosophical point that we shouldn’t leave all guns in the hands of government, particularly given some horrible results from the 20th century. […]
[…] The Biggest Risk Factor Leading to Premature Death Is…? […]
Reblogged this on Neverending1's Blog and commented:
Why I do not believe in gun control. Neverending1
Reblogged this on Foodforthethinkers's Blog.
http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/visualizations/20th-century-death/
I’m afraid you aren’t even close to being accurate according to the World Health Organization. Drugs, alone, have killed almost as many as ideology.
The figure of 50 million people killed by Europeans in Africa, if taken from RJ Rummel’s website, is probably exaggerated. Rummel simply extrapolated from the Belgian Congo (or: Congo “Free State”) I believe.
Actually British colonialism was probably good for Africa — by keeping parts of it out of the grasp of the Belgians, French, and Germans. I say this without much sympathy for _modern_ Britain.
The US government bankrolling Pol Pot sounds like a conspiracy theory to me: if we have to blame the Americans, let’s blame them for bankrolling Stalin and whitewashing the Holodomor.
In human history, I read somewhere that the greatest killer by far has been malaria, but I don’t know if it’s true. In any case, governments contributed and still contribute to the death toll, by inhibiting economic development.
To this cheerful note, I add a belated Merry Christmas and early wishes for a happy 2014.
[…] The Biggest Risk Factor Leading to Premature Death Is…? (danieljmitchell.wordpress.com) […]
wonder what the 2013 body count is………… and how much of it was financed by the American taxpayer?
[…] The Biggest Risk Factor Leading to Premature Death Is…? (danieljmitchell.wordpress.com) […]
I don’t know the numbers but surely the biggest EXCUSE for killing other people (whether by government or others) is religion. Think back in history with Christ himself being an early victim, then the middle-age crusades right through to the present day when we see (for example) Sunnis killing Shias and vice-versa.