I’m in Vienna, Austria, for the annual European Resource Bank meeting.
I had the pleasure last night of listening to Jose Pinera speak about economic reform in Chile, particularly the system of personal retirement accounts.
He shared a chart that conclusively shows why good economic policy makes a difference.
Wow. Look at how much faster the economy has grown since the communists were ousted in 1975 and replaced by a pro-market government.* And the poverty rate has plummeted from 50 percent to 11 percent!
Simply stated, economic reform has been hugely beneficial to poor and middle-class people in Chile. Something to remember as we try to rein in the welfare state in America.
Let’s look at some more data. A couple of years ago, I shared this chart showing how Chile had out-paced Argentina and Venezuela. In other words, Chile’s performance is ultra-impressive, whether examined in isolation or in comparison with other nations in the region.
The reason for all this success is that Chile didn’t just reform its pension system. As you can see from this Economic Freedom of the World data, Chile has made improvements in virtually all areas of public policy.
The nationwide school choice system, for instance, is another example of very beneficial reform.
It’s not quite Hong Kong or Singapore, but Chile is definitely a huge success story.
*The Pinochet government that took power in the 1970s may have been pro-economic liberty, but it also was authoritarian. Fortunately, Chile made a successful and peaceful transition to democracy in the late 1980s and has generally continued on a pro-free market path.
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] I have a three-part series (here, here, and here) on how low-income people have been big winners as a result of Chile’s shift to free […]
[…] This should be an easy choice. The current constitution limits the power of government and has helped Chile become the Latin Tiger. Incomes have jumped and poverty has plummeted. […]
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] I have a three-part series (here, here, and here) on how low-income people have been big winners as a result of Chile’s shift to free […]
[…] Given that Chile’s free-market reforms have been especially beneficial to poor people (see here, here, here, and here), I wonder they understand how Boric’s election would threaten their […]
[…] Thanks to free-market reforms in the 1980s and 1990s, growth exploded, Chile became the Latin Tiger and poverty plummeted. […]
[…] I have a three-part series (here, here, and here) on how low-income people have been big winners as a result of Chile’s shift to free […]
[…] I have a three-part series (here, here, and here) on how low-income people have been big winners as a result of Chile’s shift to free […]
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] free markets, which began in the mid-1970s, was especially beneficial for the less fortunate (see here, here, and […]
[…] voters put the nation’s prosperity at risk – One of the world’s biggest success stories during my lifetime has been Chile’s shift from authoritarian statism to capitalist […]
[…] least if they care about good results, especially for those with lower […]
[…] the way, I have several columns (here, here, here, and here) documenting how poor people have been the big winners from […]
[…] the way, I have several columns (here, here, here, and here) documenting how poor people have been the big winners from Chile’s […]
[…] I’ve explained on many occasions that lower-income people in Chile have been the biggest beneficiaries of pro-market […]
[…] I visited Chile about a year ago and finished a three-part series (here, here, and here) showing how the less fortunate have been the biggest […]
[…] Income has soared and poverty has plummeted thanks to market-based reforms. […]
[…] in 2013, I shared some of Jose’s data showing how the economy took off after Chile enacted pro-market […]
[…] Sounds like Guedes has the right ideas. Assuming Bolsonaro does what is right for his country (such as much-needed pension reform), Guedes could be the Jose Pinera of Brazil. […]
[…] if we go to the other side of the Andes Mountains, we find some good news in […]
[…] which country offers more opportunity, especially for the poor? The obvious answer is Chile, where poverty has rapidly declined ever since the country shifted to free enterprise. In Venezuela, by contrast, poor children die of […]
[…] however, may be an exception to that unfortunate pattern. It has enjoyed amazing levels of growth since a shift to free-market policies starting about 40 years ago. It is now the richest country in […]
[…] she repeats the crazy assertion that Chile’s shift to free markets backfired, even though the economy boomed and subsequent governments dominated by Social Democrats have left the reforms in […]
[…] out that Hong Kong and Singapore both score highly for rule of law and small government. And Chile deserves honorable mention as well. For what it’s worth, the Princess of the Levant’s home country of Lebanon […]
[…] the other side of South America, Chile has enjoyed comparatively strong growth since reforms began in the […]
[…] Chile deserves special attention since it is the highest-ranked nation from its region and also the highest-ranked nation from what is considered to be the developing world. Estonia also deserves plaudits for being the highest-ranked nation to emerge from the former Soviet Empire. […]
[…] Chile deserves special attention since it is the highest-ranked nation from its region and also the highest-ranked nation from what is considered to be the developing world. Estonia also deserves plaudits for being the highest-ranked nation to emerge from the former Soviet Empire. […]
[…] in the 1980s and 1990s liberalized the nation’s economy and resulted in rapid increases in economic growth and big reductions in […]
[…] The Chilean Miracle Shows that Economic Liberty is the Best Way of Helping Ordinary People […]
[…] Second, I made the argument for entitlement reform, specifically the “pre-funding” version of Social Security reform that’s been adopted in nations as diverse as Australia and Chile. […]
[…] P.D. Si quiere otro ejemplo de cómo el crecimiento a largo plazo cambia las cosas, eche un vistazo a esta tabla de comparación de Chile, Argentina y Venezuela. No sólo Chile ha superado a las otras naciones gracias a las reformas favorables al mercado, sino que la tasa de pobreza se ha reducido drásticamente. […]
[…] P.S. If you want another example of how long-run growth makes a big difference, check out this chart comparing Chile, Argentina, and Venezuela. Not only has Chile overtaken the other nation thanks to pro-market reforms, but the poverty rate has fallen dramatically. […]
[…] P.S. If you want another example of how long-run growth makes a big difference, check out this chart comparing Chile, Argentina, and Venezuela. Not only has Chile overtaken the other nation thanks to pro-market reforms, but the poverty rate has fallen dramatically. […]
[…] P.S. If you want another example of how long-run growth makes a big difference, check out this chart comparing Chile, Argentina, and Venezuela. Not only has Chile overtaken the other nation thanks to pro-market reforms, but the poverty rate has fallen dramatically. […]
[…] P.S. If you want another example of how long-run growth makes a big difference, check out this chart comparing Chile, Argentina, and Venezuela. Not only has Chile overtaken the other nation thanks to pro-market reforms, but the poverty rate has fallen dramatically. […]
[…] A sua inclusão no “clube dos países ricos” demonstra, no entanto, que existe saída. E o melhor de tudo, não é preciso fazer mágica e nem tentar reinventar a roda. A fórmula está aí: quanto menos interferência governamental nas vidas e nos negócios das pessoas, mais prosperidade. O caminho da liberdade econômica levou o Chile a um desenvolvimento institucional, social e econômico sem precedentes na região. […]
This is not strictly true because the communist system was apply just for one government.
[…] Second, I made the argument for entitlement reform, specifically the “pre-funding” version of Social Security reform that’s been adopted in nations as diverse as Australia and Chile. […]
[…] Second, I made the argument for entitlement reform, specifically the “pre-funding” version of Social Security reform that’s been adopted in nations as diverse as Australia and Chile. […]
[…] opinion polls. And with the very good results we’re seeing from nations such as Australia and Chile, I’m cautiously optimistic that reform can happen in […]
[…] The Chilean Miracle Shows that Economic Liberty is the Best Way of Helping Ordinary People […]
It’s amazing how most mainstream economists downplay the success of Chile post 1975, and do not attribute the success – they don’t want to acknowledge – to Pinochet. Many a times while discussing Latin America they skip delving on how Chile got moving, and their stand would be like.. “Chile is an exception, isn’t useful comparing it to other LA countries”. And other times, they would pick and nit pick details, statistics interpreted at their discretion, and then try to prove that it was not Pinochet’s measures which bore fruit, or that it were some of Pinochet’s non-pro market reform measures that aided the growth…
Also, about Pinochet government using authoritarianism to help implement pro-market reforms. Given the entrenched interests in the system, especially labor unionism, I wonder if it were possible to bring about labor market restructuring without a heavy hand as in the times of dictatorship. I think authoritarianism entailed here served a much-needed purpose in the face of militant resistance from entrenched forces.
Then this dictatorship led to a successful democracy because economic freedom is most naturally compatible with other freedoms protected in (non-authoritarian regimes such as..) democracy.
Between, I think that even Chile is too much dependent on factor endowments (like other LA countries) which are not as capital and skill intensive. This may prove to be a bane in some respects in long run. So they should try to build comparative advantage in manufactures (along global production networks, if possible) as well.
Dear Gentleman…with all the respect to your opinions and concepts, precisely those “Chicago Boys” were responsable by the largest massive rallies that accompanied the downfall of the Pinochet dictatorship in the late 1980s, due to an economic crisis named “deflation”, probably your Chileno’s business friends were the classic entrepreneurs that loved had ties with dictators due to cronyism and favoritism (the only that win are the business that are “friendly” to the tyranny). The Free Market System in all history of the world never can be compatible with a criminal tyranny. You don’t have to be a sociopath, criminal and THIEF to bring a real “Free Market System” to the society.
I take your point but Pinochet brought in the Chicago School as advisors and moved the country away from communism. If you view all countries as prisons then Pinochet was a better prison warden than Allende and thus Chile is a better country today because it moved toward a free market economy and away from communism. I am told by my Chileno business friends that it was the Pinochet government that decided on Chile’s entry into the wine industry because Chileno business could not agree. This has been a successful venture for the economy of Chile. Chile was also one of the first countries in the world to have a free market in telecommunications which helped to make it world class – that is what brought me to Chile, to start a telecom venture with Chileno and UK businesses.
Some people believe that thanks to “Pinochet” Chile now is an excellent country with a real “free market” and the most prosperous economy in Latin America and maybe very soon in all of America (North & South), is NOT thanks to the fascist Augusto Pinochet that was a sociopath, criminal and thief…everything is thanks to the Free Market System that started to make their job after Pinochet transfered power to a democratically elected president in 1990. The Free Market System needed 23 years to do their some people name “Economic Miracle” (I don’t believe in miracles) and now Chile enjoy the most highest quality of life indexes in Latin America and now is the easiest country in the world to incorporate a new business. Costs = zero, with an online set up registration option, and a time frame of a single day. Viva the Free Market System! Get out of Fascism (torturers and murderers)!
yes, torturers, murderers,destroyers of property and thieves, statists are a criminal gang
When you say authoritarian you mean torturers and murderers, right??/
Contrary to the socialist-communist propaganda Chile was fortunate in having Pinochet since as pointed out he was pro-market. This is often lost in the media discussion about Pinochet as are the totalitarian policies of Allende, his communist predecessor. Allende set about policies which destroyed the Chileno middle class and as a result did little to help the poor. The other thing Pinochet did was remove much of the police and political corruption – those caught engaging in corruption were summarily dismissed from their positions. Many of Pinochet’s economic advisors were from the pro-market Chicago School. Today Chile is the premier country in Latin America and thanks to the price of copper one of the wealthiest.
The proof of the pudding is always in the eating…compare Pinochet, the Argentine Junta and Chavez….all were authoritarian, but only one was pro-market and made real movement towards economic liberty for the average man.
Excellent post here. I was fortunate to visit Chile twice in the mid 1990’s and saw first hand the young capitalistic country growing. I wrote a blod post similar to this last year comparing Chile’s GDP growth vs. the US growth and you may find that interesting as well.
http://cosmoscon.com/2012/09/28/obamanomics-recovery-compared-to-a-free-market-recovery/
Reblogged this on Public Secrets and commented:
But try to explain to progressives that privatized Social Security accounts, school choice, and other free market are empirically far better for the average citizen than statist solutions, and they’ll look at you as if you’re at best mad and, more likely, downright evil.