Being a libertarian, I’m used to disappointment. So when something actually goes according to plan, I get very happy.
On that basis, I should be utterly and deliriously overjoyed about my endorsement of Francois Hollande to be President of France. I wanted him to win, in part because he would engage in statist experiments that would help discredit bad policy.
Well, all my dreams are being fulfilled. Here’s some of a new report in the Wall Street Journal.
French Socialist President François Hollande is set to increase the minimum wage by more than inflation, betting consumers will help revive the country’s stalling economy, while his government levies more taxes on the wealthy and large corporations in a bid to reduce the budget deficit. …The government also is preparing to unveil tax increases to make good on its pledge to reduce the budget deficit to 4.5% of yearly output this year and 3% in 2013. The list includes a new tax on dividends, a new top income-tax bracket of 75% for people earning more than €1 million a year, and increases in the wealth and inheritance taxes.
It’s not terribly surprising that Hollande’s going the fully Monty with higher taxes. Indeed, I’ve already mocked those plans.
But I’m surprised that he’s pushing a higher minimum wage as well, particularly with unemployment already at high levels. This video explains why minimum wages undermine job creation and hurt the less fortunate, but Hollande apparently thinks his plan will stimulate growth.
Other European nations have become more rational and now understand that labor markets need to be more flexible.
The Smic increase and the fiscal plan are in line with Mr. Hollande’s election promises but position France at odds with most other euro-zone nations, which are seeking to keep a lid on labor costs to improve their competitiveness and rein in their budget deficits through spending cuts rather than tax increases.
The comment about “spending cuts” is nonsensical, however. Even though traditionally left-leaning organizations such as the World Bank have concluded that government is far too big in Europe, most governments have imposed huge tax increases. Only the Baltic nations have focused on spending cuts.
As such, we can expect more news like this in France.
In France, economic growth has evaporated, with national statistical office Insee forecasting a further rise in the jobless rate, from 10%. Flag carrier Air France last week said it needs to shed more than 5,000 jobs, around 10% of its workforce, by the end of next year.
The nation’s dwindling productive class, meanwhile, will get even smaller since we’re already seeing evidence that investors and entrepreneurs are going to escape to other nations with less punitive tax regimes.
I joked last month that Obama would never be able to make America as socialist as France, and Hollande is confirming that tongue-in-cheek prediction with his crazy policies.
But I should state that I don’t actually want the French people to suffer. But if they elect bad people who impose bad policy, then I want to make lemonade out of lemons and at least help the rest of the world learn from their mistakes.
As my friend (and soon-to-be American citizen) Veronique de Rugy explained in a video, we don’t want America to become more like France.
[…] various points, I’ve also expressed pessimism about the future of France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Ireland, and even the United […]
[…] various points, I’ve also expressed pessimism about the future of France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Ireland, and even the United […]
[…] should have been a black mark. Hollande was the socialist who imposed confiscatory tax rates (resulting in effective tax rates above 100 percent for thousands of people) and drove […]
[…] a big smile on my face because Francois Hollande’s class-warfare tax policy in France is a bigger failure than even I predicted it would […]
[…] has been moving in the right direction). The French, for instance, are increasingly infamous for class-warfare tax policy and onerous levels of […]
[…] various points, I’ve also expressed pessimism about the future of France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Ireland, and even the United […]
[…] various points, I’ve also expressed pessimism about the future of France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Ireland, and even the United […]
[…] has been moving in the right direction). The French, for instance, are increasingly infamous for class-warfare tax policy and onerous levels of […]
[…] Hollande is also boosting the minimum wage, so I guess it will also be patriotic to be […]
[…] But then why aren’t the French famous for humor considering they’ve had to deal with Sarkozy and Hollande? […]
[…] has been moving in the right direction). The French, for instance, are increasingly infamous for class-warfare tax policy and onerous levels of […]
[…] various points, I’ve also expressed pessimism about the future of France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Ireland, and even the United […]
[…] Instead, I’m hoping the American people will learn an important long-run lesson: If you want more growth and prosperity, the recipe is smaller government and free markets. In other words, our economic policy should be more like Hong Kong and Singapore, but the Obama administration has been making us more like France. […]
[…] our economic policy should be more like Hong Kong and Singapore, but Obama has been making us more like France. Rate this:Share this:PrintEmailFacebookTwitterMoredeliciousDiggFarkLinkedInRedditStumbleUponLike […]
[…] desperately hope the government will reconsider this dangerous step. The world already has lots of examples of nations that are following bad policy. We need a few places that are at least being […]
[…] desperately hope the government will reconsider this dangerous step. The world already has lots of examples of nations that are following bad policy. We need a few places that are at least being […]
[…] “tax haven” debate is that groups like the Tax Justice Network are closely allied with governments in left-wing nations such as France, and they share the same goals as statist international bureaucracies such as the Paris-based […]
[…] “tax haven” debate is that groups like the Tax Justice Network are closely allied with governments in left-wing nations such as France, and they share the same goals as statist international bureaucracies such as the Paris-based […]
[…] blog is called International Liberty is that the world is a laboratory, with some nations (such as France) showing why statism is a mistake, other jurisdictions (such as Hong Kong) showing that freedom is […]
[…] blog is called International Liberty is that the world is a laboratory, with some nations (such as France) showing why statism is a mistake, other jurisdictions (such as Hong Kong) showing that freedom is […]
[…] The Crazy French Double Down on Obamanomics « International Liberty. Share this:TwitterRedditFacebookEmailPrintDiggStumbleUponLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. […]
[…] Mitchell: The Crazy French Double Down on Obamanomics – Being a libertarian, I’m used to disappointment. So when something actually goes […]
Dan: I saw this, remembered our last conversation and thought you’d be pretty pleased. Quite frankly, between the CA tax increase on the ballot, the French tax hikes there will be some interesting natural experiments. I pick sad times ahead for the French. good seeing you. rea