The fiscal turmoil in Greece is not about fiscal balance. It’s a fight between looters and moochers such as Olga Stefou, who think taxpayers should endlessly subsidize everything, and the shrinking group of productive people who are pulling the wagon and keeping Greece’s economy from total collapse.
Not surprisingly, the Greek government has tried to prop up its uncompetitive welfare state by pillaging that group of productive people. But it appears that the kleptocrats may have gone too far and triggered a Tea Party-type revolt.
Here are some excerpts from a remarkable story about a Greek tax revolt from Der Spiegel in Germany.
Belitsakos is…the physical and spiritual leader of a movement of businesspeople in Greece that is recruiting new members with growing speed. While Greece’s government is desperately trying to combat its ballooning budget deficit by raising taxes and imposing new fees, people like Belitsakos are putting their faith in passive resistance. The group’s slogan is as simple as it is stoic: “We Won’t Pay.” This business owners’ absolute refusal to pay any taxes resembles an uprising of the ownership class, rather than the working class, a rebellion of the self-employed business owners who have long been the backbone of Greek society. These are not the people who weaseled their way into Greece’s oversized civil service; these are people who put their money in the private sector, working 12-hour days, seven days a week. …”The state will kill us,” he says. “We’re acting in self-defense.”
In other words, these are the good guys. And look what they have to deal with.
Then he starts to do the math. Over the last two years, his sales have massively shrunk as 60 of the tavernas and restaurants he used to make deliveries to have terminated their contracts with him. At the same time, the government has raised the value-added tax (VAT) twice while imposing a never-ending series of new fees. He mentions the €300 ($406) one-time fee for the self-employed, a two-percentage-point boost in the VAT, a €180 solidarity levy for the unemployed and a property tax that is “easily a few hundred euros every year.” …Belitsakos calls them “charatzi,” a word from Ottoman times that can perhaps best be translated as “loot” or “compulsory levy.” The term is meant to indicate taxes levied arbitrarily and without justification, such as the tithe once paid to feudal lords.
This doesn’t mean that anyone who refuses to pay tax is automatically a hero. Some of the moochers and looters that have destroyed Greece think they should rape and pillage others and not pay taxes themselves.
These days, even communists, unionists and leftists are raising a public outcry against the new taxes. This week, Aleka Papariga, the general secretary of the Communist Party of Greece, said that the only way to stop the complete bankrupting of the people was for them to not pay the “charatzi.”
The UK-based Financial Times, in a story on the likelihood of a Greek default, also finds anger among the nation’s productive class.
The frustration is evident even among those who have jobs. George, a 49-year-old real estate agent, said despite a pledge to cut 30,000 public service jobs, the austerity policies of the government still appeared intent on protecting the interests of civil servants and state employees in general at the expense of the private sector. “Everything from water to electricity and telephony charges has gone up because of the increase in VAT [value added tax],” he said. And a new special property tax meant he would be hit yet again. In an increasing sign more and more people are getting upset with the political system and taxes, Andreas P, a 54-year-old clerk at a big Greek supermarket chain, is vowing to refuse to pay the new special property tax in protest at what he sees as an explosion of public service workers. “My father had a [café] in our village near Lamia [central Greece] back in 1980 and knew that just four out of the 400 inhabitants were state employees,” he says. “When I visited my village in August, I tried to count by curiosity how many were employed in some form in the public sector. I found out that more than 200 were working there. Is it ever possible for a country to prosper with so many state employees who do not produce? Can you give me a good reason to pay the extra taxes?”
These two stories underscore the message that I’ve been repeating for years. Greece’s problem is not deficits and debt. Red ink and imminent default are bad, but they are symptoms of the real problem of a bloated public sector and the dependency culture created by too much government.
This video explains why the burden of government spending is the critical fiscal policy variable.
And it goes without saying that America faces the same challenge. The only difference is that we have a few years to solve the problem before we have our own Greek-style fiscal crisis.
[…] building support for tax relief, find an entrepreneur who is being driven into the ground by capricious and excessive […]
[…] building support for tax relief, find an entrepreneur who is being driven into the ground by capricious and excessive […]
[…] la Grèce pourrait essayer d’inverser les augmentations de taxes et impôts qu’elle a lancées ces dernières années, et qui étouffent […]
[…] Greece also should try to reverse some of the economy-stifling tax increases that have been imposed in recent […]
[…] companies, Italian boat owners, Spanish movie patrons (and porn aficionados), California citizens, Greek shop owners, Facebook millionaires, Norwegian butter buyers, New York taxpayers, Bulgarian smokers, foreign cab […]
[…] boat owners, Spanish movie patrons (and porn aficionados), California citizens, Greek shop owners, Facebook millionaires, Norwegian butter buyers, New York taxpayers, Bulgarian […]
[…] is a long-overdue revolt of the Greek tax […]
[…] from 124 billion euro in 2009 to 106 billion euro last year. Unfortunately, there have also been big tax hikes, and the overall level of spending is still about where it was in 2007, so Greece is far from a […]
[…] from 124 billion euro in 2009 to 106 billion euro last year. Unfortunately, there have also been big tax hikes, and the overall level of spending is still about where it was in 2007, so Greece is far from a […]
[…] maybe there is hope for Greece. Some people (perhaps like the long-suffering tax slaves I wrote about two years ago) are fed up with overpaid government […]
[…] that we haven’t seen much – if any – growth in tax-happy nations such as Greece, Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Spain, and the United […]
[…] doute des hypocrites, et je ne serais pas choqué de savoir que leurs compatriotes irlandais ou grecs protestent pour les même […]
[…] doute des hypocrites, et je ne serais pas choqué de savoir que leurs compatriotes irlandais ou grecs protestent pour les même […]
[…] they’re probably hypocrites, and I wouldn’t be shocked to learn that their Irish and Greek compatriots also are protesting for the wrong […]
[…] wrote last year about a backlash from long-suffering Greek taxpayers. These people – the ones pulling the wagon rather than riding in the wagon – are being raped […]
[…] I wrote last year about a tax protest in Ireland, and I wrote earlier this year about a tax revolt in Greece. […]
[…] wrote last year about a backlash from long-suffering Greek taxpayers. These people – the ones pulling the wagon rather than riding in the wagon – are being […]
[…] wrote last year about a backlash from long-suffering Greek taxpayers. These people – the ones pulling the wagon rather than riding in the wagon – are being raped […]
[…] […]
[…] wrote last year about a backlash from long-suffering Greek taxpayers. These people – the ones pulling the wagon rather than riding in the wagon – are being […]
“Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting what to have for lunch” and Liberty is when the lamb has a rifle. Final vote on lunch: Grass, by a margin of 1-0, with two abstentions.
A tax revolt in a nation of tax cheats might be a pretty poor rifle, but it might work. Greek socialism will continue until it runs out of money, and socialists always (eventually) run out of other people’s money.
The Greek economy ($318 Billion) is smaller than Washington State’s economy ($350 B) and larger than Maryland’s ($300 B).
Greece needs to cut gov spending by at least 50% to have a chance to survive long term. But they currently have so many paople getting money from gov that it might be impossible to ever get a majority to do that.
This is the fundamental flaw of one man one vote democracy, once moochers outnumber producers the society enters a self reinforcing death spiral toward bankruptcy.
One possible solution is to give each person a number of votes proportional to the total taxes they pay. This would include all taxes, sales, payroll, and income taxes.
The tyrannical Soviet Union crashed when the Russian people found that because nobody worked to produce anything, they did not have enough to eat. From where within a nation comes the grit and determination to be free? Are pride and self-reliance lost forever? Or are they defining characteristics of human nature?
Maybe democracy cannot work, since parasites always outnumber producers. So what is the alternative? Aristocracy, pompous asses blowing entitlement smoke, is not the answer. Fundamentally, I think, the only hope is honest public education. Informed people, as Burke said, will not be argued into slavery.
I don’t see how 20% of the producers in Greece can overcome the 80% government parasites? The PIIGS of “Europe” are going to implode in the next year.
Unless the USA gets rid of the Marxist-Socialists in the WH and Congress, we are going down the same road. Fortunately, we still have more productive people than Government leeches, but the gap is closing.
Devolve the USA Federal Government NOW and our Nation can be saved. It is time to return to a Constitutional Federal Government and turn our ship of state around. It will take 10 years but we CAN do it.
Of course, if we continue to produce “uneducated drone” in our schools and colleges it will slow us down. Wake up, America.
[…] Dan Mitchell of International Liberty writes in The Tea Party Goes Global: The Revolt of the Greek Tax Slaves: The fiscal turmoil in Greece is not about fiscal balance. It’s a fight between looters and moochers such as Olga Stefou, who think taxpayers should endlessly subsidize everything, and the shrinking group of productive people who are pulling the wagon and keeping Greece’s economy from total collapse. Not surprisingly, the Greek government has tried to prop up its uncompetitive welfare state by pillaging that group of productive people. But it appears that the kleptocrats may have gone too far and triggered a Tea Party-type revolt. . . . These two stories underscore the message that I’ve been repeating for years. Greece’s problem is not deficits and debt. Red ink and imminent default are bad, but they are symptoms of the real problem of a bloated public sector and the dependency culture created by too much government. […]
If that 20% decides they have nothing to work for, they will join the 80%, and the wheels will come off the country.,
[…] of the Greek tax slaves. Don’t think this couldn’t happen […]
[…] TIP: Dan Mitchell Share this:TwitterFacebookEmailLike this:LikeBe the first to like this […]
[…] theoretically infinite power of the state to tax is found to have an extremely practical limit. People do change their behavior. And many revolutions were driven by what was at their core, tax […]
[…] The Tea Party Goes Global: The Revolt of the Greek Tax Slaves […]
I would be cautious about celebrating Greek tax protesters. Tea Partiers do not believe they have a God-given right to flagrantly cheat on their taxes yet still retire at age 50 sponging off society for the next 40 years. I expect all of these Greek heroes believe exactly that. I expect every one of them demands a European welfare paradise. They’re just unhappy they can’t get away with cheating on taxes as much as the other guy can.
[…] The Revolt of the Greek Tax Slaves […]
Europe is sliding into a dark age.
OBJECTIVIST,… In Greece, like many other parts of the world, a non trivial proportion of pubic employees not only produces little or nothing, but actually fulfils the function of hindering the remainder of their co-patriots from producing. Entire departments have been created and staffed b public employees, whose net function is “making a living” by introducing obstacles to those who want to produce and prosper.
Sorry, I have lived in Europe — including Greece — and I can assure you that there will be no tax revolt — at least not one leading to any meaningful retreat from mandatory collectivism and certain economic extinction.
Rational arguments of sustained longer term prosperity and elementary arithmetic are futile against the immediate, visible, myopic, and seductive benefits of redistribution.
So good luck to the Greek 20% productive minority against an 80% majority — which believes that reducing incentives to produce through the welfare state, can somehow be compensated by the efficiencies (lol) of central planning and lead to worldwide competitiveness and prosperity.
I often read that “Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting what to have for lunch”. But perhaps a more accurate description — from Greece’s Aesop’s fables — is “Eight grasshoppers and two ants voting whose stored up grains will be used to make dinner”.
There is no hope for Greek society for at least two generations. The voters are steeped in a suicidal philosophy of redistribution and central planning. Greeks are past the event horizon on their way to decline. They will limp along through minor bankruptcies, some reforms, and some wealth transfers from the ever decreasing number of ambitious people left in Europe. Then, the moment some minor reforms are made and anemic 1-2% growth returns (still certain path to economic extinction in a world riding a 4-5% average growth trendline) the mentality of living through other people’s productivity and the (lol) efficiency of central planning will predictably return.
The only language that the Greek majority will understand is the reality of emigration.
And BTW, this is why the American People who (in one of their grandest deviations from the American Spirit of individual freedom – reminiscent of repugnant authoritarian regimes) have myopically tried to seal the emigration exit, are increasing their chance of a more violent final implosion.
https://danieljmitchell.wordpress.com/2010/04/11/europe-should-not-copy-americas-imperialist-and-anti-growth-worldwide-tax-regime/
(…can’t find that post on Soviet Union, Nazi Germany and today’s America “exit taxes”)
Trying to counter deep policy fundamentals of decreasing competitiveness by merely plugging the exits is only a recipe for a more violent implosion.
Time for Americans to change their W-4’s to “exempt from withholding.”
I’m thrilled at the prospect of watching a modern, western democracy come apart at the seams, reneg on the endless benefits the government union / crony capitalist / welfare class have bestowed upon themselves and find their way to a new government founded in not being the tax slaves of the powerful entrenched interests.
Payback is coming for those who deserve it.
The public employees are paid with tax revenue and therefore raise taxes. Perhaps just as bad, they produce nothing of value. This is the other half of the buyer seller exchange failure. The looter and moocher language comes from Ayn Rand. Time to read her to understand how the looters got the producers to pay for their free ride so long. Atlas Shrugged is about the sanction of the victim–the producer.
[…] MITCHELL: The Tea Party Goes Global: Revolt Of The Greek Tax Slaves. “The fiscal turmoil in Greece is not about fiscal balance. It’s a fight between looters and […]