This great cartoon I saw at The Corner is a very good summary of what the public-sector “collective bargaining” issue is all about.
In private sector labor disputes, unions and management both have ample incentives to protect their respective interests.
With government labor negotiations, by contrast, that natural system of checks and balances doesn’t exist. There’s no strong incentive for politicians to be frugal stewards of taxpayer money – particularly when they negotiate very expensive fringe benefits that defer costs to future years.
Indeed, because government employee unions tend to be very politically active, often being huge contributors to political campaigns, politicians often have a strong incentive to be profligate with taxpayer money.
[…] It’s possible to reform labor laws so teachers don’t have out-sized influence. That sort of happened in Wisconsin under Governor Scott Walker. […]
[…] It’s possible to reform labor laws so teachers don’t have out-sized influence. That sort of happened in Wisconsin under Governor Scott Walker. […]
[…] is why this cartoon is the best summary of “negotiations” between politicians and union bosses, and this video is damning proof that […]
[…] For the simple reason – as illustrated by the cartoon – that politicians are bureaucrats tend to be on the same side with negotiating new […]
[…] Except it wasn’t really a surrender since she was already on their side (as perfectly captured by this Ramirez cartoon). […]
[…] as Michael Ramirez illustrated, bureaucrat unions give lots of money to state and local politicians, and those politicians then […]
[…] I now think I overlooked his true masterpiece, at least if salience is an issue. The cartoon he produced on politicians and bureaucrat unions perfectly identifies the problem that has produced gaping […]
[…] un premio a la viñeta política más deprimentemente precisa, también ganaría el premio por su imagen de lo que ocurre cuando los políticos estatales y locales “negocian” los paquetes de […]
[…] was a prize for the most depressingly accurate political cartoon, he also would win the prize for his depiction of what happens when state and local politicians “negotiate” compensation packages for […]
[…] if you really want to understand the story behind the story, the real problem is that the unions representing government employee unions give a lot of money to politicians. […]
[…] found a good one-liner from Craig Ferguson, along with some political cartoons from Michael Ramirez, Henry Payne, and Sean […]
[…] I also found a good one-liner from Craig Ferguson, along with some political cartoons from Michael Ramirez, Henry Payne, and Sean […]
[…] But this is why I wrote earlier this month that “there needs to be a much tougher approach when contract negotiations take place.” Simply stated, politicians like to curry votes from powerful interest groups, so contract negotiations between governments and government unions generally are a sham. All too often, the politicians and unions conspire against taxpayers. […]
[…] illustrated by this superb cartoon by Michael […]
[…] also a good one-liner from Craig Ferguson, along with some political cartoons from Michael Ramirez, Henry Payne, and Sean […]
[…] also a good one-liner from Craig Ferguson, along with some political cartoons from Michael Ramirez, Henry Payne, and Sean […]
[…] If you want to enjoy bureaucrat humor, click here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and […]
[…] This Michael Ramirez cartoon shows how taxpayers get squeezed when politicians and bureaucrats negotiate. […]
[…] is why this cartoon is the best summary of “negotiations” between politicians and union bosses, and this video is damning proof that […]
Put into words it’s so hard to understand
But now I understand perfectly
[…] And I’m definitely opposed to the excessive pay and benefits that politicians grant to bureaucrats in exchange for votes and money from government employee unions (as cleverly depicted in this great Michael Ramirez cartoon). […]
[…] is why this cartoon is the best summary of “negotiations” between politicians and union bosses, and this video is damning proof […]
[…] for the best political cartoon about what’s been happening in Wisconsin, I would pick either this “fake negotiation” cartoon by Ramirez or this “coach class” cartoon by […]
[…] mentioned above are extreme examples, but they help underscore the problem that exists when politicians and bureaucrat unions make insider deals, swapping political support for lavish compensation […]
You can replace “Unions” with all sorts of things to make this work in other circumstances:
Our Founding Fathers may have used “Religion” and label the guy in the middle “Freedom.”
You could use “Business” and “Consumers.”
Or maybe, “Security” and “The Constitution.”
It is interesting that the Unions and Politicians are depicted as shaking left hands.